-Asians are actually the highest paid race -there are programs in place to get minorities jobs or into college simply for being a minority. Why don't they have to earn these accomplishments based off merit? Sounds like a privilege for them. -I'm white and from a low middle class family, we hardly have money to buy anything extra beyond the necessities. If this white privilege is a thing why does my family have to live paycheck to paycheck?
These are just a few points that show the whole white privilege argument is stupid.
even though Asians may be the highest paid race, they as well as other coloured radicalized groups in society don't get he recognition for their achievements like white privileged people do. The Asian as your example, would only get questioned or the black peoples success would also be questioned in society as "oh how did he end up doing that?" or "he is smart for a black man" where as whites don't get questioned on their success.
@Kkaos I didn't omit Asians from my statistics. This isn't about that, it's about the reasons there are disparities between races in the first place. My agenda has nothing to do with its existence because it's existence has already been proven time and time again, met with ridiculous opposition like "oh 8m white and I'm poor" or "I'm black and I'm rich" or "I'm Asian and I'm middle class" it doesn't matter because the socioeconomics behind favoritism in society is cemented in the demographics of our cities and states.
So prove it exists. You've posted bullshit about average incomes, yet I've already shut you down on that because white don't receive the highest income on average, so I want to see some real proof for you?
Does white privilege exist in only America, only in the western world, or the whole world?
@Kkaos it’s obviously predominantly in the western world. You think I’m China whites are that much more privileged? use you common sense. Part of white privilegeisnnot being aware it exists
@realistincanada Duh, of course they aren't. Ever heard of a rhetorical question? The fact you like to think of yourself as educated is simply hilarious. I'm still waiting for you to stump up with your own arguments rather than directing me towards your article because you're either too lazy or ignorant to provide your own material.
You did omit Asians though. You say there is white privilege, yet whites aren't even the most privileged based on the argument you are trying to present so you left them out. Also to say "I'm white and I'm poor" is a completely legit argument to white privilege. If you are going to say that an entire race of people are privileged shouldn't they all have some advantage compared the others? Me being white has not given me an advantage in anything my whole life (not that it should either). What rights do I as a white person have that other minorities dont? Having rights or advantages that others don't would be white privilege, but we dont. And like I mentioned above there are actually programs in place that hand minorities jobs or get them into schools simply for being non white. That's privilege. To say blacks and Hispanic heavy areas have more poverty on average is not an argument for saying an entire race is privileged when there are also many people in that race that live in poverty.
@Kkaos you dumb ass, I am using academic scholars to validate my argument. I didn’t create this research and if I didn’t use academic evidence to prove my argument, then my argument would not have any proof
@realistincanada Haha, I'm a dumbass am I? How cute. An insult from you is like an insult from a 3 year old child with down syndrome, it's meaningless but
Still waiting for you to stump up with your own valid arguments that are cited with evidence as well.
Taking Whites forcefully out of high-up positions and placing minorities into them?
Implementing a "white privilege" tax which takes money from rich white people and giving tax cuts to poor blacks and leaving the poor whites to starve whilst alienating the rich white class?
Increasing spending on welfare?
Genociding white people? <-- this seems like the solution many left-wing degenerates want.
@Goochbreaker I don't have the energy to report you. And I certainly don't have the energy to reply to you on every opinion. Have a nice day big funni man.
Basically that what leftists and other black supremacist groups such as BLM are asking. Whites must give everything they have and will have to blacks, and then slowly back off of any kind of power, and just become submissive little slaves.
None of these is really on the table. The solution is just to understand it and fix weak points such as refusing to hire people for not having white enough names. People don't want hand outs. People want to be able to reach equal ground. I read a research paper that stated it takes about 7 generations on average for a family to go from wealthy to poor or vice versa. Most black people work their buts off. They just want the same reward for the same amount of effort and the same ability to improve their lot in life. This cannot happen if people pretend there are no issues worth looking at. It's not just blacks. It's women, hispanics, Asians, etc. Minority executives in the U. S. are extremely low. 20 years ago there were only about 5 female executives. None were minorities. Ten years ago it was about 20. Now it is up to about 40, and minorities females are added in and finally being allowed to work their way to the top. Same issue with many leadership positions.
@wolfcat87 What a pile of complete and utter bullshit.
1. I don't know about companies only hiring people with white sounding names, if it does occur, it's definitely in secret. But what I know that does occur because it's said almost proudly and openly, is companies exclusively hiring non whites in order to improve 'diversity'. What do you have to say about that?
2. "takes about 7 generations on average for a family to go from wealthy " What a load of absolute shit. There are PLENTY of wealthy people, wealthy families who are self made millionaires, even billionaires. Nor does someone's wealth directly correspond to their race. They're are poor people and rich people in EVERY country.
3. " It's not just blacks. It's women, hispanics, Asians, etc" Funny how you mention Asians, did you even bother to check the damn statistics? Asians on average earn the highest in America. Yep, that's right, Asians who immigrate to America end up earning the most on average.
@Kkaos Actually, those companies are only required to hire to match the actual population distribution of the area they are in. Doe sit make sense for a company in a 99% black area to only have 99% white employees? No. Should their credentials matter? Yes.
It was in secret. It was only discovered when someone decided to do a study just to see what would happen. You can look it up.
