How big is your ideal penis size?

Length wise. and be honest.
1-4 inches.
Vote A
5-8 inches.
Vote B
9-12 inches.
Vote C
Hes a monster, might as well be in p*rn.
Vote D
Its not the size that matters, its how you use it.
Vote E
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Girl Guy
0 0

Most Helpful Guys

  • I would have to say I agree with many of the comments on here. 5-8 inches is what most guys would be. From most of the girls I have spoken to it is not the lenght that they really like but the thickness. No one is going to pick 1-4 inches and very few guys will be this small anyway so that wasn't really a good option either. It is also true more than anything that it is technique and ability to understand and care about how to please a woman that is the quality most women want and not size. I think most women are happy with an average length and a decent girth but would not insist upon either if they could get a guy who loved and respected them. The man with the largest penis in the world is a guy called Jonah from New York and he is 13 inches long so your 9-12 would also cover very few men either as it is not realistic and anything more would be impossible it seems. There are so many guys out there that claim to be 8 or 10 inches or whatever but seriously most are lying. If you get a ruler or tape measure you will realize just how big you are actually claiming to be and how embarrassing it will be for you if you do it to a girl you actually end up with. She will notice! I would say in the end anyway many guys worry and have an obsession with their size but most girls do not care either way. If it is normal and works and you care about her then that is all that matters!

  • I find mine at 8- 3/4" X 3-1/2" thick to be Ideal, I have been with a few that are fairly tight to my size but they always have an amazing orgasm from it. in part I have huge balls as my girl reminds me every time she tries to swallow all of me and laughs after wards that its like downing a huge vanilla shake. so B is my answer.

    • i call bullsh*t 3-1/2 inches think would make you the largest dude in the world, that would be something like 10 inch girth that would be larger then a one litter bottle

    • Actually, 10.99 inches to be exact :)

    • haahaahahaha this comment makes me laugh lol

    • Show All

Most Helpful Girls

  • Honestly, 5 Should Definitely Not be in the same category as a 7 or 8. How do you expect to get an accurate poll?

    Realistically, Who's Ideal would be 1-4?

    & How many Girls do you think would want a 9-12?

    So Let's say 90% of the Girls choose B Only because 7 fell in between 5-8 BUT their "Ideal" Would Never be a 5, a 51/2, or even a 6? Their "Ideal" Is a 7-7.5?

    As Chelsea1989 said 5-8 is a Huge difference. It's WAY TO GENERAL. I mean, Don't most guys fit between a 5-8?

    • im not asking for specific lengths just approximations that's why the answers were so broad, and apparently some girls do like the 9-12" range. p.s. have you ever asked a question with a poll ? it gives you a maximum of 5 choices

    • Where did I say that No Girl would want a 9-12? I Clearly Asked "How many Girls do you think would want a 9-12?" Either way you are missing my point. I know there are only 5 options. It's your poll, I just asked how you expect to get an accurate percentage when in option B (in my opinion) you include small with medium and large. That is all. That really didn't warrant a response, I wondered. Nothing to get hissy about.

    • wasnt getting hissy, I apologize if I came off that way, just saying

    • Show All
  • Eh, it's not a big deal really. I'd say 5 1/2-6 inches to around 8. It's more about girth than length anyway, and that varies hugely from girl woman to woman.

    Unless it's some truly magical perfect combination of length and girth, I'd say it's more important to know what you're doing with it (and the rest of your appendages) than how big it is.

  • I honestly think it's about how they use it. If a guy has the perfect d*** in your opinion, and he can't use it (aka, he sucks in bed), then what's the point? And what if the guy has a less than average d***, but he's simply amazing? Hence why I voted 'E'.

    Maybe I'm just biased because I don't enjoy sex...

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

4 4
  • Mine.

  • 4 inches is my preferred, my favourites are 1 inch to four inches. =] 5 and 6 inches are tolerable, anything bigger is aesthetically displeasing to me.

  • 6 inches.

  • lol@ the one guy who did 1-4 and lol@ the women with gaping wide vaginas who did 9-12.

    • Lol, that was me

    • lol oh you

  • 5-8 is a pretty huge difference, but yeah my ideal would be 7.5-8, that way it goes really deep, but still feels good rather then hurting

    • love a grl that appreciates a big d***

  • Like 8 inches and really thick, with a big head, big balls, and it should be straight, not curved. Also prefer black guys so yeah make it black.

  • For me 5 :) not to big not to small :)

  • 5-8 would be ideal