I was just wondering if people believed in evolution. I personally do as I am studying in a field of science. Being agnostic, I am just unable to see how people can believe in creationism not that I am denouncing it or anything. There was a similar question but it didn't have a poll so I figured I'd do one.
WOOPS! I pressed the wrong one...I'm for evolution all the way.
There are some many questions like...what came first? The chicken or the egg? Well that answer is quite simple...the egg.
Why did the chicken come from the egg? Because eggs came before chickens...lizards came first, evolved from fish that moved to land (dating of fossils proves this). Now call me crazy but lizards lay eggs...hmm. There we go the egg came firstt and the chicken was a mutation of a whatever animal layed that egg.
Simple. I don't believe in creationism one little bit! Science may not explain everything, and why is that? Science can't find every signle fossil of every single animal that lived on this earth...because it's totally unrealistic to expect every animal's skeleton to have fossilised. It's completely ridiculous for people to go...oh you can't explain this from a science point of view...there for GOD did it.
There's a lot of things religion can't explain...did the bible talk of dionsoars? Did it talk about the earth being this unhabitable rock in the middle of space with no life on it? NO! The bible says the earth was created in seven days...ok science disproved this. Eath formed over millions and billions of years...how is the bible going to explain that?
The bible makes no mention of neaderthals, and yet the inhabited this earth for close hundreds of thousands of years before cromagons (us) arrived. Go figure.
Another reason I don't believe in creationism...religious people change or "mold" what the bible says to suit the current science knowledge of the time. I mean, years ago christians believed in demons, who would posed people and witchs and now they say demons mentioned in the bible are simply metaphors for peoples inner demons... Excuse me while I laugh. Way to mold it to suit the times...I mea if creationism is the whole truth...christians should still believe in witches and demons that poses people and not just in rare cases...back in the time of salem witches...this was a strong beleif all christians believed.
Personally having been raised Catholic I was able to experience 'a little of both' and decided I disagreed. Being atheist I do not mean to quash anyone else's beliefs and I hope that with time they will learn to understand or accept my beliefs also.
well, its actually both. there are some things science can't explain. so there has to be something else that made everything. like you can't make a tree without the seed. where did the seed come from? science can't make it. so something (or someone) else made it.
its complicated. you can't have one without the other. you may try hard to get science to figure out everything but it can't. somethings can't be figured out, no matter how hard you try. so something (or someone) made it. that's just it.
Where did that something else come from? How did God just appear? Using your logic, surely something must have made God? But what made the something make God? - 6 months ago
Answerer
Thats the thing! who made what? did god just come out of nowhere (like the "Big bang" theory) where did he come from? who made what? science can't explain these phenominas so their has to be faith. that someone out there is making things happen. someone (or some power) is making all these things. people use faith cause that's all there is. no evidence that their is a god but there is something (or someone) who has there hand in this and controlling the outcome. - 6 months ago
Question Asker
Faith can't explain it either. Thus my point of if God made everything, then who made God? Does God have his own God? In that case, who made God's God? - 6 months ago
Answerer
Who knows? you can never find out. that's why people believe something that's unexplainable. no one knows where god came from so they believed that he was real. so they can have something to have faith in. maybe gods real. maybe not. but the christians (and others) made someone they think have all the power to create all of everything. everyone needs something to believe in. so, most people want the unexplianable explianed. so they created someone who can make everything else. - 6 months ago
Question Asker
You just said God was created by man. Thank you very much. - 6 months ago
N/A
When: 8 months ago
I believe in both. They're not wholly separate. I don't get why people don't believe they can't exist together.
I believe in both... in some weird way..We know from evolution that the world used to be some empty planet with an atmosphere that couldn't sustain life, then suddenly little bacteria started existing. I think that evolution wouldn't have happened without some sort of outside force causing these specific two cells or whatever from fusing together and reproducing to make a totally new and different cell.
I don't think it's fair to say "we know" that anything just "started existing" out of nowhere. That is not at all what scientists have proved through evolution. - 9 months ago
Personally I think its a bit a both. I don't believe man came from monkeys per say but I think our structure may have adapted to the world that keeps changing. Like mamoths and elephants.Our planet is getting hotter so why need the extra hair? I believe in God but I guess you can say iI believe in adaption if anything. And maybe the universe was a big bang...created by God
If you believed in God, you would understand that tumors and all that is ugly and wrong with this world is a result of sin. But since we disagree on that one crucial point, that answer obviously won't please you.
So you are saying everyone with a disease or an ailment is a sinner. So much for Jesus dying for your sins. You accept him as your savior and there is still a very good chance you'll end up with some disease. Seems like he died for no reason. - 11 months ago
Answerer
I'm saying that EVERYONE is a sinner, regardless of health, age, race, etc. Every single person on the earth has sinned. And yes, there is always a chance you will end up with a disease, but for eternity, I know I'm going to heaven. And Jesus did not stay dead- He rose, and that's the most important part of that story. Because there is sin in the world, Jesus came to atone for everyone's sin, to cover it from God's eyes, to redeem us. You just have to accept that redemption. - 11 months ago
Wow your religion sounds very macabre. I thought all sinners can be forgiven. If you know you are going to Heaven, are you forgiven than I guess? - 8 months ago
I believe in intelligent design. Why? Because I have faith and because looking at the wonders of science, as you are doing, you have to wonder if it was all on accident. Is the universe the way it is because of millions of accidents? If you believe in the Big Bang Theory, where did that stuff come from? Whether you believe in that, Theistic Evolution, or Intelligent Design, it's hard to deny that there is some sort of higher being that designed us and the world we live in. We're the right distance from the sun, we're the exact tilt the earth needs to be at, we have the right amount of water, the right atmosphere, look at one skin cell and tell me it's not amazing. It did not happen by chance.
living things come from other living things. not *poof* and its there. things change and adapt for survival. people claim that doctors healing people is a miracle. but it comes through science! why doesn't God heal crippled people? why are there homeless people and starving and diseased people!? WHY won't God, who Creationists claim is loving, just, peaceful, kind, and helpful, heal them or help them!? Creationists come up with a few answeres to explain questions like that because, even though the answer (using logic) is not probable or possible, they are uncomfortable with having a question that is not answered about God. they say 'God must have a specific purpose for that (crippled, starving, etc.) person. that is why they are the way that they are.' or, to answer the question of why something is the way that it is or a why? question 'because God made it that way.' Creationists think 'God made it. he is all powerful and all knowing. who are we to question this great God? we have no right to disobey and think or wonder at other answers.' Creationists either are people who don't want to think of dying and losing forever the good things that they have (so they have faith that life will be great in heaven and that they will still have a great life) or their life is not a good as they would like it and they want to have a hope for a better life. they do not want to face it that their life isn't the greatest. they want God to fix everything for them.
in my OPINION, those who are not satisfied with their life need to work to change it on their own. don't rely on someone else to help you get out of bad situations.
please do not take me as being closed minded. I am open to listening to any religion. there may be a God. I have just learned from my past experiences that faith in something may waste your life away. I tried to have faith. I tried to believe that one day someone would come along and fix everything. but when my life stayed the same, I realized that if I wanted it to get better, I had to work for it and change it myself.
i have a hard time seeing why someone would trust science over God. science theories have been proven wrong, but God hasn't. really man is behind science as some point so you are also choosing to trust a sinful being more than God. I think it takes more "faith" to believe in evolution than creation. I've seen God work in my life and other peoples lives so I know He is real. there are so many beautiful sights to see that only Gods Hands could have made. I've heard facts from both sides and my belief still remains with creation. there is way too much proof God exists not to believe in it.
But science laws have been proven correct while God hasn't. At least that's the way I see it rather than science being proven wrong. - More than a year ago
Answerer
No its the opposite way around. there is proof in nature and in my life and in other peoples lives of God. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
Coincidental proof has no factual basis. There was this one time I had to poop and so I missed my ride. 10 minutes later that car crashed and the passenger side was wrecked. By "God" making me poop, he saved my life. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Well I don't believe in coincidences or luck..i believe it was God. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
I guess God gave me diarrhea and not the ice cream (lactose intolerant) I had earlier that day. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Well you can believe what you want, but I know the truth. - More than a year ago
You have to see it farther thru... God allowed you to be Lactose intolerant so the day you meant to be in a car wreck, he decided this person has a purpose, that has yet to be fullfilled.