Again, 7 generations to go up or down on AVERAGE. lol. Rarely do people go from the slums of Brazil to billionaire. BE real here. How often do people on welfare suddenly become millionaires? They generally don't. I the vast majority of cases it's a gradual process. 7 generations was the average. More clever or luck families would advance faster and less would advance more slowly.
... Do you realize that most Asians in the U. S. did not migrate to here? Asians have been here as long as anyone else. Immigrant children on average tend to earn more than the average American.
@Kkaos But, what does that have to do with whether or not they are given as many chances to promote to executive positions at work? If Asians are more likely to secure jobs in fields that pay more and do not ever advance, then of course they would earn more on average. That does not mean they are getting executive positions. Statistics do not really work the way you just used them. Yikes. If they are going into the same jobs and are promoted more to a point, then they'd earn more than those below them, but they may still be stunted in how far they can promote. Does that make sense?
@wolfcat87 Provide the statistics for the demographics of people who are ELIGIBLE for executive positions and then provide the demographics for those who are chosen. I'll be waiting.
@Kkaos You're funny. The only people eligible are the people promoted... If you cannot get promote due to color, then you can never be eligible for anything. Think about that. Also, if you are able to spend so much time arguing, learn to do your own homework. Show me the number of people how get promoted to each level and their colors. Degree rates by race are pretty caught up at this point, so if they do not match the local population distribution, they are indeed discriminating.
@wolfcat87 No; 'what does that have to do with whether or not they are given as many chances to promote to executive positions at work?' You've claimed white people are given an unfair advantage when it comes to promotion to executive roles, in order to prove that, you must provide the statistics of how many people were eligible, what their races were, what their credentials were and then prove that they were either chosen or not chosen based on their race and any racial privileges or lack thereof. Come on, you've made a claim here, I want to start seeing some evidence from you.
It has NOTHING to do with the local population distribution, as now you're bringing in people who were NEVER even in contention for these roles into the mix, they're irrelevant. I want to see the demographics of the people who were in contention for executive roles compared to the people who got the roles. Then and ONLY then can you start making judgments about any racial biases in the recruitment process.
Beautiful, rather than corporations being based on merit/meritocracy they introduce "diversity quotas" where they hire exclusively minorities or according to the "demographics of the area they live in"
I agree with all but one point: “I hate to break it to you, but the model white collar worker in the eyes of America, is a white man (or a white woman if we're being generous.)“
The model is white man not woman but the practice is woman in a lot of industries. There are more female doctors, lawyers basically anything other than STEM women are progressing in.
But yes it is very troubling to me the lack of African Americans in most white collar work places.
I worked at a large company that was always hiring and interviewing and saw many a black faces in the waiting room and their resume.
Never saw one hired despite credentials. Not for a white collar role. Only for support roles and even then it was rare. People assume black women will be sassy on the phone or have a bad attitude.
It very much exists. You are being ignorant. Only people such as yourself who have full advantage of it will not realize it. Many white people are aware of this privilege and they therefore understand that they have an advantage over coloured people, simply based on the colour of their skin , although not all white people can get the benefits.
White priv. is something that you are born with, because you inherit the privileges that are reproduced from generation to generation. read this for all you uneducated folks , pay attention to the list as well www.winnipeg.ca/.../white_privilege.pdf
@SketchForger There are rich people and there are poor people in every country. You've deliberately and falsely skewed your data in order to omit Asians who actually earn more than whites on average in the United States.
@realistincanada You're an adult, explain in your own words what I have asked... Or are you not educated enough to speak for yourself?
@Kkaos are you not educated enough to read an academic article? Read the article and learn. That is a University article that was written by scholars. Are you illiterate? do you need someone to come read it to you?
as I stated below, even though Asians may be the highest paid race, they as well as other coloured radicalized groups in society don't get he recognition for their achievements like white privileged people do. The Asian as your example, would only get questioned or the black peoples success would also be questioned in society as "oh how did he end up doing that?" or "he is smart for a black man" where as whites don't get questioned on their success.
@realistincanada You are delusional and playing the victim. Stop it. That is what is wrong with this country. WHITE PRIVILEGE IS A MYTH. Stop with the bull shit.
Lol, what university or college did you get an education at? University is where I got the information that actually confirmed that white privilege exists, there are several academic scholars who have researched this. Clearly you are uneducated and uninformed about hierarchy’s that are present in society? Or maybe you are one of the financially poor white people who do not have the benefits of white privilege? Read the academic article I pasted into this thread. Get educated, do you think this ‘white privilege’ concept was made up? And you think I’m playing victim? You must have barely graduated high school. This white privilege is very real and it’s very evident within western society. There are several university articles that I can prove that it exists with. Ask me for them. PSA kids pursue a university/college education. You don’t want to be embarrassingly uneducated like this illiterate 52 year old. The facts are in front of you. READ the link I provided
@realistincanada Come on, I want to start seeing proof from you. Indeed I've read and written many research pieces and part of making an argument is you writing your own material. I want to see clear and concise points from you that are backed up with exact references. Unless you can do that, what you say is baseless.
