Home | New Members | Expert Answers | How To Videos | Our Blog | Sign Up | Sign In
Invite Friends
 
GirlsAskGuys.com GirlsAskGuys.com
  Chat Flirting Dating Relationships Sexuality Break-Up Behavior Style Other
almondz

Should I break up with him for good?

Average Rating:
Your Rating: 
MiserableBoringEnjoyableInterestingFascinating
 
almondz (Age:25 to 29)     When: A month ago
Views: 336     Category: Break-Up

My boyfriend and I just reconciled recently (we have broken up and gotten back together so many times) and he was more attentive to me than ever. We were broke up for a month and he says it was hell for him. His "kid's mother" seems to be putting pressure on him and using her child as a pawn to get back with him since we been together. I've been trying to open his eyes, and not to mention the kid isn't even biologically his!

We got into a big argument about it and I tell him that I wanted to meet his kid's mother. I want to see their interaction with each other and see if he still has feelings for her even though he says he doesn't. He tells me that I can meet her on Friday (which was yesterday).

The afternoon I was supposed to meet her I ask him if I'm still going with him to drop his 'daughter' off and meet the mother. He gives me this story about her not having a car and she's all depressed and blah blah blah. I am wondering if he has something to hide or something and I am p*ssed about it. It seems like he cares more about her feelings than he does about mine. I tell him not to call me anymore and now I'm hurting because I love him so much. What should I do?


Update: I don't have anything against the child, but it seems like the child's mother is using her child as a clutch to get my boyfriend back. She is asking him for things that is outside of what he can provide and she's playing the crying game.    A month ago

Update: My boyfriend finally took me to see the child's mother on Halloween, now there is more drama! See my new question. Geez!    18 days ago

Update: All your answers really helped me its hard to pick a best answer!    18 days ago

3000 characters left  Anonymous Spell Check Spell Check
 Report Question Widgets Note This
SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend
 Share on Facebook

Answers

    From Guys  
9
From Girls  
8
 

What Guys Said

MadHatterni
2623  
MadHatterni      When: 25 days ago
He is the mother of his child correct? Can't trust a B*tchy female with a son. I feel you forgeting he has other obligations to her and you. If he's with you and shows it then show him you won't take him for granted and how much better off he is with you than her. The child is a perfect excuse. If I was you I would also use it to my advantage and ask your boyfriend if you him and the child can go to a fun place and enjoy the day together so you leave an impression on the child that the mother would watch her step.

example - go see a movie the child would like and go eat his fav food making him think your cool.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report
 
happa808 I think you misread the statement, the child's not biologically his. But he may have built up an emotional attachment to the child - 23 days ago
Answerer I ment if their close, then you should be close to him, showing you want in on their inner circle too. that's all. - 23 days ago

sumina7
1720  
sumina7      When: 25 days ago
Dont blame his ex, it is he who is to be blamed for behaving this way with you. It is understandable that you feel angry with him for not giving you the importance that you deserve. Break up with him for good.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

ap1100
675  
ap1100      When: 25 days ago
I think you should move on. You're too young to deal with this kind of craziness in your life. Whether the kid is biologically his or not, I do think if he's seen as "dad", he needs to be there for it. The fact that he hooked up with a nut job of a girl is his fault and he shouldn't be so quick to leave his responsibilities. If he does, he'll create another insecure girl with daddy issues who will be the focus of more topics on here about why girls love jerks.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report
 
Question Asker I didn't see it at first...love can be blind. I need the male perspectives on the situation. - 18 days ago

Littletad
14583  
Littletad      When: 29 days ago
Sounds like he's more trouble than he's worth. It's up to you if you want to continue anything with this man.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report
 
Question Asker I'm starting to see the light!!! - 18 days ago

Diamond_Smith
131  
Diamond_Smith      When: 29 days ago
Hey babe, I'd like to help by asking you some questions:

1) Of the 6billion+ people on the Earth, how many have you had relationships with?
2) Do you feel you might be jealous because his attention is not entirely on you?
3) How would you feel if the child was his, and he broke up with you for her?
4) If you proved the child wasn't his, would it make him more attracted to you?
5) Have you asked yourself if he might be having an affair?
6) If he was having an affair, how would you react?
7) If you started seeing one of your past relations, how do you think it would make him feel?
8) If you answered "jealous" to question #7, do you think he already knows how you feel now?
9) Say you accept that he might be having an affair with his ex.. If you be the woman NOW, by telling him you're taking a break from the relationship, SAY "NO" to any arguments he might bring up after..even if he acts all sappy & phones you every day after..

now say you kept your options open for 2 weeks, and by the end of that time he did not say that he would give up his ex, would you proudly move on to the billions of other men, or would unhappily choose to be stuck in your past fighting a losing battle?

What does your female instinct suggest after your thoughts?
Your INTUITION about men is your strongest power when dealing with men, and you know that very well better than myself! Find a female friend, or internet buddy if you must that will support your intuition and your choices as you feel your way around his motives, and help you stay strong as you may feel unwilling to give him up if you must.

Wishing you the best!
Diamond Smith
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report
 
Question Asker Thank you Diamond!! - 18 days ago

bobair
920  
bobair      When: A month ago
This isn't a problem with his ex, it's a problem with you.

If you're insecure and jealous about his ex girlfriends, then everything you're doing is pushing him away.

If you're ever unsure if a relationship is over, ask yourself this... do you ever feel resentment from him, or towards him? If you answer yes, then it's over.

There's nothing that helps you forget an ex boyfriend like a new guy worth getting to know,
~ Robby
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report
 
Question Asker Thanks for the advice, and I have to admit I am insecure about our relationship. I was secure until a situation happened that almost wrecked us. I do hold some anger against him because of some of the problems we go through. It;s tempting to get a new guy, but I wouldn't want to rebound and hurt the other guy's feelings. We would have to be friends first until I could fully recover from my previous relationship. - A month ago
Answerer You know yourself better then me... but I always call B.S. on avoiding the rebounds.

If you're honest and upfront with the next guy by saying "I just got out of a weird relationship and now all I want is fun, so don't get attached" and if he's game, then have all the fun you can, without the need of feeling guilty. Guy's can relate to not wanting something serious. Being friends first is a waste of time.

That will ease you out of a bad past situation, and into a better one. YES! - 29 days ago
Question Asker Thanks again! You really helped me out. - 18 days ago

DoggyDude
1070  
DoggyDude      When: A month ago
Impossible to say. So many variables.

Like how the guy was with this other woman with a child. Was he responsible for the child being here for instance? (even if it isn't biologically his).

I would say, push this guy back to his previous relationship (if they panned children together). Otherwise you splitting up something.

If he got truly lulled into a relationship with someone who already had kids (and he had not responsibility for) then just fight for your love.

Just don't mess around where kids are concerned. If he has been with his ex for a long time and the kids grown up with him, send him packing.
Do you agree?
Agree   2 Disagree   0
Report
 
Question Asker The child isn't his but at first he thought it was. The girl got pregnant and everything while they were together and all that time he thought it was his. He caught her in bed with another man so he got a blood test and turns out the child wasn't his. He's still in the child's life buying her things and acting like a father. Its wild to me because the child knows he isn't her father, and doesn't call him daddy she calls him by his first name. - A month ago
Answerer It doesn't sound healthy that. Fair enough, I am still friends with my ex, but if she had kids I wouldn't be round playing with them, would be too weird. At least to my mind at the moment.

I wouldn't know what to make of him either. I guess you need to sit him down and find out where he thinks everythings going with his ex, the kid and him. If your happy with the answers fight for him, if not well, maybe you decide to find someone new.