I could have been to merely tell the world about that day. Only God knows. Realize, that God is the reason for science. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
No I am lactose intolerant because it runs in the family. I didn't become lactose intolerant for that one day. If God can see the future, then in his eyes, my purpose should have already been fulfilled and therefore I should have no reason to live as will everyone else. So he should just blow the world up because everyone that has a purpose has fulfilled it and everyone who doesn't, will just go on suffering for the rest of life. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Not everybody has fuffilled their purpose. I don't think you get the point that is trying to be made. if you had God in you then you'd understand. everything that happens has a reason. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
I think it is you who doesn't understand what I just said. - More than a year ago
I choose C! Raised to believe the story of creation happened as it is written, I found it difficult to swallow with all the scientific research that has been accomplished. I went back to college to study astrophysics, and the data that has been produced is vary swaying (evolution). What I want to say is why are we forced to believe in a literal interpretation? If God was explaining creation to an uneducated man, wouldn't the story as presented in Genesis be the best way to tell it? I believe in God, no doubt there, but I have a problem with taking everything literally. When we explain things to children, we explain them in steps, same thing with the Spirit inspired word of God. I've also found those who do study science in depth do believe in God, just not the spoofed version most of society accepts. I also believe this version puts limits on God that aren't required to believe in the same all powerful God. My God is big enough to handle it all. evolution and creation. That's why I don't worry about it too much. I find people who are so stuck on creation they can't be open enough to all the scientific fact, they really have a very small God who doesn't want them to learn about the world around them. Sad!
I choose B, creatonism. there is nothing like evolution its all fake. there is no time humans were primate. Charles Darwin is just lying from his nose. I believe that there is a higher authority, someone who can take life and also give life. We just have to look back at our life and see that there is a total supernatural being in charge of our lives. Evolution theory is what a scientist made up at the lab. But for creatonism there is so much proof and I have so much testimony to tell the world. We relly do have a Saviour but we must ask HIm into our life if we need Him. People don't ask Him into their life until its too late. one story There was one day I went for a haircut and barber started saying that there is no god,if there is a god why are people so homeless,sick and dying. I kept quiet. After he finished giving me a haircut. when I was going home I saw people with overgrown hair and long beard looking so dirty. I came back to him and I told him that there are no barbers because I saw people with bushy hairs and he told me that people don't come to get thier hair cut. I was like hmmn people also don't come to God for salvation that's why they are sick and dying. Hahaha
There are a lot of sick people who believe in God. If you go by what you say, everyone who believes in God and a Saviour should never be sick. And to say you have testimony to tell the world is just a laugh. There are theories to support both sides. Just one side requires more "faith" than the other. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Okay, whatever you say. I don't really care about other peoples belief, I only do care about mine. I am so sorry for answering your question. I want to withdraw my answer. - More than a year ago
So all those bones that are 2 million years old and show the progression of the human skeleton are just made up? In fact Creationism is not science. It was created by the people who very much in fact were opposed to Charles Darwin's ideas in their children's text books. What these people are doing are replacing science with religion. Wait I thought church and state were suppose to be different? There's nothing wrong with accepting science and faith. It's better than turning a blind eye to it. - More than a year ago
Answerer
We all know that its not science. They did those things because they have proofs and Charles doesn't even have any. - More than a year ago
Fossils are so true because they helped to discover about Jesus and in short artifacts really helped to find out the truth. People might go about doubting it. But everyone will not always be the same. some people love to follow the right way and some love to follow the darkness. It doesn't really matter, we are still one world under one sun. - More than a year ago
Answerer
I knew that some people will definitely oppose my comment. It doesn't matter at all - More than a year ago
Science every time. I have never believed in creationism or the idea of a greater being. Nor do I believe in the after-life, anything spiritual, vaguely religious, any god, ghosts. etc. I believe that the Bible especially is a moral text which some have interpreted in a literal sense. I want to spend my life living for the now, not living a God-fearing (or Satan-fearing) life worrying about what will happen when I die. When I die I will be buried in the ground or burned and my ashes will be sprinkled somewhere pretty so that I will be part of nature. I think nature is such a beautiful wonderous thing in itself that has occurred over millions of years and that is spectacular enough for me without having to worship a being I have never seen and have no evidence of or faith in. I will, however, and do respect and listen to the opinions of anyone else.
Your body will be buried but your soul won't be. Your body will be seriously burn in ashes but your soul won't be there. And by the way you need to go on a research to find out the oldest book in the world. - More than a year ago
Why wouldn't it be laughable. Sometimes it feels good to laugh at your foolishness. like they always say " He who laughs last, laughs best". Funny haha....... - More than a year ago
Answerer
Why are you so convinced that people have "souls"? And, as for things "seriously" burning - surely things either burn or they don't. And I know what the oldest book in the world is, I also know what the oldest profession in the world is. Age doesn't make something right and true. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
The Bible isn't the oldest book in the world. The first bible was made in 397 AD. The oldest book is said to be the Vedas. - More than a year ago
N/A
When: More than a year ago
I did not want to put this as it might sound. But isn't it better to believe in creationism and that a higher power such as God did create the earth and accepting him to go to heaven. Because if you don't you can end up below. What I'm saying is, it's better to believe then when we die, and possibly find out the truth to find out it's too late for you to now say you are a believer. If there was no God then you would have nothing to worry about either way. But if you didn't believe and there is one, what do you think the consequences would be? So I choose B. Also, there are too many miracles, that I have personally seen that you can't put all of them down as consequences.
I don't think you could have said it better! that is a great point and no one will ever lose in the end when God is in their life. in Him the battle is already won! - More than a year ago
I chose C, simply because neither evolution nor creationism seem to really explain everything for me. I suspect it's impossible to really "know" the truth about where we came from or why.
I don't believe a being [a god] suddenly decided to create us because that just doesn't make sense to me. There a lot of questions I have about that line of thinking. And I also don't believe that we evolved from animals because even though we seem so closely related, that explanation just doesn't explain why humans are so distinctly different, why we seem to have this "soul". How could that have just popped up in the evolution chain? Basically neither seem believable to me, I believe it's impossible to know for sure, and for the most part I'm okay with not knowing. :]
Ok so if we weren't created by God and we aren't from monkeys...how did you get here? - More than a year ago
Answerer
I already addressed that. I said that I believe it's impossible to know. I don't have any actual theories about it. I don't feel that I need to know how I got here in order to enjoy my life, I'm fine with not knowing. - More than a year ago
I believe in God without him in my life my mom would have never been cured from depression. I saw her with my own eyes almost commit suicide now you tell me.when she turned to God who helped release her from her personal demons. I've lived a hard life but through god and jesus christ I have overcome many of my own struggles. I encourage you to really examine your life and seek truth because there is a god out there who loves us and calls us.
I definitely believe in evolution, there's no real proof of creationism except for the bible, which wasn't even meant to be taken literally (for instance, women can't wear jewelry.yes, I saw it in there).
I suggest reading that passage in full... What you read was in the old testament, which is set in a time of living by the "law". We now live by the grace of Jesus Christ.
Sincerely, A Loving Black Man - More than a year ago
Answerer
I still believe in evolution..there's way too much proof of evolution not to. - More than a year ago
Definitely Faith.to be honest I don't like over the top religious people that try to persuade you what is right and that you are wrong, to me that's not what Christianity is all about. I think everyone has the right to believe what they want, there are SO many beliefs and theories out there, I think the basis of them all would have some truth to them. .I just know having faith in god has gotten me through a lot of things, I know he's helped me, and I know he's there. Living the way he wants, has made my life easier, its hard to do, but I think the underlying morals behind his ways are in our best interest. but even though I have been taught these things in my life as my family are Christian, I know god will lead me the way he wants and what he believes is best for me, I don't think it's necessary to be what other 'Christians' believe you should be. because when it comes down to it, we are all human. Who says what someone else believes is right, it's when people follow people that things become corrupt and wrong.You have to make up your own mind, what you think is right, an educated decision of course, but I think it's the underlying morals that count. faith gives you hope through the hard times, knowing there's someone else out there promising you that things will get better and will actually get you there. ultimately it's a beautiful thing knowing that there's a 'heaven' and you get to live eternally in a place that's not corrupt.