@realistincanada True liberal... name calling and all. LOL. You have it down pretty good... race card... playing the victim... I bet you get violent also when you are confronted in person. Most liberals do. lol
Regardless of me being a liberal or not is very irrelevant to this argument. You have no argument against my evidence and my points. Your only “point” that you addressed which is absolutely irrelevant was that I am playing a victim. Lol I expected much more from someone as old as you who should have knowledge on academic resources. And yes I do insult people such as yourself who are blind to the facts due to pure ignorance. you have no convincing arguments
How do I play the victim? Am I complaining about it? No, I’m just motivated to work even harder. I am an African American, living in Canada and I am striving to be successful no matter the barriers society places on me for being coloured, and regardless of the white privilege that racialised minority’s do not have access to
@realistincanada Tell me would you prefer to be in Liberia, there is no "white privilege" there, and it was never colonized, do you think you would be better off? Even before its civil wars it was doing badly even by African standards.
we are not privileged. i grew up everyday wondering if we would be eicted from our apartment. i guess im in the minority. if i wouldn't have been adopted i would have been in worst. we are in the same predicament as every ethnicity
@realistincanada Perhaps you should call it majority white privileged then. Of course if even one single white person does not have it it demonstrates that it is not something that we can inherit.
So you admit that not all white people are privileged, yet you defend the racist concept that whiteness implies privilege all the same? You basically destroyed your own theory right there. And then you say those who deny "white privilege" don't look very smart? Wow, get a clue, my man.
There's no contradiction. A very high percentage of whites are privileged, however it does not mean that all white people are comparatively living privileged lives. Privilege is not a stereotype, it's a statistic, and one that you should have the humility to admit to.
You should have the humility to admit when you've failed to make an argument that passes prima facie. Assuming privilege based on skin color is no less racist than claiming dysfunction based on skin color. Claiming "all white people are privileged" is akin to claiming "all black people are criminals."
white privilege is often used in an accusatory context where you as a white person are accused of being the perpetrator of misfortune for the minorities, which i think can not stand.
yes we have white privilege i'm not denying that but if you tell me that it's my fault the others have less privileges, then i stand up and combat your ignorance.
so what i'm saying is that you're right, the term is neutrally and objectively true but the way it is often used to guilt trip a majority into obedience is just not right.
i think my take would be a perfect disclaimer for your take. The Idea of "White Privilege" is Racist and "Male White Supremacy" is Sexist! ↗ it seems to me that both our takes combined would be the perfectly rounded take on the issue. i should be able to link your take to mine xD that would spare me some of the annoying discussions i have in my take ^^
I'm NOT a white person and I don't believe in white privilege
Society is sometimes unfair to others but if you're gonna whine about it online and look at other people with prejudice because of it (which IS racism) then God help you
I've a feeling that if you were a millionaire/successful in life, you wouldn't even acknowledge such things happening
Because let's face it, people who blame white privilege are just a bunch of losers complaining about how the system is unfair instead of adapting and dealing with it
This feeling of perpetual victimhood is what lowers people's potentials not white privilege or whatever new thing you can come up with...
I think White people are privileged because of their skin tone. I have white friends who don't think so. They think they have suffered like the blacks. They think this way because they are not rich. But, they have other benefits that I try to explain to them. I think they know, but don't want to admit. White people have everything and they get away with everything.
White privilege is having a photo of a white guy with the label ignorance across his face and sitting back and taking it. I challenge anyone to post a photo of some other race with that same label. This site is pure racism and they would never pull this down.
That photo and this site's handling of it is confirmation that SJWs are the most racist people to date. The most hilarious part is the you cite crime data from the epicenter of the liberal kingdom Chicago. Why are liberals not held accountable for that rather than some nerd white guy with a banner across his face? And by the way you originated the photo I assume.
Well it's were I live so... I didn't really intend for the photo's point to be served as the white person being ignorant, just being ignorant in general.
Chicago is one of the most segregated cities in the US, and it's a good example of how blockbusting and red lining shaped the opportunities of past and present generations.
The problem with these terms is that they often seem to imply that only this one particular group has privileges. White people definitely enjoy MORE privileges that black people, but you can't pretend that black or people of colour don't have their own.
It's the same with male vs female privilege, except in that one people still convince themselves that women still have less privilege. To that I say, "maybe in Saudi Arabia"
Look, white privilege does exist to a certain point due to racism, but let me make this clear if a person works their behind off, focuses and has drive they will make it to the middle class or above it.
One can't sit around and just blame cacausians for crime in their communities, poverty or lack of education.
The hell with hand outs and waiting for white people to come help.
Help your damn self and your own people to succeed.
How recently do you think blacks were allowed to work their way up? My mom's generation was the first with the way things were on the east coast. My nana slaved away working hard her whole life. She was never allowed to make it far. People would withhold her wages and refuse to pay her knowing she would never be listened to by the law over them. She could be fired and replaced at any time in favor of someone whiter. She was an intelligent and beautiful woman, and she was lucky to be pale. She fared far better than many other blacks did. She watched er father be spit on and abused by whites every day in the south. My mom was born into this, and she still had to wait for serious changes to take full effect (not until the late 80's / early 90's) before she could benefit. I had to be bused to white schools in the 90's in FL, because they violated federal segregation and equality laws. Don't tell us what could and could not be done! No one wants whites to help so much as to not hinder.
How about fuck no? "White privilege" is the largest piece of racist propaganda I have seen in my lifetime, and anyone who uses the term is a racist piece of shit.
Because it's a racist concept to begin with. The west is the greatest place on Earth to be any minority in where your rights are enshrined in law regardless of skin color, gender, sexual orientation or what have you. Meanwhile, in countries and the middle east and parts of Asia, being gay is a crime and being a woman means you're property. Only complete and utter morons are stupid enough to blame white people for their problems while majority non-white countries are where human rights go to die.
