Should transgender inmates stay in the prison that corresponds to their own gender identity?

For context- this subject has come up for scrutiny in the UK in recent weeks. Some rulings in prison are devolved to different parts of the UK, such as Scotland, whose parliament's biggest party is the liberally-minded SNP. In Scotland at present, transgender prisoners may apply to be transferred to a prison that corresponds to their gender identity. They may apply regardless of if they have undergone transition therapy or legally changed their gender, though of course the prison board may reject the application. However it has recently caused major controversy as one inmate, Karen White, who had been convicted of sexual offences against females, was approved for transfer to a women's prison despite not having legally changed their gender or begun any form of gender therapy, and four inmates subsequently came forward to testify that they had been sexually assaulted by White within a few days (White was then transferred back to a men's prison.) It gained some wider publicity after the author JK Rowling retweeted a tweet calling urging stricter control in future. So, I just wanted to know what your thoughts on the matter were.

(A couple of additional bits of information:
There are fewer than 200 transgender inmates currently in the UK, with a population of about 60 million.
However, over 50% of transgender inmates at present are either in prison for sexual crimes or have been convicted of sexual crimes in the past.
On the other hand, some activists argue that transgender prisoners are more likely to suffer abuse from fellow inmates in a prison that does not correspond to their identity.)
All prisoners should go to prison on the basis of the sex they were born, regardless of what crime they committed or what gender they identify as.
Vote A
Transgender prisoners should be allowed to switch prisons, provided they have legally changed their gender and undergone conversion therapy, and so long as their crime is not too heinous.
Vote B
Transgender prisoners should be allowed to switch prisons regardless of if they have undergone conversion therapy, provided they have legally changed their gender + their crimes are not too heinous.
Vote C
Any prisoner who identifies as transgender should be allowed to switch prisons regardless of legal gender or biological sex, provided their crimes are not too heinous.
Vote D
Any prisoner who identifies as transgender should be allowed to switch prisons, regardless of legal gender, biological sex or what crimes they have committed.
Vote E
Select age and gender to cast your vote:
GirlGuy
Should transgender inmates stay in the prison that corresponds to their own gender identity?
4
28
Add Opinion