What an interesting question. being in science and rather agnostic myself I totally see where you're coming from. But if you think about about it, science does offer a pretty bleak view of life, we're born we die, just as everything else in the universe will - that's pretty much all there is, nothing else after. Understandably many people are not going to like that view and want to hope and believe that there is something else, something omniscient to ease the sense of insecurity and pointlessness that science can create. Wow, the amount of debating/arguments you can get out of this topic is absolutely amazing hey. Anyway, that's just my thinking.
I was raised Catholic and went to a Catholic school for nine years, and I think I believed in everything I was taught then, but now I consider myself agnostic. I think a person named Jesus existed, but that's all I'm sure about. I never believed in Hell or the devil; if man was given free-will, we choose to do wrong, the devil is just an excuse. I think the bible is just a book, and I could write a book, so it's just not that spectacular to me. I do believe in angels, but that came after my grandfather died when I was already agnostic, so I don't consider it a religious thing for me.
I respect the beliefs of others (my entire family is still Catholic after all), and sometimes I do believe in God, but religion isn't a big part of my life, and I don't think there's anything wrong with that.
I pray one day you find what you are looking for to once ago have you believe. The bible is more than just a book. Its actually the oldest book on the planet. It is a collection books and lessons to help us understand the truth about life.
Sincerely, A Loving Black Man - More than a year ago
Question Asker
The Bible is not the oldest book on the planet. You need to do more research other than listening to a priest. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Honestly, I'm not working towards believing again. I'm pretty apathetic towards God. If he exists, great, if not, I don't really care. I'm happy as I am--and much happier than when I did practice religion. I have nothing against practicing, it's just not for me. I would be considered a "good Christian" despite the fact that I don't define myself as Christian. Having God in my life wouldn't change anything for me. - More than a year ago
How do you know if you don't ask? nothing will change if you don't want to, but great things can happen if you do. Also not to sound morbid, but believing in god will change whether we will live eternally in heaven or eternally in hell when we die...no-one just dies. we live on one way or the other. it may not be true, but if it is, I wouldn't want to be living in hell, especially the way it's described in the bible. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
When you are on your deathbed, just ask Jesus for forgiveness for all your sins and give the church some money and you are sure to go to Heaven if it exists. - More than a year ago
Answerer
I said right in my post that I never believed in Hell, so either way, it doesn't matter to me.
I also said that I respect the beliefs of others, so I don't know why anyone's saying anything to me about my beliefs. What I said applies to me alone--if you don't like it, fine, but you don't have to try to convince me to put my faith in God. If anyone's going to do that, it will be me. - More than a year ago
If you were to have God in your life and not be changed I question even having Him because no one can have Him and not be changed! - More than a year ago
Its not so much of me trying to change you & make you believe. Its the love that God has created within me to love my enemies. Love my neighbor. To go against that, make me feel . . . lost. Its all love. I'm sorry if I made you feel offended. Take care.
Sincerely, A Loving Black Man - More than a year ago
Explain why the Bible has never been proven wrong. How things in the book Revelation has been proven factual over and over again. Study both, you can't just study one and assume the other one is wrong. Look at nature. How is there no creator? Think it over.
Yup I agree with you on that! - More than a year ago
Question Asker
The Bible has been proven wrong plenty of times. It says the world was created in 6 days roughly 10,000 years ago. If that's true, then dinosaurs that date millions of years ago were never created. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Plenty of times huh? Is that whole "created in 6 days" thing a fact or a theory? - More than a year ago
Question Asker
You said the Bible was never proven wrong. Even if its theory, its still proven wrong. - More than a year ago
Answerer
A theory is not a fact, it's an experimental base. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
So the bible is based on an experimental base. - More than a year ago
Answerer
The Bible is not a science book, yet it is scientifically accurate. If the Bible is not true or if it is filled with errors, Christianity would only be a “blind faith” something people believe without any evidence to support it. Christianity is not a blind faith. It is the only religion that can prove itself, and a main source of that proof is the Bible. One of the strongest arguments for the accuracy of the Bible is its 100% accuracy in predicting the future. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
I see I see. The bible is so accurate. Just like me. I predicted when I was 10 that natural disasters would kill many people. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Look in Revelation. Look at the crazy stuff it says, I don't think someone would just put that in there. That there will be an anti-Christ, and he will have many powers but there will be a battle. Check it out. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
I skimmed it and couldn't find anything factual. It was all vague. A two year old can make vague descriptions that will come true. - More than a year ago
It's your choice, but I mean. It's your comfort that you're putting on the back burner. Think it over feel it out. Can't explain why I almost died 3 times. Can't explain why I can cry for hours and then the one minute in prayer after being dumped for the first time, I can have complete and utter joy. I have that child like faith, it's not my parents faith. I used to be atheist. I found it out for myself, I don't like brain washing either. - More than a year ago
By
Question Asker
God made you almost die 3 times. I doubt you were an atheist. You may not have believed in god but that doesn't make you an atheist. - More than a year ago
By
Answerer
I was wasting my life, God opened my eyes. I got things out of it like: I am here for a reason, and you know bad things happen in life so people notice the good things- the blessings we receive. Now that I'm doing my best to let go and give God my control he has blessed me. If I want more "attractive characteristics" such as being more patient, God will not give me patience, he will give me opportunities to become patient. Ex. breaking up. Now I think to myself, "what now?" (beauty from pain) - More than a year ago
Umm... you really haven't done much study into the book. Here's a simple one, the bible says Pi=3 in 2 different places. This is mathematically wrong. Since it is a proportion, it doesn't matter what number system you use, it's still wrong. The Gospels don't agree on Genealogy of Joseph nor do they agree on the day of the crucifixion (day before passover vs the day after). You would figure they would at least get that one right. Since both can't be true....
Check your sources, I'll wait... - More than a year ago
Haha..i love this question asker many of the things it says in the bible cannot be proven true at all..(like the dinosaurs for example, fossils dating back way before 10 000 years) maybe if you read something other than the bible, you'd have some knowledge as to how things actually work - More than a year ago
By
Question Asker
Thank you lalalove. I love you too. - More than a year ago
N/A
When: More than a year ago
Genesis 1- 3. Everything starts and ends with God. He is more real than all of us. But even at this very moment there are millions of new stars, even galaxy's being birthed. THere still are constant changes happening all the time. And this huge GOd, the creator of all loves me more than Himself, that he would of offered His son to die for me. It blows my mind.
Science is science! Faith is faith! The two do not combine very well although a lot of people make them combine! There are so many things in this world we haven't discovered yet and so many things involve with it - it is religion and faith. I can't say I believe in evolution because all evolution is - is a stupid big bang theory - how the heck can you say that some zones and rocks have come together and created space that just sounds absurd. And that we evolved from monkeys - yes we are definitely distinctly related to them somehow but sorry I don't look like a monkey (although they are very cute) and I do want one but besides the point, evolution to me does not exist.
As for creationism yea that is just all either made up or spoken by the church for people to believe in something, anything - we really don't know which religion is true - I mean every religion is based on another or stolen from another to clarify the meaning behind the story of how the earth really came to be and what people don't realize is that the first religion ever to exist was Judaism - I mean that religion is over 4, 000 years old and people criticize it. Christianity - well that should be understandable how old it is - 2008 years old as for Islam younger than both of these, other religions such Buddhism and Hinduism and such and such are all created for people to reach some kind of enlightenment or something else to believe in. Each criticizes the next and each says the other one is full of bull (excuse the term).
As far as I go in believing in something it would have to be god - yea I know I just all religions are bull (excuse the term) but I didn't say I believe in religions, I only believe in god! I mean these are my opinions others may have different ones but what can I do - we all believe in what we think is right, in what we think we studied is the true existence of evidence of how the earth really came to be. But we'll find out the truth only when we die that I know for sure!