Awe, your so pretty. Britain has its many whipping horses. Britain likes to segregate amongst its whites. You have your Catholics and Prodys, if your Irish and Catholic God Save you in England if you don’t have an education.
Go talk Brexit elsewhere. The US only practices what it’s mother country taught them to be.
@sjoes006 calm down, I was merely stating my opinion. And that’s Ireland girl, not where I come from, do some geography. I have an education, and nowhere was I talking about brexit but alright. Embarrassing tbh.
Do your own Geography & social science. You embarrass yourself by not knowing the history and great wrong doings of England on Northern Ireland and Scotland. The English usually know nothing of this.
My father was born & raised outside of Derry. I was born in the US and had to decide if I wanted British or Irish dual citizenship. I decided to be American and Irish passports because I just couldn’t betray my community by filing a British passport.
Brexit is a very racist divide and it is causing problems for the divided island of Ireland.
It isn’t appreciated, no one in Ireland wants more troubles. But it’s creating trouble.
I realize Trump is a problem you should know at your age that Brexit is a huge problem for everyone in finance. Your country’s scandal is was sidetracked bc of Trump but you’re still a mess.
Indeed you were lock step with us until 2006 or so. Both on bad courses. Apologise or at least acknowledge the genocide of Irishmen during the 18-19th century.
@sjoes006 I’m not Irish. So the catholic and Protestant issues has absolutely nothing to do with me. I’m not from Ireland. I know all about the troubles but again, has fuck all to do with me.
Really couldn’t give a shit about where your dad is from.
Again, Brexit had nothing to do with this issue but if you wanna drag shit up about your country that’s irrelevant I really could.
I’m not denying genocide happened but it actually had fuck all to do with me. I’m Dutch you moron, my family is Dutch. So it has ZERO to do with me. I was around then, so I wasn’t part of the genocide. I have nothing to apologise for.
You’ve literally dragged up unrelated issues to place blame on me because I don’t live in a country where cops shoot black kids in the street. The topic was white priveledge. Return to the issue or feel free to be blocked.
@ShrewdRose nah The US wasn’t mindless in its making. But it followed the same pattern its parent country laid out once it became a world power after WWII. Mindless, no.
The US is just as complicit in its horrible dealings as the UK was during hers. My point simply being kettle/ Black... work together to make better policy as we both worked together for so long to make really bad policy post WWII.
You identify as UK citizen so I’m going off of that. If you were raised in the UK then you don’t have to be Irish to know that even in England Catholics are deplorables. That’s not PC and it is something we try to hide but it’s a theme.
Hmm Dutch even better. Nazi sympathizers, you sound better and better. My stand in Grandmother, when I was a child, my nextdoor neighbor, was in high school during the war. I knew her for 30 years. She told me of boys getting taken up into trucks on the way home from school in Amsterdam. But when I was older she told me of the cooperation. The Netherlands service cooperated and became part of the stealing of boys.
So you’ve gone from a pretty horrible situation in Ireland that was maybe genocide in the 18-19th century and then guerrilla war after that l, to being on hook with the. Nazis. Well done.
WHITE PRIVILEGE IS SO A THING WHERE YPU COME FROM.
@sjoes006 nazi sympathisers? Are you serious? You’re an absolute joke and I’m no longer discussing anything with you. You clearly do not know your history whatsoever.
‘I’ve heard’ what, some fuckin bullshit tale. You know absolutely nothing. Absolutely embarrassed for you and how dare you. Get off my thread you lying scum bag.
Actually white privilege isn't really about economics, it is about the difference between the way white people are treated in society as opposed to POC. It helps explain some of the economic disparity but is not defined by it - most poor people in the US are white.
That's because a majority of the people in the US Are white, but comparatively there are a lot less white people that live in poverty compared to other minority groups.
Great take. I live in the suburbs of Chicago and go to the city a lot and there's definitely segregated areas and issues with gentrification, especially with Pilsen. In fact, when I walked to a show, there was graffiti saying fuck gentrification on the sidewalk.
People who get offended by the term "white privilege" are the same people who get offended by "black lives matter" and "cracker".
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
70Opinion
-Asians are actually the highest paid race
-there are programs in place to get minorities jobs or into college simply for being a minority. Why don't they have to earn these accomplishments based off merit? Sounds like a privilege for them.
-I'm white and from a low middle class family, we hardly have money to buy anything extra beyond the necessities. If this white privilege is a thing why does my family have to live paycheck to paycheck?
These are just a few points that show the whole white privilege argument is stupid.
As a half Asian myself, I find it funny how he chose to omit Asians from his statistics. He's just trying to skew things to fit his poisonous agenda.
even though Asians may be the highest paid race, they as well as other coloured radicalized groups in society don't get he recognition for their achievements like white privileged people do. The Asian as your example, would only get questioned or the black peoples success would also be questioned in society as "oh how did he end up doing that?" or "he is smart for a black man" where as whites don't get questioned on their success.
@realistincanada Prove it.
@Kkaos I didn't omit Asians from my statistics. This isn't about that, it's about the reasons there are disparities between races in the first place. My agenda has nothing to do with its existence because it's existence has already been proven time and time again, met with ridiculous opposition like "oh 8m white and I'm poor" or "I'm black and I'm rich" or "I'm Asian and I'm middle class" it doesn't matter because the socioeconomics behind favoritism in society is cemented in the demographics of our cities and states.
