Is this skinnyness level still hot? Or is it too skinny?

[Anonymous]

I'm trying to get down to a bmi of 16-17 (i know it's a bit underweight, don't really care) because i find most girl's with bodies at that point to look perfect and i want to look like that. I know that i'm probably going to lose hotness points because it's pretty skinny, and i don't care that much about that. But i'm still kinda curious what guy's think about that skinnyness level and i want to see if you think that's still doable sex/dating wise or even attractive maybe?

A few exemples of what i want to look like:

[Lliam]

Way too skinny. Actually grotesque. The ideal woman is supposed to be soft and curvy. Not the kind of curvy that is a modern euphemism for obese. Curvy in the classic sense - nice boobs, smoothly curving hips, round plump bottom, shapely legs with round thighs. Even her flat tummy should have a thin layer of fat. Think of the old Playboy models. Fit and thin, but lush in the right places.
Women have their feminine shapes because of healthy fat that comes on during puberty. A woman with a low bmi is unhealthy and looks unhealthy.

[Sensmind]

I am right on the verge here - I thought some of the pics are ok but right on the lower edge , do not lose anymore weight while I thought others were just too skinny for me - So overall I am probably slightly over the line of too skinny, I like skinny but not that skinny

[Asker]

Those aren't me :'( B tw which pics were too skinny for you?

[Sensmind]

I thought 1 and 3 were just a bit past comfort line for me

[KatherineJ]

If you are healthy then whatevs. It’s about being happy with you, not what anyone else thinks that matters.

[Kas19]

You're going to hate life when you get down to your desired weight. Welcome to the Ed community 👉👈

[HugoThe2nd]

I like skinny, but some of these are getting a little too skinny.
I have seen women with a BMI of 16.5 who looked normal and ate properly, but it comes down to your build and height.

I'd probably have to see it in order to okay it.

[MCheetah]

That's way too skinny for me.

[MrBadd]

No that's not hot at all. In general men tend to think men need to be about 15lbs heavier than they need to be, and women tend to think women need to be about 15lbs lighter than they need to be, in order to be attractive.

[Zzmaex]

That looks almost unhealthy, this isn’t an insult but are you actually okay?

[Jazzi02]

The ideal body I look for. Also what I try to achieve.

[NathanDavis]

The problem here is that, while some women are naturally very slim... you are actually trying to lose weight to look this slim, which probably requires for you to eat a lot less, or to exercise way too much, and this is going to affect your metabolism greatly, which is very unhealthy, and this won't be desirable nor attractive, this is going to be a major concern for everyone in your life.

[jshm2]

Sheesh! You need to be careful you don't fall through a drain grate in the pavement!

There are pencils with more meat and substance than you!

[sensible27]

Uhh.. no. It might be unhealthy.. i think the minimum healthy fat percentage in girls is somewhere around 13% below that it gets odd. It might even be the case that your body starts storing fat in reserves thinking you are not getting enough to eat.. so when you do eat, it stores.. (but not sure though..).

[Jenny4455]

Im close to being that skinny. Not all guys like it, but a lot do.

[0112358]

I like skinny girls. Some of these are too skinny. Last one especially.

I would also say that targeting a bm I won't make you look like people wise bodies naturally tend to that bmi. That's not how it works.

[humanearth]

Way too skinny, I like girls with some form of fat on them. I would not want to date a skelton

[Ripper_E]

It can be.

[Jesus_is_the_guey]

my opinion since that’s all these are when it comes to looks and is that’s far too skinny don’t kill yourself trying to be skinny unless you’re naturally like that then as the polls will undoubtedly show a lot of guys like that too

[Nik1hil]

What wouldn't I do! To be with a skinny girl like this one..
😍😍😍😍 I would hold her body and kiss her everywhere..

[chriscdi]

not in my opinion

[Browneye57]

Uh no. Not hot. At all. Sorry toots. EAT.

[Andres77]

You look hot but that level of skinny, I'd be afraid I'd break you

[Ironic_Method]

I like slim and petite and she looks good, but she's dangerously close to being too thin for my tastes.

[DaveToo]

Looks anorexic.

[Archerer]

I do think that is too skinny, I’d be worried it isn’t healthy. If you are healthy and you are that skinny then ok, no problem.