Most Helpful Guy
It's pretty gay. If it was me I would be happy with the gift since my girlfriend gave it to me. But as a gift I wouldn't understand why she would get me something like that and really have no idea what to do with it. I would be a little upset about it since it would mean she clearly doesn't really get me and couldn't find something more sunited to my interests. I would still be very much happy she got me a gift regardless tho. It would probably end up stored away in a box pretty fast tho, I mean what straight guy wants stuff toys laying around.
Most Helpful Girl
I think it would be a sweet and caring thing to give him a stuffed animal. I think a guy shouldn't be offended about what their girl gives them, but should take the gift with love and pride. My dad once knew a guy who walked into a bar and saw this man sitting down at the barstool wearing a pink knitted sweater. The guy walked up to him to laugh at his shirt and the guy wearing the sweater stood up and looked down on the man. Turns out the guy wearing the sweater was a huge tall muscled man. He said," my wife made me this sweater. You got a problem with that?"" In a deep voice. The man shrunk down and just said," Naw man pink looks great on you."" Sure shut that guy up.