Good luck. - A month ago
ap1100 This guy sounds nuts. All of the drama surrounding the conception of this child would be enough to have me packing. He has low self-esteem and I guess he'll get, and has gotten, what he deserves, which is a lack of love since he doesn't love himself. - 25 days ago
Question Asker LOL AP, he is nuts and I'm starting to see that now. Its a shame I wasted 5-6 months with this guy. Love hurts. :( - 18 days ago

pugsey06
35  
pugsey06      When: A month ago
I would think if he loved you he would not let that get in the way. You should be the one winning if he actually cared not her
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report
 
Question Asker Exactly! I feel like if you have nothing to hide then what's the problem? I would have to meet her eventually if you plan on marrying me. - A month ago
Answerer Ok it sounds like you guys are have a lot of problems already really is he worth the trouble - 29 days ago

jacquesvol
8875  
jacquesvol      When: A month ago
What should I do?"
IDK. The problem might be the kid.
If he's attached to the kid, it's normal he wants to see it, biological father or not. A man who raises a kid will often ends up considering it as his. (I at least would and I know others!) An arrangement with his ex about the kid would be best.
Do you agree?
Agree   3 Disagree   0
Report
 
Answerer PS,
It would be way better for the kid too: it would give it more stability. Kids need stability! - A month ago
Question Asker I agree, but I think the mother uses the child as a clutch to get back with him. - A month ago
Answerer That's why I wrote "an arrangement": it could/ would draw some limits and boundaries. If he doesn't get to see the kid at all, he will want it more than if the kid comes over to your place a weekend/ month or fortnight and spends some vacations with you. Much depends on the age of that kid (baby, toddler, teenager?), on her mother willing to get into some kind of agreement about it.If she's pulling him towards the kid she can't refuse very well without showing her hand) and on your hospitality. - A month ago
 

What Girls Said

KatieKA
62  
KatieKA      When: 7 days ago
Oh hell every time I hear a guy has a kid to another woman I stayed away. Nothing personal to them, but that woman has a kid to them, and sometimes they will use the kid as a leash to get back the man, be it for money, sex, attention for the child. Always seems to cause some turmoil in the future. If only condoms didn't break.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report
 
Question Asker Exactly! - 3 days ago

cekendria09
212  
cekendria09      When: 23 days ago
Ok I think you should be mad I would want to meet his baby mama too if he makes it seem like something is going on. I love kids and my fiance has a possible baby. I have been to court with him for dna testing and child support court and I have met the baby mama. If he won't let you meet her something is going on and you have the right to stop it so you demand it one more time to meet her and if it doesn't happen you leave and he will be running back to prove you wrong if he realizes you are the one. And if they are not sleeping together.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report
 
Question Asker Preach!!! - 18 days ago

rockmom
2200  
rockmom      When: 26 days ago
theres probably nothing harder to do than watch a man you love be manipulated by someone. it makes them seem weak and makes you wonder if there are feelings keeping him under her control. I wouldn't say its feelings he has for her as much as it is his inability to stand up for himself. you have to decide if you're up to watching her control him which in turn controls you to a degree. it sounds like he really cares about you and maybe the child too, so maybe he's worth it but its going to be hard on you unless he can grow a backbone.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

the-love-guru
2140  
the-love-guru      When: 29 days ago
Okay, I read the first paragraph, then stopped reading. I have one sentence to say to you... "It's called a breakup because it's broken." Memorize it. It's a book, a brilliant one. Chances are, if you've broken up more than once, you should stay that way.

I'm sure you've got the standard "he gets me", "we have chemistry", "I love him", etc. etc... but the fact of the matter is that you keep breaking up. Meaning that one or both of you are doing something that is wrong, or you're just incompatible. Which, that's okay because there's MANY men out there that you'll have a wonderful relationship with.