So prove it exists. You've posted bullshit about average incomes, yet I've already shut you down on that because white don't receive the highest income on average, so I want to see some real proof for you?
Does white privilege exist in only America, only in the western world, or the whole world?
@Kkaos it’s obviously predominantly in the western world. You think I’m China whites are that much more privileged? use you common sense. Part of white privilegeisnnot being aware it exists
@realistincanada Duh, of course they aren't. Ever heard of a rhetorical question? The fact you like to think of yourself as educated is simply hilarious. I'm still waiting for you to stump up with your own arguments rather than directing me towards your article because you're either too lazy or ignorant to provide your own material.
You did omit Asians though. You say there is white privilege, yet whites aren't even the most privileged based on the argument you are trying to present so you left them out. Also to say "I'm white and I'm poor" is a completely legit argument to white privilege. If you are going to say that an entire race of people are privileged shouldn't they all have some advantage compared the others? Me being white has not given me an advantage in anything my whole life (not that it should either). What rights do I as a white person have that other minorities dont? Having rights or advantages that others don't would be white privilege, but we dont. And like I mentioned above there are actually programs in place that hand minorities jobs or get them into schools simply for being non white. That's privilege. To say blacks and Hispanic heavy areas have more poverty on average is not an argument for saying an entire race is privileged when there are also many people in that race that live in poverty.
@Kkaos you dumb ass, I am using academic scholars to validate my argument. I didn’t create this research and if I didn’t use academic evidence to prove my argument, then my argument would not have any proof
@realistincanada so give us these sources then.
@realistincanada Haha, I'm a dumbass am I? How cute. An insult from you is like an insult from a 3 year old child with down syndrome, it's meaningless but
Still waiting for you to stump up with your own valid arguments that are cited with evidence as well.
And the solution to "white privilege" is what?
Taking Whites forcefully out of high-up positions and placing minorities into them?
Implementing a "white privilege" tax which takes money from rich white people and giving tax cuts to poor blacks and leaving the poor whites to starve whilst alienating the rich white class?
Increasing spending on welfare?
Genociding white people? <-- this seems like the solution many left-wing degenerates want.
you guessed it
@Goochbreaker I didn't remove your comment, I responded to it in fact. I don't even think you can remove comments on this site.
@Goochbreaker I don't have the energy to report you. And I certainly don't have the energy to reply to you on every opinion. Have a nice day big funni man.
Basically that what leftists and other black supremacist groups such as BLM are asking. Whites must give everything they have and will have to blacks, and then slowly back off of any kind of power, and just become submissive little slaves.
None of these is really on the table. The solution is just to understand it and fix weak points such as refusing to hire people for not having white enough names. People don't want hand outs. People want to be able to reach equal ground. I read a research paper that stated it takes about 7 generations on average for a family to go from wealthy to poor or vice versa. Most black people work their buts off. They just want the same reward for the same amount of effort and the same ability to improve their lot in life. This cannot happen if people pretend there are no issues worth looking at. It's not just blacks. It's women, hispanics, Asians, etc. Minority executives in the U. S. are extremely low. 20 years ago there were only about 5 female executives. None were minorities. Ten years ago it was about 20. Now it is up to about 40, and minorities females are added in and finally being allowed to work their way to the top. Same issue with many leadership positions.
@wolfcat87 What a pile of complete and utter bullshit.
1. I don't know about companies only hiring people with white sounding names, if it does occur, it's definitely in secret. But what I know that does occur because it's said almost proudly and openly, is companies exclusively hiring non whites in order to improve 'diversity'. What do you have to say about that?
2. "takes about 7 generations on average for a family to go from wealthy " What a load of absolute shit. There are PLENTY of wealthy people, wealthy families who are self made millionaires, even billionaires. Nor does someone's wealth directly correspond to their race. They're are poor people and rich people in EVERY country.
3. " It's not just blacks. It's women, hispanics, Asians, etc" Funny how you mention Asians, did you even bother to check the damn statistics? Asians on average earn the highest in America. Yep, that's right, Asians who immigrate to America end up earning the most on average.
@Kkaos Actually, those companies are only required to hire to match the actual population distribution of the area they are in. Doe sit make sense for a company in a 99% black area to only have 99% white employees? No. Should their credentials matter? Yes.
It was in secret. It was only discovered when someone decided to do a study just to see what would happen. You can look it up.
Again, 7 generations to go up or down on AVERAGE. lol. Rarely do people go from the slums of Brazil to billionaire. BE real here. How often do people on welfare suddenly become millionaires? They generally don't. I the vast majority of cases it's a gradual process. 7 generations was the average. More clever or luck families would advance faster and less would advance more slowly.
... Do you realize that most Asians in the U. S. did not migrate to here? Asians have been here as long as anyone else. Immigrant children on average tend to earn more than the average American.
@Kkaos But, what does that have to do with whether or not they are given as many chances to promote to executive positions at work? If Asians are more likely to secure jobs in fields that pay more and do not ever advance, then of course they would earn more on average. That does not mean they are getting executive positions. Statistics do not really work the way you just used them. Yikes. If they are going into the same jobs and are promoted more to a point, then they'd earn more than those below them, but they may still be stunted in how far they can promote. Does that make sense?
@wolfcat87 Provide the statistics for the demographics of people who are ELIGIBLE for executive positions and then provide the demographics for those who are chosen. I'll be waiting.