Well, maybe you can find out if you do one of those between past lives regression! :) Now, are you saying Christianity is the oldest religion? There are quite a few others that go back thousands of years; I would even say Christianity got the concepts from these older religions. Is just that Christians don't like to hear that. - More than a year ago
Christianity did spring up from another religion- Judaism. Jesus was a Jew. It's really cool go back and look at the Jewish prophesies of the Old Testament and see how they compare to Christ. Compare Psalm 22 with Matthew 27 if you get bored. Psalms was written a thousand years before Christ. It's pretty crazy
Christianity isn't about religious rituals and doctrinal dogma. It's simply about trusting in Jesus alone for salvation, and following His simple teachings- to love God and love other - More than a year ago
Actually, Hinduism and many traditional/tribal religions predate Judaism by at least a few thousand years. And of course you don't look like a monkey now (although at the skeletal level the similarities are striking) but go back 30 million years and your ancestors probably did. It's been about 5-7 million years since we shared an ancestor with chimps, so that's a lot of time to change! - More than a year ago
Answerer
To annwyl-cariad we don't know that just cause we discovered these things doesn't mean we actually came from monkeys and if your talking about the Mayans and all the other tribal yea they are not really that old cause if you think about it humanity didn't start at one section of the earth - while 1 thing was going on at this part another was going on at the other part of the world I could be wrong but think about it when Columbus discovered America he thought Native Indians were Hindus... - More than a year ago
Excuse me? Hinduism has been practiced in India for about 7,500 years. I'm not sure what Columbus's thoughts about the Native Americans have to do with this. Tribal religions far predate the major religions of today. Heck, the Hebrew Tanakh talks about the gods of other people in the area, so those religions must be at least as old as Judaism! Your arguments are non sequiters. Take a comparative religions class sometime, I think you'll find it quite enlightening. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Hey I don't really care it's all you people who are so obsessed with this stuff & all this to me is just plain idioticism now that's an interesting religion - your the 1 whos getting all personal about it so to me its whatever I like to learn but if your taking 1 theory from 1 and you hear another theory from the other - all that will do to you is mess up your brain - I try to look at things in a positive way if I hear something interesting I like it and search it out but this who knows when well know - More than a year ago
Answerer
(continuing) the real truth about everything that weve discovered - life is just 2 big theories creationism & evolution but its a persons choice to choose whichever I'm sorry but I just like to believe in things as they are & for you apparently this is very personal -my belief is if I see it, touch it & feel it than its real & columbus (I was just saying) & no don't feel like taking a religious class like I said each teaches you something that's not true oh & question how do we know that all this is... - More than a year ago
Answerer
(still continuing) whatever you like to study - the big bang theory and evolution and such is true? yes there are proofs apparently archaeologists who've studied how long this is and that but how does it all fit in w/the bible studies maybe I'm not making my argument here (probably not) but seriously I guess well know when we die but yea forget what I said about not taking that class I just researched Hinduism does exist for 7500yrs it is very interesting! - More than a year ago
I didn't mean to sound like I was taking this personally...I'm not. I'm just a natural debater. And I like to encourage people to seek things out and learn. If you don't choose to take the early chapters of Genesis as literal truth and instead interpret them figuratively, that opens the door to the possibility of the Big Bang and evolution. Whatever you choose to do or believe is fine. But I definitely encourage the religions class...I took one last year and it was absolutely fascinating! - More than a year ago
Yeah, I'm definitely a believer in evolution. Honestly, I'm not sure how people can continue to deny it either. (If you find it relevant, I'm studying primeatology). But I'm also Catholic. See, the way I see it, belief in evolution does not have to preclude belief in God. Some people, the majority of my (Baptist) family included, believe that the earth and everything on it was created in seven days. I've given up trying to convince them that it's possible to believe otherwise and not be an atheist.
But really, I think that while God could have just said "Let there be stuff" and made the world (heck, He wouldn't have even had to take seven MINUTES if He didn't want to), isn't it so much COOLER that He took billions of years to shape the world into what it is today? And to think that He's not done, that He's still working through the process through which the world came to be as it is? A God that is always working through evolution to shape the world around us? A God that doesn't try to make us discard scientific evidence in order to believe in Him? Now that's a powerful God, a God that I would love to devote my life to! And that's the kind of God I believe really exists.
So you say you believe in "God". So what God do you believe in? Obviously not the God of the Bible, because "that" God created it in 6 days. And actually, really easy to deny evolution. Because science points to a young earth. It doesn't point to billions of years like scientists claim. I'm not saying you're an atheist if you believe in evolution. But you definitely don't believe in the God of the Bible. Because either the Bible is 100% right or its wrong. - More than a year ago
Answerer
But I do believe in the God of the Bible. But the first chapter of Genesis can be interpreted either as six literal days or six figurative days. 2 Peter 3:8. "But do not ignore this one fact, beloved, that with the Lord one day is like a thousand years, and a thousand years are like one day." Time isn't the same for God. What is a day to Him isn't quite like a day to us. - More than a year ago
Answerer
I don't see why some Bible stories can't be interpreted as figurative. Doesn't make them less true in their essence. Don't get me wrong, I have a immense amount of respect for you, Jarett, but on this issue we'll have to disagree. Just because I believe in evolution doesn't mean I don't believe in the crucifixion, or the resurrection. It's the "100% right or 100% wrong" argument that irritates me. Just because a story is figurative doesn't make it false. Truth goes deeper than literal fact. - More than a year ago
I think it was a literal 6 days. Yes, the Jews did have yearly Sabbaths and stuff, but their main thing was the weekly Sabbath rest- on the 7th day on the week. Also, in Genesis, it says "It was morning, then it was evening. the first day." To me, it sounds like one literal day, since there's only one evening and one morning mentioned. Buuut I do believe that salvation lies on our faith in Christ, not our views on the interpretation of the word "day." - More than a year ago
The Bible can be interpreted billions of different ways. That's why we have cults. The problem is, is that people that believe in God are swayed by biased scientists who have an agenda. Don't believe everything you hear. You don't have to believe in science OR the Bible. They don't contradict like some scientists want you to believe. They are quick to point out "evidence" for evolution, and then later have to take back what they said because the evidence was fake or had a diff explanation. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
Religion also has an agenda and are quick to denounce evidence with "facts" from a book that was written by people. - More than a year ago
Answerer
I've said this before, and I'll say it again. Everyone is biased. Everyone has an agenda. Even you, even me. We could go on about this all week, but I've found that it's impossible to change a person's strongly held opinion via a discussion on a website. And obviously, you and I both have strongly held opinions on this issue. But that's okay. I agree with you that you don't have to choose between science and faith. But I've just reconciled them differently than you. - More than a year ago
So you are basically making your own "god" up here? - More than a year ago
N/A
When: More than a year ago
I vote creationism. I don't really understand the big bang theory. I was always taught that two giant rock-like masses smashed into one another, and kablamo, earth and such formed.but where did those rocky masses come from if that is the case?
Well if God created the Earth who created God? And if God is and always has been why is it an impossibility to believe that "matter" of any kind always has been? - More than a year ago
Grace86..if someone created God then christians would be worshipping that person. its hard to comprehend because it is complex for our minds, but He really just always was there. - More than a year ago
idk bro depends on yourself you being agnostic don't believe in God so you can't really get it you know.. it might be stupid for rational people but I personally think there is a God I don't know things are too perfect expecially in someones life and that's one of my main reasons in believing in God
god is for weak people strong people know the only thing you should believe in is yourself
first off Id like to say I have tried my hand at church (dad teaches sundayschool and mom is a priest yes she can be a priest in the episciplechurch)
I only say this because in my eyes most religous people have no reason to believe in a god other than the fact that they're told to and then percieve things that happen by chance to be work of god whether it be big or small things like a deeply religous friend told me how he was going to take this one route but instead he "felt" he shouldnt and then there was a car pile up and he says god subconsciously warned him...