Go find him! Best of luck.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report
 
ap1100 They may something that looks like love, but love isn't enough in a healthy LTR. You're right; the drama of endless breakups indicates something is wrong. - 25 days ago
Question Asker I have to pick up that book. Thank you! - 3 days ago

rachie123
290  
rachie123      When: A month ago
If this guy has been sweet since you got back together and is willing to do what you need in order to feel happy and satisfied in the relationship he has GOT to let you meet the mother. I would suggest to him that you would like to meet the mother because you would LOVE for the little girl to spend the weekend with you and you want the MOTHER to see what kind of person you are so she would feel comfortable. Play the nice guy. You want to be kind to his kid. The Ex woman whatever she is will get so insanely jealous she will probably threaten to take the kid out of his life completely (had friends in similar situations by the way) if he brings her around you or goes somewhere with you for the weekend. Truth is, the kid isn't his, he feels bad abandoning the kid. I think most of it has to do with the kid probably because he has taken care of her for a while and feels attached. I doubt it is the ex, she knows you exist and if something is going on, then you know what to do. I would try playing the nice guy though (even though you want to freak out) because being hostile or insecure/jealous doesn't get anyone anywhere. You want to appear like the strong person here, so then he goes wow my girlfriend is so incredibly cool, look at my whining complaining ex. & hey she's an ex for a reason right? he caught her with another guy didn't he? if he runs back to that you're better off without him because he is a total dumb ass. It really sounds like he got suckered in by the kid, but doesn't want to be with her.

ps. I can pretty much bet that if you make up a fun weekend for this kid (your idea make sure she knows that) the mom won't let it happen and confirm your idea that she wants your man. Continue to plan outings, she will get so frustrated she will take the kid away and poof you solve both problems. No more ex...no more kid that isn't his. lol.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report
 
ap1100 You can't use the kid as a pawn on either side. This kid has been through enough with this promiscuous mom and crazy dad; she doesn't need yet another person playing a parent role. - 25 days ago

koolgirl345
206  
koolgirl345      When: A month ago
To be honest with you I truly thinks that he still have lots of feelings for his child mother. It is very strange to me that he does not want you to meet the mother of his child. (strange).It sounds to me that they are closer than what he is making this out to be. maybe he is still in love with her.( just my opinion) you just can not trust men or figure them out.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report
 
ap1100 You can trust men who don't have craziness in their lives. Those of us who don't carry baggage, who are open on every issue, and who act trustworthy can be trusted. The OP wants to date a weak, passive aggressive guy and expect to get a healthy result. You can't date an elephant and expect it to say "moo" - 25 days ago
Question Asker Thats what I thought. After the mom dropped the little girl off he says 'I guess she is going out on a date or something' and I'm like wtf do you care if she is or not? He p*sses me off. - 3 days ago

anaymous
403  
anaymous      When: A month ago
Womens intuition and gut feelings are usually dead-on. The fact that you wrote asking if he is hiding something tells you your intuition is kicking in. Are there other things he hides? The mother doesn't have a car. Well, who has been driving her around? Where does your boyfriend live? Does he call you everyday? Are you able to reach him anytime via telephone? I wonder if he's playing both sides or if he is just uncomfortable. I dated a man who had kids and I met the mother and really liked her a lot. We got along great. Even when the kids were at my place she knew she could call anytime to talk to them. And, I even told her she could stop by anytime. There was definitely no feelings between him and the mom. You should have that same comfort. You have a right to be angry and I'm surprised you are putting up with it. Tell this guy in a nice way how you feel and that you'll give him a time frame...like 2 weeks. You'd like to meet the mom in 2 weeks or you will end the relationship because it's not healthy for you feeling this way. He may not have even told the mom about you so this gives him a window of opportunity to make things right and tell the mom about you instead of you showing up like a surprise. Just a suggestion.
Do you agree?
Agree   3 Disagree   0
Report
 
DoggyDude Thats some good advice :).

The one thing I would add though is whilst I agree womans intuition is usually dead on, what I've experienced to be often wrong is the perceived trigger cause or explaination of the intuition.

