Girlfriend and I had a threesome (MMF) and it was awesome. Should I tell her I want to do this more often?

My girlfriend and I were talking about my doing something really kinky together and we both agreed we should try a threesome. We decided we would try an MMF threesome first then do an MFF next but I ended up enjoying the threesome with the other guy a lot more than I thought. We found him through a friend of my girlfriend who was interested. We all got tested and were clean so we didn’t use condoms which I don’t mind. We all had some drinks first so we were up for anything. We all got naked and he had an average size cock similar to mine so I was relieved. He said first he wanted to watch me fuck my girlfriend so I was happy to oblige and I fucked my girlfriend doggystyle in front of him but I did not finish. This is where things got a little weird. The other guy started fucking my girlfriend in front of me and started pounding her really hard, which made me uncomfortable at first and then she orgasmed really hard while he was taking her. She’s only done that like once with me. He stopped fucking her and then I went to get a drink of water. When I came back the two of them were talking with each other and she looked like she wanted to discuss something and she said that he wanted to fuck me and she wanted to watch. I was shocked but we were all drunk so I got on all fours and bent over in front of him. My girlfriend started lubing up my asshole for him to fuck and he entered me slowly and the feeling was incredible. I was actually proud that I could take it all in my ass. He started thrusting slowly at first then he sped up and started moaning as he was thrusting inside me faster and faster. He sounded like he was going to start cumming but wasn’t pulling out and then I felt something warm fill up my ass. I felt so self conscious after being used but it was a lot of fun. My question is that I really want to try this again but we were going to have another woman next time in our threesome. Should I tell my girlfriend I want another threesome with another guy?
Updates:
+1 y
My girlfriend and I talked it over this morning about what our next steps are. I told her I really enjoyed our last threesome and she agreed that the guy we got was really good. The next part was difficult to admit to her but I decided to tell her anyway that I really did enjoy getting fucked in the ass. I wasn’t sure if she just through I was moaning while getting fucked because I was drunk but I did really enjoy the feeling and he was hitting my prostate just right.
+1 y
She then said that she always wanted to see me lose my anal virginity like that and next time wants to record it. So we are looking forward to our next threesome with a guy. We’ll still try another woman but my girlfriend and I want to try it with a guy again.
0 3

Superb Opinion

  • I would try with another woman and then discuss with her what you liked more. Maybe if both were equally pleasurable you could try a foursome with another couple or two random people

Most Helpful Guy

  • Mate tell her i bet she would be very turned on about it. Enjoy it everytime you get to share each other as you learn more and more about eachother with nothing to hide

Most Helpful Girl

  • If you both had a great time, absolutely. Make sure y'all discuss. Glad you had fun.

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

1 7
  • Wow, that's really hot! I'm glad you were open to doing it. Question, if she asked you to suck his cock to completion, would you do it? If she wanted to see him suck you off, would you let him do it? I ask because I'm bi-curious. I have LOTS of fantasies about it.

    If you want to talk privately, feel free to write me directly at nothingtosee at yahoo dot com.

    • We did that a while ago with the same guy. She got really turned on watching me, especially since I was touching myself while going down on him. I didn’t realize I would get turned on from sucking him dry but I just started touching myself and we both came at the same time.

  • Welcome to the wonderful world of bisexuality! I did it with a couple 3 times. Him and I hooked up first while he was in town for work. But he only wanted to do hand jobs. He tried unsuccessfully to fuck me (not sure why, I know how to relax, so it's easy to get in me) and couldn't pull off riding me (I'm pretty thick). Then she came into town and we went at it for a couple of hours! I really surprised myself! You should also try letting her peg you. c Just try to be open to anything. You may find other things you really love!

    • That’s so hot. We did have a couple more threesomes after the first time with the same guy. Looking back the first couple of times, I was really self conscious about have him cum in my ass because the feeling was so foreign to me and I couldn’t believe I let another guy use me like that. But once my girlfriend told me how it turns her on to watch us have sex, I got less and less self conscious. We got a very realistic strapon after this where my girlfriend will peg me with it and jerk me off at the same time so this has really enhanced our sex lives.

    • Better yet, Get a guy to blow you while she pegs you.

    • And then have them switch places halfway through.

  • Yeah why not if you enjoyed it I would be open and just let her know you enjoyed it she probably liked it to watching

  • of course you should tell her

    • Yeah, we had a long talk about it. I did end up telling her.

    • yay congrats :)

  • Tell her... Even try with different men sometime

    • We did have him back over a couple times after and we did find another guy for another MMF several months later.

    • That's great.. now try to go outside in resort or tours.. ask her to date others. Try black men, they are huge and long

    • You can message me. So that I can provide you more ideas and my experience

  • Of course you should I love it too

    • You’ve had threesomes too?

    • yupp

    • Did you have one similar to the one I had? If so, please explain.

    • Show All
  • Do it boy! sounds like you loved it.

  • Well you should definitely tell her I think they're fun