I think old time religous leaders deserve to be on the same list as Hitler and Stalin I mean what's so different they got people to kill people so their ideas would be excepted what's so different Hitler declared war on the world and enforced it with killings stalin had millions killed The church has claimed just as many lives if not more than them If you don't believe me than study some history please besides the crusades in which one of them I forget which they came across a village and killed all the inhabitants and then ate them fun huh
"When the Lord your God brings you into the land you are entering to possess and drives out before you many nations . . . then you must destroy them totally. Make no treaty with them, and show them no mercy." that's just one of my favorite quotes from what my religous background has taught me sounds like a merciful god now huh
You can't disprove fairies You can't disprove witches but they can't be real right You can't disprove god either but so many people know its/he's real but how ask a religous person if you want to p*ss them off then you get to hear their memorized sunday school lesson
Just because we can't explain all of evolution doesn't mean it doesn't exist or that a greater being created everything who knows maybe we're just an experiment from a far older and knowledgable alien specie
I along with most scientisit believe that it is impossible to have something come from nothing. Evolution has traces that date back as far as religion began and even further...no offense to any religious people out there who believe in "Creation" bu it just can't be true...
I don't believe in evolution nor do I need to. It is a verifiable fact that be easily shown to anyone who is willing to look at the research in any one of a dozen different scientific fields.
People believe in creation because they want to believe they are special and live forever. These things are not remotely related. When the question of creation comes up, simply reframe it as "do these people have the right to inflict their religious beliefs on other people's children?". If the answer is "no", the issue is settled.
Think of it this way if you don't believe in God your going to hell but wait if you don't believe in any other cultures God your going to hell. How can you go to Heaven or Hell if your going to go to hell either way you look at it. What about the Indians, the Romans, the Greeks, they had many many Gods so what happened to them, did they go to hell if so how? They believed in many Gods not just one, so if they thought there were many Gods then how were they wrong, and why would they go to hell? What about the cavemen where are they, did they even have a religion if not then if they didn't know any religion existed then how are they wrong and are they supposed to be in hell?
I have wondered this for a while and the only logical explanation of where we came from is from primates. If a wild animal dies there's no heaven or hell for them, how could there be, all they are programed to do is survive and keep the species alive, uh oh wait a minute now, what does that sound like kind of like us right, we get jobs to feed ourselves to make money, we reproduce to keep our family going, and to keep the human race going. So if you think about it early man was just like a wild animal, were they not? Well they died out and evolution took place and it will still continue to take place long after we are gone.
So I don't know it seems that evolution makes more sense but then again what if there is a superior being if anyone really knew the answer the debate between evolution and religion would be solved.
I believe in God and I believe He created the world. Exactly how He created the world, I have no idea. However, as a scientist as well, I also feel quite confident that evolution does in fact occur, but evolutionary theory fails to suffiently explain the origins of life, or the diversity of species for me. It still has major gaps, so to speak. So micro-evolution is proven. Macro-evolution is still in the theory stages in my opinion. I do not believe in literal creationism by any means though. I see the creationist story in the Bible as more of an allegory.
Lol someone saying "science theories have been proven wrong, but God hasn't.".
HAHA
Don't people know how science work !?!?! What the hell is the problem. If theories would never be proved wrong we would be living on flat planet that sun goes around.
THEORIES MUST BE THE KIND THAT IT IS POSSIBLE TO PROVE THEM WRONG !
If theory can't theoretically be proved wrong, it is not a theory. This is what these "ID" people don't understand. Well one of the things they don't understand. "Falsifiability" "Scientific Method" the way science works. Well is it stupidity or bad education, I think a mix of those.
"Look at the eye, in its perfection" Many need classes "Look at jaw how perfect it is" This wisdom-tooth is killing me. "Look at the cell, how perfect it is" Well this one is on rampage, I think it is cancer. "Look at the brain, its complexity its perfection" And how damn many things can go wrong up there.
I would fire that designer.
And best of all "Look at banana how perfectly it fits in human hand"
I understand you don't believe what I believe, but in this case, I urge you to leave room for error. Just as these scientist have left themselves room for error.
Don't go so far to prove wrong, or so far in disbelieve, that you can't turn back, or change your ideaology.
I do believe that God has created all. Thats my faith & spirit.
My flesh wants to listen to the reason of the world. The world is not getting better, so why would I place my believe with them. They have no clue to the after life. They think they have a clue to the beginning, but that's all theory. They have nothing.
Nothing. Nothing.
Theory, means they are not sure, but have an idea. You know how often theories are proven wrong?
*sigh* I'm amazed at how many times I (and others) have to explain this.
Evolution and creationism are NOT in ANY WAY related. You can believe in evolution and creationism. Evolution is NOT the big bang! Come on people. Not that hard. Furthermore, humans did NOT come from apes as we know them. No one of intellect will ever say they have. You know who DOES? Ignorant Christians. Apes and humans are related in that they both descended from a common ancestor, and their DNA is similar, not because we're the great-great-greatx1000 grandchild of a Baboon.
Evolution essentially says that species change (adapt, evolve) over time to fit their conditions in order to survive. Social Darwinism is NOT evolution. It is people using Darwin's theory of evolution (biology) to define social interactions (sociology). I for one am tired of religion and science being compared -- yes, they're both similar in that they are searching for truth, but religion requires FAITH while science encourages research & discovery. Evolution is not a religion, you cannot 'believe' in it. It, like science itself, is constantly evolving (ehehe) as we learn new things.
Evolution is fact. The only thing up for debate is what evolved from what, what causes specific changes or prevents changes from happening at all, what speeds/slows down the process, etc. Death and birth are both accepted as fact. Genetic mutation is accepted as fact. Evolution is simple genetic mutation occurring over many generations in response to certain environmental factors. Much of the anti-evolution spasms going on are because of zealots who refuse to educate themselves.
For example, creationism is NOT Christianity. However, the Christians have hijacked the title to make you think that it is. Creationism is simply the belief that we were created - by what or whom is not specified. That varies from person to person. According to the Christian doctrine, Evolution isn't possible because God created man at a certain time, a time when man already existed according to modern science. So, to those of you who say that there MUST be a god -- you may be right. No scientist will refute that. He'll certainly say there is no proof either way, but he will only disagree with you when you try to say the Abrahamic god created us from nothing a few thousand years ago.
In a twist of irony, even though the creationists hate evolution for reasons that aren't even valid, the OTHER idea they hate could actually fit in with their theory. The 'Big Bang' theory (which I don't necessarily think is valid) COULD just be the means by which the god of the creationist's made the universe. But try convincing them of that.
In conclusion, evolution is not the big bang. You cannot 'believe' in evolution. Creationism is not Christianity. Creationism does not refute evolution, and evolution does not refute creationism. Neither Darwin nor the theory of evolution says that we descended from apes. We are, however, primates. Just like we're mammals.
i am a very scientific guy but I strongly believe in creation. there is a GOD put there that did create this world. evolution didn't just happen on its own. someone "GOD" had to get things done.
God made planet earth? that's what your saying? - More than a year ago
Answerer
Yes, and he created us as well, we didn't just come out of no where. ofcourse we did evolve, but were always eveolving, thas what people don't see. you start growing and so does ur body. and ur kids cary on ur features. - More than a year ago
When you say this god created "us", are you accepting the possibility that perhaps this god created something else, which we evolved from? Or are you, like many others, determined to think that we are the original and final product of a benevolent creator's divine plan? Also, do you accept the possibility that there is no divine plan, and/or that we will fade away without any special treatment? That we're intellectually superior to animals, but not supernaturally so. If that makes sense. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Well, I wana think that there was something b4 us, that would be cool as hell to find out what it is.
but no, sorry, he created us as humans on his shap and form, from mud may I add. yes we are superior to animals. but do you have any supernatural powers??? if you do, I would LOVE to meet it.
and you lost me by "divine plan". - More than a year ago
You stated that he created "us", then you stated that we evolved -- THEN you said we were created in this shape and form. You contradict yourself, hence my questions. The 'divine plan' comment was referring to the Christian belief that we were created to worship God, die, and go to heaven/hell.
As I see it, the only way a creator could exist is if he created the universe and the things needed to allow life, and then just let natural laws do their thing (as he would have created them to do). - More than a year ago
Answerer
U missunderstood me when I said were always evolving, but its ok.
what I ment by that is that were always becoming better as humans, NOT MONKEIS. we were always humans, another words when adam was created there was no other human, he didn't just see other monkies and started speaking to them, wondering if there was any other creatures like him and then ran into eve. - More than a year ago
Answerer
The reason why GOD gave us a choice weather we wana worship him or not is because if we don't have a choice of loveing and fearing him and doing the right and wrong then none of us should be judged.
think about it : no choices, no concequences. - More than a year ago
couldn't agree more with you. I have done a marine biology degree and am now studying my master. I don't understand how anyone can believe in creationism when it is so apparent with Darwinian theory.