@Kkaos You're funny. The only people eligible are the people promoted... If you cannot get promote due to color, then you can never be eligible for anything. Think about that. Also, if you are able to spend so much time arguing, learn to do your own homework. Show me the number of people how get promoted to each level and their colors. Degree rates by race are pretty caught up at this point, so if they do not match the local population distribution, they are indeed discriminating.
@wolfcat87 No; 'what does that have to do with whether or not they are given as many chances to promote to executive positions at work?' You've claimed white people are given an unfair advantage when it comes to promotion to executive roles, in order to prove that, you must provide the statistics of how many people were eligible, what their races were, what their credentials were and then prove that they were either chosen or not chosen based on their race and any racial privileges or lack thereof. Come on, you've made a claim here, I want to start seeing some evidence from you.
It has NOTHING to do with the local population distribution, as now you're bringing in people who were NEVER even in contention for these roles into the mix, they're irrelevant. I want to see the demographics of the people who were in contention for executive roles compared to the people who got the roles. Then and ONLY then can you start making judgments about any racial biases in the recruitment process.
Beautiful, rather than corporations being based on merit/meritocracy they introduce "diversity quotas" where they hire exclusively minorities or according to the "demographics of the area they live in"
I agree with all but one point: “I hate to break it to you, but the model white collar worker in the eyes of America, is a white man (or a white woman if we're being generous.)“
The model is white man not woman but the practice is woman in a lot of industries. There are more female doctors, lawyers basically anything other than STEM women are progressing in.
But yes it is very troubling to me the lack of African Americans in most white collar work places.
I worked at a large company that was always hiring and interviewing and saw many a black faces in the waiting room and their resume.
Never saw one hired despite credentials. Not for a white collar role. Only for support roles and even then it was rare. People assume black women will be sassy on the phone or have a bad attitude.
I dont get offended by something that doesn't exist.
It very much exists. You are being ignorant. Only people such as yourself who have full advantage of it will not realize it. Many white people are aware of this privilege and they therefore understand that they have an advantage over coloured people, simply based on the colour of their skin , although not all white people can get the benefits.
@realistincanada Prove it. Also explain why you use racist terms such as 'coloured.
@Kkaos can you explain why this myTake doesn't prove anything? And site specific points?
White priv. is something that you are born with, because you inherit the privileges that are reproduced from generation to generation.
read this for all you uneducated folks , pay attention to the list as well
www.winnipeg.ca/.../white_privilege.pdf
@SketchForger There are rich people and there are poor people in every country. You've deliberately and falsely skewed your data in order to omit Asians who actually earn more than whites on average in the United States.
@realistincanada You're an adult, explain in your own words what I have asked... Or are you not educated enough to speak for yourself?
@Kkaos are you not educated enough to read an academic article? Read the article and learn. That is a University article that was written by scholars. Are you illiterate? do you need someone to come read it to you?
as I stated below, even though Asians may be the highest paid race, they as well as other coloured radicalized groups in society don't get he recognition for their achievements like white privileged people do. The Asian as your example, would only get questioned or the black peoples success would also be questioned in society as "oh how did he end up doing that?" or "he is smart for a black man" where as whites don't get questioned on their success.
@realistincanada Whites get questioned on their success all the time, you are doing it right now.
@realistincanada You are delusional and playing the victim. Stop it. That is what is wrong with this country. WHITE PRIVILEGE IS A MYTH. Stop with the bull shit.
Lol, what university or college did you get an education at? University is where I got the information that actually confirmed that white privilege exists, there are several academic scholars who have researched this. Clearly you are uneducated and uninformed about hierarchy’s that are present in society? Or maybe you are one of the financially poor white people who do not have the benefits of white privilege? Read the academic article I pasted into this thread. Get educated, do you think this ‘white privilege’ concept was made up? And you think I’m playing victim? You must have barely graduated high school. This white privilege is very real and it’s very evident within western society. There are several university articles that I can prove that it exists with. Ask me for them. PSA kids pursue a university/college education. You don’t want to be embarrassingly uneducated like this illiterate 52 year old. The facts are in front of you. READ the link I provided
@realistincanada Come on, I want to start seeing proof from you. Indeed I've read and written many research pieces and part of making an argument is you writing your own material. I want to see clear and concise points from you that are backed up with exact references. Unless you can do that, what you say is baseless.
@realistincanada True liberal... name calling and all. LOL. You have it down pretty good... race card... playing the victim... I bet you get violent also when you are confronted in person. Most liberals do. lol
Regardless of me being a liberal or not is very irrelevant to this argument. You have no argument against my evidence and my points. Your only “point” that you addressed which is absolutely irrelevant was that I am playing a victim. Lol I expected much more from someone as old as you who should have knowledge on academic resources. And yes I do insult people such as yourself who are blind to the facts due to pure ignorance. you have no convincing arguments
@realistincanada you have no point just playing the victim
How do I play the victim? Am I complaining about it? No, I’m just motivated to work even harder. I am an African American, living in Canada and I am striving to be successful no matter the barriers society places on me for being coloured, and regardless of the white privilege that racialised minority’s do not have access to
@realistincanada there is no white privilege.
