Why did I queef so much with the guy I lost my virginity to?

[Anonymous]

It made me think I was loose, but his penis was around 5 or 5.5 inches and it wasn't thick or anything. Every time we had sex I was very wet so my vagina was more "opened up" I suppose, aroused.
But literally, EVERYTIME we had sex, as he'd thrust his penis would slip out and this would push air inside me and I'd queef, all the damn time. It made me start to think I was loose or something.

But then, recently I've got a new boyfriend. His penis is significantly bigger than the last guys, and it's thicker. We've tried to have sex once, but it hurt so bad and he couldn't actually get it inside me because it felt like it would rip my hole. But he says his penis isn't big, I think it's average or slightly above average, and maybe 2.5 fingers thick.
So judging by this, does it mean I'm not loose, and the first guy was just small and that's why I queefed all the time? Because I didn't queef when my latest boyfriend put the tip inside me, even that hurt. My vagina was sore for a few days after.
Thoughts?

[IDTBTD]

It's like an armpit or soapy hands if something's went and gets friction it's gonna make a noise

[Lyndsielee666]

Pulling out and paying it back in pushes air in your vagina. You answered your own question.

[realDonaldTrumpJr]

The average penis is 5.16 inches so it sounds like your last boyfriend was average.

[Abdulwahh]

Did the guy do foreplay

[Anonymous]

u have ur answer in the question