Last I checked, evolution did not contradict creationism itself (the idea that the universe was created by a supernatural being), only most of the teachings that could be considered part of modern creationist theory. Christianity, for example, obviously contradicts evolution and is thus invalid -- but someone saying that we were created and that natural laws determined our past and continue to determine our present and future may still be correct. Or do you disagree? - More than a year ago
Just because you picked evolution doesn't mean that you don't believe in God or the story of Adam and Eve etc. In fact there is a study of evolution that deals with animals and their adaptations over the several million of years. I mean it's pretty common sense that all species were not like they are today so they had to evolve. Proof? Look at the fossils. Pretty rock solid to me.
The problem is that the Adam/Eve story doesn't take into account evolution. God could not have created them from dust if they evolved from something else. Also, as evolution is certainly not instant, they didn't go from pre-human to human in one generation. They were born from something else which would directly contradict the theory that they had no natural parents.
You can believe in a god AND evolution, just not the Christian god combined with the literal interpretation of Adam and Eve. - More than a year ago
Evolution does not state that we came from monkeys. We're cousins rather than father & son. We descended from a common ancestor. Also, creationism does not contradict evolution. Christianity does, but not creationism. Research & knowledge all the way. - More than a year ago
N/A
When: More than a year ago
What does this question have to do with dating and relationships?
you're thinking in the box where there is everything?u never looked outa this box(the universe you live in)if one could what would you see?nah no one can guess but the rules of life and things could be different,in our universe everything should be made by hands in order to exist,maybe out of our box everything just exists some other way.
Science it what brings the world forward, religion is what's holding it back.
And being a man of science, I am an atheist, as God cannot be proven. So the basic methodology of science does not allow "God".
So what do I mean when I say "religion is holding the world back"? A very good example would be stem cell research. This WILL eventually be the standard, and the only reason its use is still limited is because of religious concerns. This, in my eyes, is foolish, and thousands of lives could probably have been saved.
Most people are religious because they've been told about God from a stage in life when they're not able to make up their own opinion. Except for former alcoholics and drug abusers, very few people become christian when they're adults.
I am, of course, ready to stand up for my points of view and ready for any discussion ;)
I agree that religion can holds things back. You have Christians who are trying to figure out whether something new goes against the Bible. But as far as stem cell research, you are killing a life to save another? That brings into play a lot of morals. Who's to say one life is more important then another? But to be honest, having a discussion with you is pointless because you already said God can't be proven. You've already made your decision. No point in discussing anything. - More than a year ago
Answerer
So do you see God as the only argument against stem cell research? - More than a year ago
Stem cells are taken from an embryo which is up to 50 cells I believe. I argue against the view that this is a life. This is a POTENTIAL life as far as I am concerned. Stem cell research is something which has my total backing. - More than a year ago
@Jarett & Grace - Stem cells and embryos aren't life any more than sperm is life. Grace, you used the phrase 'potential life', but I doubt you think a man is committing murder every time an ejaculation ends in anything other than pregnancy to term.
@Hazel - You see what you want to see. As the great Carlin once said, regardless of who you pray to your prayers are answered at the same 50-50 rate. Your success in life can be blamed on your god, but not proven to be his divine will. - More than a year ago
I choose B. I think both have similar backings in that "E" is determined by humans, and "C" is created by humans. It is taught that the people in "C" were lead by GOD to write what they wrote. The bible is a book of Testimonies, where people give you information about what is going on in that time. I take the people from the bibles word over the scientist of today because they actually have the best chance at being correct. Scientist can come up with stats and try to back them with today's reason, but the truth is that they will never know. The bible can be seen as history book. I don't think you can use some of the times it presents, but that's because they had a different time telling system. There are people even today that don't run on our yearly calendar. I know in the end that you have your own decision to make about what you believe.
You say you believe in God, but not the bible. That is impossible. There is no GOD without the bible. Not saying he wouldn't exist, but rather you would not know about him unless he revealed himself to you. That's why I believe he revealed himself to the people of that time. They had nothing to know he existed.
If evolution is the way we entered, then why does it stop now? Where are those Apes that should be evolving? When does E stop?
I do think its possible that GOD has just thought of everything. He created the universe for a reason. He made the stars so far away for a reason. I sincerely hope he shows a sign to make us all believe. God controls this show!
There can be a God without a Bible. Christianity is not the only religion.
If someone were to say that God talked to them and inspired him to write a book, would you follow it religiously and go to war to prove it is the new Bible? Probably not, you would say he was a crazy person or a cultist. What makes the people of years ago any better? - More than a year ago
It's funny that you should call the bible a history book, considering that there is no proof of Moses having existed. There is no proof of the Israelites being enslaved by the Egyptians. Most of what the bible says lacks any proof or even historical documentation. Tell me, how is it that there were no major economical changes when the Jews (who outnumbered the supposed Egyptians) left Egypt? - More than a year ago
It's been said that until lions have histories, tales of the hunt will always glorify the hunter. It's quite valid in this situation. What happened to the people BEFORE Adam/Eve? Oh. Right. Despite PROOF and DOCUMENTATION, Christianity, Judaism, and Islam ignore them.
The bible was NOT a testimony of what was happening at the time, it was written many years LATER from a collection of random journals, myths, and stories spread by word-of-mouth. Kinda like Santa. And the Tooth Fairy. - More than a year ago
How exactly does the bible have a greater chance of being accurate than scientists do? What, because you can't disprove it, it must be true? Typical Christian thoughts. Like someone else said, if a person came to Earth and did the things that Jesus supposedly did, we'd call him an illusionist and stick him in a mental hospital for being a schizo. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Warren, Its alright. You can disprove What God has created. & don't get me wrong, I too question creation. Nothing by scientist is given as FACT. I say this very calmly, because I understand you discontent with what I believe. I urge you to get the facts. These events did take place, and there is evidence of them, you just have to look, just as you did to prove it wrong. Don't be so strong against something to where if your wrong, you can't apologize.
Sincerely, A Loving Black Man - More than a year ago
I believe in a power higher then myself. I was a fall down drunk b4 and nothing and I mean nothing would relive me from my alcoholism.
In my mind I would laugh at the thought of God or a higher power. The best advice I ever got from someone was to pretend to believe in one ( Higher power) if I did not. I took that advice and have been sober for 4 years now. Also who is not to say Evolution was not part of God's plan. I found out in 4 years that it's also ok for me not to understand God's plan or why.
first off there's a lot of people on here that need to read the book 7 ideas that shook the universe. secondly people will believe in whatever they want to believe in as long as it gives them comfort and helps them cope with the things that the human brain cannot comprehend. I personally don't believe in religion for the simple fact that too many wars/ battles as you may call it have stemmed over it. and if I was religious in any way id be a taoist.
We are all getting along here! No one is being personal which is great. Better to discuss religion that to go to war! :) - More than a year ago
Answerer
Yeah, I understand, I just like to discuss topics that are easier to agree on - such as relationships, feelings, etc. However, I'm not opposed to other people discussing it! :) - More than a year ago
I'm sure that, if an agnostic didn't think that evolution was a viable idea, they'd hit Other. Generally, though, when someone is agnostic they don't mind agreeing with proven scientific principles. - More than a year ago
Answerer
You're probably right. I just like having my own special category lol. However, though I agree with most scientific principles, I also entertain the thought that they could be wrong.
Whereas most religious people think 100% no exceptions their religion is right. - More than a year ago
You're Agnostic and you're unable to see how people can believe in creationism? Isn't the point of Agnosticism supposed to be that you accept that anyone of them could be the answer and you think it's just too big of an answer to waste our time fighting wars over? Are you sure you're not just atheist? Or maybe I'm in the wrong religion. Hell if I think the way I do, do I even need a religion to place me in a demographic from which people can judge me without even knowing me?