Assigning the wrong explaination to the intuition can lead to the worst mixups and lack of mutual trust between the couple (since if you falsely accuse your partner of infidelity, when the real problem is he's been lying because he doesn't know how to pay the rent.. well - 25 days ago

meplusabeemer
3048  
meplusabeemer      When: A month ago
He obviously has an attachment to this little girl. I have to concur that based on what was written that the mother is using her as a means to keep him in her life. He probably has great guilt if he isn't "there" for the little girl. Unfortunately, he does not see or is in denial about this woman's blatant manipulation.
If he doesn't have feelings for the mother and he has nothing to hide, then you should meet her. It's a simple remedy for this problem. His failure to follow through sends out a huge red flag.
I think you need to acknowledge that as long as you are both together, this little girl will be in his life. Until he separates being a father versus manipulation then your struggles will continue. If you can help him identify this then you've won half the battle. If you can't then you'll have to decide if stay or go.
Good luck.
Do you agree?
Agree   2 Disagree   0
Report
 
Diamond_Smith Hey babe, I'd like to help by asking you some questions:
Of the 6billion+ people on the Earth, how many have you really gotten to know yet?
Do you feel you might be jealous because his attention is not entirely on you?
How would you feel if the child was his, and he broke up with you for her?
If you proved the child wasn't his, would it make him more attracted to you?
Have you asked yourself if he might be having an affair?
If he was having an affair, how would you react?
(continued...) Diamond - 29 days ago
 
Find more questions on breaking up with him     
Home > Break-Up Questions > Should I break up with him for good?
 
Join GirlsAskGuys
Members earn points to get Expert Advice on Video, Amazon & iTunes Gift Cards, books and more!
Male Female
 Open Contests  
Crazy Thanksgiving Story with Family
Thanksgiving is right around the corner and just like the last year and the year before, you will most likely spend it with your family. And just like everyone else, you have a crazy uncle or an...
$20 Amazon Gift Card   $20 Amazon Gift Card
Check out the winner of the last contest!
Worst Pick Up Lines
Winner received $20 Amazon Gift Card
View All Contests >>
Questions on breaking up with him
A Girl Asked Is breaking up the best thing?
My current boyfriend (who is my first one) and I don't act like we're in a true relationship. We've acted the same as when we were friends. It's...  
A Girl Asked Should I meet the parents after breaking up?
i am 6 years older than my ex-bf, it's perfectly fine for him, but his family opposed against our relationship, so we broke up. His mother is going to...  
More Questions on
breaking up with him
Expert Advice
More Video Answers
A Guy Asked  Question: What is the best way to handle a break up?

Video Answer From Tamsen Fadal
Click here to watch larger video
Break-Up Xpers
  
kingbrother
12252  
kingbrother
Single, 16 years old
United Kingdom
0 Questions - 1103 Answers
Break-Up Xper: 3319
Reeses-pieces777
22375  
Reeses-pieces777
Single, 21 years old
Canada
43 Questions - 972 Answers
Break-Up Xper: 3237
BirdofParadise
2950  
BirdofParadise
Single, 22 years old
United Kingdom
108 Questions - 466 Answers
Break-Up Xper: 1720
Shlei3
14534  
Shlei3
Engaged, 26 years old
United States
0 Questions - 353 Answers
Break-Up Xper: 1220

What is Xper? View Rankings
Disclaimer: GirlsAskGuys cannot guarantee the accuracy of answers, opinions and advice submitted by members. Please use common sense when following or omitting any content on GirlsAskGuys.com
Browse Categories: Flirting  |   Dating  |   Relationships  |   Sexuality  |   Break-Up  |   Behavior  |   Style  |   Other                                         Home Top
  Site Links     About GirlsAskGuys     GirlsAskGuys Widgets     Help Us Improve!   RSS Feeds
Home
Videos
Partners
Search Questions
Terms of Use, Privacy
Help, New Members
About Us
Contact Us, Send Feedback
Sitemap
Advertise With Us
Resources
Post your questions on your blog, website, or any social networking page. You can embed into MySpace, Facebook and more. Click here for more info.
Have a suggestion? See a problem on the site? Click here to give feedback and suggestions on the new GirlsAskGuys, and help us give you a better experience. Visit our blog here
 Subscribe
Add to My AOL
Add to Google Reader or Homepage
©2009 girlsaskguys.com™. All Rights Reserved.