@realistincanada Tell me would you prefer to be in Liberia, there is no "white privilege" there, and it was never colonized, do you think you would be better off? Even before its civil wars it was doing badly even by African standards.
we are not privileged. i grew up everyday wondering if we would be eicted from our apartment. i guess im in the minority. if i wouldn't have been adopted i would have been in worst. we are in the same predicament as every ethnicity
Statistics exist because of factors. It is nobody but financial ancestors fault that this is a thing.
no one cares about YOUR personal life. we are stating facts of the majority of white people.
www.winnipeg.ca/.../white_privilege.pdf
@realistincanada Perhaps you should call it majority white privileged then. Of course if even one single white person does not have it it demonstrates that it is not something that we can inherit.
So you admit that not all white people are privileged, yet you defend the racist concept that whiteness implies privilege all the same? You basically destroyed your own theory right there. And then you say those who deny "white privilege" don't look very smart? Wow, get a clue, my man.
There's no contradiction. A very high percentage of whites are privileged, however it does not mean that all white people are comparatively living privileged lives. Privilege is not a stereotype, it's a statistic, and one that you should have the humility to admit to.
You should have the humility to admit when you've failed to make an argument that passes prima facie. Assuming privilege based on skin color is no less racist than claiming dysfunction based on skin color. Claiming "all white people are privileged" is akin to claiming "all black people are criminals."
white privilege is often used in an accusatory context where you as a white person are accused of being the perpetrator of misfortune for the minorities, which i think can not stand.
yes we have white privilege i'm not denying that but if you tell me that it's my fault the others have less privileges, then i stand up and combat your ignorance.
so what i'm saying is that you're right, the term is neutrally and objectively true but the way it is often used to guilt trip a majority into obedience is just not right.
That's the point of the disclaimer
i think my take would be a perfect disclaimer for your take.
The Idea of "White Privilege" is Racist and "Male White Supremacy" is Sexist! ↗
it seems to me that both our takes combined would be the perfectly rounded take on the issue.
i should be able to link your take to mine xD that would spare me some of the annoying discussions i have in my take ^^
Haha nope, none of the terms can really hurt you.
well they "can" if you don't resist the accusations of guilt :) but yeah i guess i'm preaching to the choir here ^^
But the earth is flat. Just kidding. You know I ❤️❤️❤️ this!
Oh you. XD
I'm NOT a white person and I don't believe in white privilege
Society is sometimes unfair to others but if you're gonna whine about it online and look at other people with prejudice because of it (which IS racism) then God help you
I've a feeling that if you were a millionaire/successful in life, you wouldn't even acknowledge such things happening
Because let's face it, people who blame white privilege are just a bunch of losers complaining about how the system is unfair instead of adapting and dealing with it
This feeling of perpetual victimhood is what lowers people's potentials not white privilege or whatever new thing you can come up with...
I think White people are privileged because of their skin tone. I have white friends who don't think so. They think they have suffered like the blacks. They think this way because they are not rich. But, they have other benefits that I try to explain to them. I think they know, but don't want to admit. White people have everything and they get away with everything.
White privilege is having a photo of a white guy with the label ignorance across his face and sitting back and taking it. I challenge anyone to post a photo of some other race with that same label. This site is pure racism and they would never pull this down.
I didn't want it to be the cover photo, that wasn't my intention and I contacted the mods about it.
That photo and this site's handling of it is confirmation that SJWs are the most racist people to date. The most hilarious part is the you cite crime data from the epicenter of the liberal kingdom Chicago. Why are liberals not held accountable for that rather than some nerd white guy with a banner across his face? And by the way you originated the photo I assume.
Well it's were I live so... I didn't really intend for the photo's point to be served as the white person being ignorant, just being ignorant in general.
Chicago is one of the most segregated cities in the US, and it's a good example of how blockbusting and red lining shaped the opportunities of past and present generations.
As a child of white privilege, I totally agree with this myTake.
Glad you could find it relatable. XD
You should move into a real slumy area. Solidarity sister.
The problem with these terms is that they often seem to imply that only this one particular group has privileges. White people definitely enjoy MORE privileges that black people, but you can't pretend that black or people of colour don't have their own.
It's the same with male vs female privilege, except in that one people still convince themselves that women still have less privilege. To that I say, "maybe in Saudi Arabia"
This is a *really* good take. You should be super proud of writing it and I’m sorry many people aren’t putting in the same effort you did
He is not putting any effort, he is just repeating statistics created by people who already have decided what conclusions to draw.
@Jackblue and yet it’s still more effort than you put in. Amazing
Look, white privilege does exist to a certain point due to racism, but let me make this clear if a person works their behind off, focuses and has drive they will make it to the middle class or above it.
One can't sit around and just blame cacausians for crime in their communities, poverty or lack of education.
The hell with hand outs and waiting for white people to come help.
Help your damn self and your own people to succeed.
How recently do you think blacks were allowed to work their way up? My mom's generation was the first with the way things were on the east coast. My nana slaved away working hard her whole life. She was never allowed to make it far. People would withhold her wages and refuse to pay her knowing she would never be listened to by the law over them. She could be fired and replaced at any time in favor of someone whiter. She was an intelligent and beautiful woman, and she was lucky to be pale. She fared far better than many other blacks did. She watched er father be spit on and abused by whites every day in the south. My mom was born into this, and she still had to wait for serious changes to take full effect (not until the late 80's / early 90's) before she could benefit. I had to be bused to white schools in the 90's in FL, because they violated federal segregation and equality laws. Don't tell us what could and could not be done! No one wants whites to help so much as to not hinder.