Being agnostic I don't deny the existence of God. Creationism is based on the bible which I don't support. My answer goes with the one with the most scientific backing. If you notice, all my comments stem from when I ask for some clarity on some points unclear to me, when someone denounces my view or when someone replies to one of my comments . I feel I need to defend my views as they defend theres. Also, Agnosticism is not a religion, its a philosophical view with a variety of meanings. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Ok that's right...maybe I should just quit the human race... - More than a year ago
The Question Asker is confused, creationism is not based on the bible. ;) Thus anything he says regarding it is invalid. No need to worry about what he thinks. - More than a year ago
I only believe in God as our Creator even though I struggle with certain aspects of Christianity or any religion for that matter I guess I always want to ask why? And am always in need of an answer that seems logical to me but even for a time in my life when I left our church I still felt like I had to act morally like a Christian (still choose not to have sex because I felt as though it's wrong before marriage.
As far as moral codes for people who don't subscribe to any particular religion, I've found the 5 Precepts of Buddhism reasonable. The original concepts that the Buddha spoke of were quite interesting, in fact, and are applicable to the lives of everyone regardless of whether or not they believe in God. They're open to interpretation, and it's a philosophy of life rather than a religion.
It's worth looking into if you're ever looking for an alternative view of things. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Thanks for that I'm looking in to it now. - More than a year ago
I am agnostic also and from a scientific perspective I have found that humans choose to use faith as an explanation for those things that cannot be explained. However, on a different level when thinking about our social conditioning it seems that some people just need faith, sometimes people just need something that provides comfort and the thought of some deity of everlasting love and compassion is very comforting, especially in strenuous situations.
To be honest, I hate creationism, too many people's faith revolves around the bible an ancient storybook that may not even be translated right. I mean most people don't understand that this book wasn't even originally written in english and really there is no way of a completely accurate translation and yet treat what is written as gospel (pun intended). They assume that if the bible were wrong their faith is meaningless, and what's ironic is that this is pretty much the same mentality as a scientist.there has to be some kind of proof of existence. It doesn't even begin to cross their mind that maybe God (if one exists) doesn't have a divine plan, or that evolution is part of the divine plan. Maybe God intended for evolution to occur.
Creationism is not Christianity. Christians believe they were created, thus they agree with the theory of creationism, but they don't define it. I agree with your last few sentences about the possibility of a god (if one existed) not having a divine plan, I just find it ironic that you say this after saying you hate the idea that a god possibly created the universe (creationism). I don't discount the notion, but I don't follow it either. If you're agnostic, you're not for or against creationism. - More than a year ago
Answerer
I never said they were the same thing, you just took it that way because it was poorly worded, I guess. I'm not here to write an essay, just quick thoughts. I do hate creationism and I'm not a fan of Christianity either. My following point was an example, dealing with the faith I'm most familiar with to back up my stance on creationism. I don't like it because there is no proof, and it's a concept that is adopted on blind faith. - More than a year ago
Answerer
As for the second point, Agnostic is pretty much the catch-all for fence sitters. Basically I use it to describe myself in the loosest sense of the word, that I don't believe the presence of a God can be explained but am still open to the possibility of one's existence. You're getting caught up on try to categorize my beliefs. To be completely honest, I'm a floater and don't wish to be part of some group. I tell people I'm agnostic to provide them a general idea of what I believe. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Finally, if you're going to point the finger at me, I'm going to point one back at you. You assume that God and Creationism are inextricably linked, which is not true. I can believe in the existence of a God without having to believe in Creationism. Creationism states strictly that all things that exist were substantially created by God. Stupid thinking in my opinion because we bear witness evolution daily. My theory states that a God simply set the chain of events in motion. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Sticking to the definition, this is NOT Creationism as it would recognize a God as being responsible for the beginning of the universe (holding true to the spirit of the definition of God), but not exercising complete omnipotent control. - More than a year ago
Creationism does not demand that the god exercise total control over his creation. Your 'theory' is called 'Deism', which is similar to 'Theism'. Both are under the umbrella of Creationism. Deism states that a god set the universe in motion and left it at that - he observes. He does not interfere. Theists believe that a god set up the universe and has an active role in it, intervening when he chooses.
Under Deism, which is still Creationism, evolution is of course possible. It's rude to point. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
Being agnostic you can be for or against creationism since you can't disprove it or prove it while evolution can be proven to a certain extent. Mainstream Creationism originated from Genesis. And of course it is going to have other branches just like evolution has several branches. Creationism is usually used as described by Genesis. Not always, but usually. Other religions also have doctrines that describe Creationism in their own light. Warren is just oversimplifying Creationism. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
Deism asserts that a supreme being does exist and created the universe but does not interfere. The problem with Deism is that it also asserts that the supreme being gave us the ability to reason which would partially coincide with intelligent design. Actually, it would fall completely under Intelligent Design in one of those subcategories just as your general "creationism" envelopes everything else except for the lack of a supreme being. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
Now there is a difference in creationism, and Creationism. 'C'reationism is a religious belief pertaining to Genesis. I guess taking the word out of context simply confused you.
So now, following your logic, we are left at a fork. Does God exist or not? If he does, its creationism. If he doesn't, its not creationism. That's as simple as it gets but its never that simple. What if, there is no God, but everything were spontaneously generated from nothing? Silly, but you can't disprove that notion - More than a year ago
Answerer
I must have lost you somewhere. I did state that I was Agnostic and thus I don't really accept the existence or non-existence of a God, mainly due to the fact that there's no proof. What I was doing was simply documenting my rationalization. My goal was to make clear that even in the event of a God's existence I do not support Creationism. In the event it was proven that a God does exist I would sway more towards Deism, I guess. - More than a year ago
This is just me trying to classify my beliefs. As I said before, what I believe in doesn't fall into any particular category. I like to think out both sides rationally and when it comes to Creationism, then I don't believe in it from the standpoint that most Christians do. That a God created the world as we see it today because such a theory isn't in sync with evolution. I'm just tired of having my choice of diction attacked rather than the point that I was trying to make. - More than a year ago
By
Answerer
I still maintain that classifying my beliefs is something that I generally don't really concern myself with. All I wish to accomplish is making my point. I'm not looking to be restricted to any group that I would need to fall back on to support it, I don't deal in rigid definitions, I like to play with ideas; they're generally more malleable. Basically I'm just tired of being attacked for my choice of diction rather than my point as both of you have failed to acknowledge it apparently. - More than a year ago
By
Answerer
I wish you both the best of luck in proving that you're smarter than everyone else. - More than a year ago
Lol not quite the website to ask this question. But first you need to look at a few things. First, you need to realize that we all have the same evidence. It's how you interpret the evidence and the bias that you have while looking at it that makes the evidence point a certain way.
Secondly is that people claim science is science and faith is faith. Although this sounds accurate, it's not. Much of science is theories that have been accepted as true because there has been nothing that has disproven the theory. But science is ALWAYS changing. We are always coming up with new developments, new discoveries that are changing old theories and making them obsolete. So saying that science is science and faith is faith is not accurate.
Third, your statement that the Bible is vague is very inaccurate. If you actually read the Bible, you would see names of people, rules, years of rulers, names of cities. The Bible is actually very specific. Not only has it never been proven wrong, archaelogy has proven that it is very accurate. Cities of the Bible have been dug up as well as evidence of the names of people and rulers in the Bible. There are many verses in the Bible that made statements about the world that weren't discoverd by "science" until thousands of years later.
It takes as much faith to believe in evolution if not more faith. How come Darwin's theory of evolution hasn't been proven by fossils? He even said that by now, we should have all this evidence that proves we got here by evolution. And yet we don't. It's just that atheists are just as closed minded as Christians are.
And finally, it's not science vs. the Bible. There are many people that want you to believe that is what it's really about. And it's not at all. You don't have to pick science OR the Bible. Science and the Bible don't contradict. Science just shows what the Bible has been saying all along.
Its evolution vs. creationism which do contradict. The point with the bible being vague was the Book of Revelations making future predictions. And evidence points towards earth that is billions of years old rather than a young earth that is 10 thousand years old. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Well it's how we got here that contradict.Christians do believe in evolution within species, but not that we got here from a pool of germs.But there are many evidence that proves to a young earth.Earths magnetic field for example. It is constantly decaying, and there is no way it is millions or billions of years old. Also there would be no comets.Everytime a comet passes the sun, it disintegrates a little bit. We wouldn't have any if it were billions years old. There are more but I'm out of space - More than a year ago
Question Asker
How would you go about explaining distant stars and quasars which can take thousands to millions to billions of years to reach earth? Is our technology wrong to calculate the speed of light and its intensity? - More than a year ago
Answerer
The problem with your argument is that you're using a self defeating argument. The Big Bang has its own problems with this argument. There is an issue called the Horizon Problem. In order for the Big Bang to happen, different regions of the universe had to start with very different temperatures. And today, if you look at different regions of the universe, they all have almost exactly the same temperature. Even if we give it 20 billion years, light still doesn't have enough time to travel from - More than a year ago
Answerer
One side of the universe to the other side of the universe, to transfer energy to make it all equal temperature. So you can't reject one theory when your theory has the same problem. You have the same issue and the same problem. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
Why are you bringing the Big Bang into this? I never mentioned it. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Because your evolution had to start somewhere. Where else did your germ pool come from if it didn't come from God? - More than a year ago
Question Asker
There are more theories than the Big Bang and God. None of them have sufficient evidence for me to directly support but I have my thoughts. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Ok, well there are tons of evidence that show that the universe is only thousands of years old, not billions. So ANY idea that leads to evolution really is an uphill battle. You have earths magnetic field, you have comets, the rotation of the planets, Jupiters energy, the ocean, the winding of galaxies, not enough stoneage skeletons, history being too short. All of these are consistent with the universe and earth being thousands of years old, not billions. These don't work with evolution. - More than a year ago
Question Asker
LOL. I read that article too. Half of your arguments can be used against Creationism by stating that the Earth is younger than evolutionists say but older than the Bible says. The other half is inconclusive scientific backing that has no current explanation possibly because the scientific community has not fully discovered all that there is to discover. That is like saying God does not exist because there is no conclusive evidence that he does. - More than a year ago
None of these are going to PROVE anything. There is NEVER going to be anyone or anything that can prove that God exists 100%. Because then faith would be tossed out the window. But my whole point is, is that although it takes faith to believe in a supernatural being, it also takes a ton, if not more, faith to believe in the alternative. And contrary to what some scientists want you to think, evolution is not an open and shut case. In fact, there is more proof against it, then for it. - More than a year ago
You state below that evolution had to come from somewhere, if not from God then where -- but you ignore the fact that, creationism is NOT Christianity. It is merely the principle that the universe was created by a God. Not necessarily the god of the Christians. Not necessarily humans themselves. Just that something was created by something or someone. Whether it was just the universe and the natural laws, or everything and us -- it varies from person to person. - More than a year ago
"Not only has it never been proven wrong, archaelogy has proven that it is very accurate. Cities of the Bible have been dug up as well as evidence of the names of people and rulers in the Bible."
First, of course the cities and rulers exist. To suggest otherwise is nonsense. The JFK conspiracy theory includes the existence of JFK.
Second, there is no proof of pretty much that supposedly happened in the Old Testament, archaeological or otherwise. No enslaved Israelites, for example. - More than a year ago
You commented that evolution had to come from somewhere, if not from God then where -- but you ignore the fact that, creationism is NOT Christianity. It is merely the principle that the universe was created by a God. Not necessarily the god of the Christians. Not necessarily humans themselves. Just that something was created by something or someone, which either directly caused humans to exist or caused conditions to be such that we would later exist. - More than a year ago
I believe there is a "God" who created all the laws of the universe. Every driving force, matter, energy, etc are has an origin. And that origin has no beginning nor end; it's not finite; it's my idea of God. So do I believe in creation? Absolutely not. God never placed human beings on this planet over a period of a day. God set evolution in play for us to have exist naturally. So my diagram is something like this: God --> natural forces/laws --> evolution --> us
Creationism includes two different schools of thought (and perhaps others); Deism and Theism. Deism matches your diagram of God --> Natural Laws --> Evolution --> Us. - More than a year ago
Creationism is that God created the world and all being in 7 days or something along those lines. Evolution is the biological change over time and that everything started off from simple celled organisms. Other is for anyone who believes something else. Be it Scientology or something other explanation. - More than a year ago
Answerer
In that case I vote for evolution. - More than a year ago
Creationism is the concept that a god created something. Evolution is as the Question Asker said it was. Deists (creationists) think that a god created the universe and the natural laws but let nature take its course, without influencing anything that happened. Theists (creationists) believe that a god created everything and had (has) direct control over everything that happens. The 7 days the Asker spoke of is from Abrahamic religions, and it is not representative of all creationist beliefs. - More than a year ago
I don't believe in the evolution that we came from monkeys, but in simple terms---in the evolution that led us to become better human beings, etc. Religion has always been corrupted by greedy leaders, and its been a tool used to keep humanity controlled. I also don't believe in creationism as that is just another fairy tale trying to explain from a spiritual level how creation came to be. Is insane that people take it literally. By the way, evolution theory loses all credibility when you start looking at the link between eugenics and evolution.of course, they don't teach that in school cause not a good selling point for the evolutionists. And if you haven't figured that out, then you might as well join a religious cult.
Hahaha...very true! very criticism too! I agree religions are just a bunch of fakes at some point - god said this, god said that when all it really is - the words are coming out of people's mouths! - More than a year ago
Question Asker
I don't see how evolution loses credibility because of eugenics. And they do teach it in schools, its just termed as "Social Darwinism." - More than a year ago
I agree with the asker on this one. Just because a theory can be applied for negative consequences doesn't mean the theory loses credibility. I can apply gravitational theory to drop a rock on someone's head, but that doesn't discredit gravity. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Gravitational theory is quite objective isn't it? If you read about Darwin, you will see his theories were not so objective, as he wasn't an objective individual....but back then, I suppose the scientific method wasn't fully enforced. There is an interesting book out there: FROM DARWIN TO HITLER: EVOLUTIONARY ETHICS, EUGENICS, AND RACISM IN GERMANY. Also, there is an essay on the net titled: The Gentle Darwinians What Darwin’s Champions Won’t Mention - More than a year ago
*shrug* Any theory that deals with the origins of mankind isn't going to be objective. That doesn't mean that we shouldn't try to find out where we came from. And you say Darwin himself wasn't objective...well, ultimately, is anyone? Everyone has an agenda, whether they realize it or not. Conspiracy theories don't interest me. Evolution has been supported time and time again, and even IF it originated from racism (big if), that doesn't invalidate the support that's been found since. - More than a year ago
Answerer
Back in my atheist days, I was all for evolution, until of course, I started looking at both sides of the coin and realized that there are agendas, as you say, in every aspect of life---science, religion, politics, whatever. HOwever, I did try to look at both sides of the stories; just like there is enough evidence for evolution, there is enough scientific evidence to discredit evolution (easiest one is breeding); just because you are blind, doesn't mean there is no moon, sun and stars. ;) - More than a year ago
Question Asker
Breeding counters evolution? How? - More than a year ago
Thanksgiving is right around the corner and just like the last year and the year before, you will most likely spend it with your family. And just like everyone else, you have a crazy uncle or an...
$20 Amazon Gift Card
Check out the winner of the last contest! Worst Pick Up Lines
Winner received $20 Amazon Gift Card
I was just wondering if people believed in evolution. I personally do as I am studying in a field of science. Being agnostic, I am just unable to see...
it is amazing how this question keeps getting diffrent answers on sooo many diffrent levels. would like to know everyones opinion on this matter. how...
I see him in my minds eye Always aware of him but never Is he really physically here.The feelings that go through me Just as I think of himI cannot explain.Warmth seeps into my bones, My heart...
Why your whole body suffers when you're tense plus, how to ease the pain.Stress hurts: Women who lead demanding lives are more than twice as likely to suffer from aches and pains as women with less...
Disclaimer: GirlsAskGuys cannot guarantee the accuracy of answers, opinions and advice submitted by members. Please use common sense when following or omitting any content on GirlsAskGuys.com