@wolfcat87: Look your grandma generation had a legit excuse. In 2018 there is none. Work extremely hard, save money and figure out away. That simple.
* a way
Thank you for telling me what should and shouldn't offend me. How positively presumptuous of you.
How about fuck no? "White privilege" is the largest piece of racist propaganda I have seen in my lifetime, and anyone who uses the term is a racist piece of shit.
Why?
Because it's a racist concept to begin with. The west is the greatest place on Earth to be any minority in where your rights are enshrined in law regardless of skin color, gender, sexual orientation or what have you. Meanwhile, in countries and the middle east and parts of Asia, being gay is a crime and being a woman means you're property. Only complete and utter morons are stupid enough to blame white people for their problems while majority non-white countries are where human rights go to die.
Did you read the myTake?
Or even the disclaimer?
I don't think they read it at all. It's very easy to turn away if they don't even bother to look.
This is so American. This issue isn’t the case here. White privilege is not a thing where I come from.
Awe, your so pretty. Britain has its many whipping horses. Britain likes to segregate amongst its whites. You have your Catholics and Prodys, if your Irish and Catholic God Save you in England if you don’t have an education.
Go talk Brexit elsewhere. The US only practices what it’s mother country taught them to be.
@sjoes006 calm down, I was merely stating my opinion. And that’s Ireland girl, not where I come from, do some geography. I have an education, and nowhere was I talking about brexit but alright. Embarrassing tbh.
@sjoes006 and don’t lay your racism at our feet.
Do your own Geography & social science. You embarrass yourself by not knowing the history and great wrong doings of England on Northern Ireland and Scotland. The English usually know nothing of this.
My father was born & raised outside of Derry. I was born in the US and had to decide if I wanted British or Irish dual citizenship. I decided to be American and Irish passports because I just couldn’t betray my community by filing a British passport.
Brexit is a very racist divide and it is causing problems for the divided island of Ireland.
It isn’t appreciated, no one in Ireland wants more troubles. But it’s creating trouble.
I realize Trump is a problem you should know at your age that Brexit is a huge problem for everyone in finance. Your country’s scandal is was sidetracked bc of Trump but you’re still a mess.
Indeed you were lock step with us until 2006 or so. Both on bad courses. Apologise or at least acknowledge the genocide of Irishmen during the 18-19th century.
@sjoes006 I’m not Irish. So the catholic and Protestant issues has absolutely nothing to do with me. I’m not from Ireland. I know all about the troubles but again, has fuck all to do with me.
Really couldn’t give a shit about where your dad is from.
Again, Brexit had nothing to do with this issue but if you wanna drag shit up about your country that’s irrelevant I really could.
I’m not denying genocide happened but it actually had fuck all to do with me. I’m Dutch you moron, my family is Dutch. So it has ZERO to do with me. I was around then, so I wasn’t part of the genocide. I have nothing to apologise for.
You’ve literally dragged up unrelated issues to place blame on me because I don’t live in a country where cops shoot black kids in the street. The topic was white priveledge. Return to the issue or feel free to be blocked.
@sjoes006 So what you're saying is America are mindless children capable of forming their own identity? Sounds about right.
@ShrewdRose nah The US wasn’t mindless in its making. But it followed the same pattern its parent country laid out once it became a world power after WWII. Mindless, no.
The US is just as complicit in its horrible dealings as the UK was during hers. My point simply being kettle/ Black... work together to make better policy as we both worked together for so long to make really bad policy post WWII.
You identify as UK citizen so I’m going off of that. If you were raised in the UK then you don’t have to be Irish to know that even in England Catholics are deplorables. That’s not PC and it is something we try to hide but it’s a theme.
Hmm Dutch even better. Nazi sympathizers, you sound better and better. My stand in Grandmother, when I was a child, my nextdoor neighbor, was in high school during the war. I knew her for 30 years. She told me of boys getting taken up into trucks on the way home from school in Amsterdam. But when I was older she told me of the cooperation. The Netherlands service cooperated and became part of the stealing of boys.
So you’ve gone from a pretty horrible situation in Ireland that was maybe genocide in the 18-19th century and then guerrilla war after that l, to being on hook with the. Nazis. Well done.
WHITE PRIVILEGE IS SO A THING WHERE YPU COME FROM.
I’ve been there and done that. Get over yourself.
Lots of questions for an Arab looking man and restaurants have refused to serve him period.
@sjoes006 nazi sympathisers? Are you serious? You’re an absolute joke and I’m no longer discussing anything with you. You clearly do not know your history whatsoever.
‘I’ve heard’ what, some fuckin bullshit tale. You know absolutely nothing. Absolutely embarrassed for you and how dare you. Get off my thread you lying scum bag.
@sjoes006 if you’re 40 you’re an absolute child who knows nothing. Blocked, you’re a racist and liar, not me.
Actually white privilege isn't really about economics, it is about the difference between the way white people are treated in society as opposed to POC. It helps explain some of the economic disparity but is not defined by it - most poor people in the US are white.
That's because a majority of the people in the US Are white, but comparatively there are a lot less white people that live in poverty compared to other minority groups.
Great take. I live in the suburbs of Chicago and go to the city a lot and there's definitely segregated areas and issues with gentrification, especially with Pilsen. In fact, when I walked to a show, there was graffiti saying fuck gentrification on the sidewalk.
People who get offended by the term "white privilege" are the same people who get offended by "black lives matter" and "cracker".