Ask a Question Answer a question Read/Write Articles Rate Members articles | sign up










lovebird01

Was I out of line mentioning money?

Average Rating:
Your Rating: 
MiserableBoringEnjoyableInterestingFascinating
 
lovebird01 (Age:Over 45)     When: 8 months ago
Views: 903     Category: Dating
Recently my fiance and I were talking and I made what I thought was an innocent, off-hand remark.

I said:
"Sometimes when I really think about it, it's something, how much money I HAVE spent on you? Between gifts and bills, food, etc.? Amazing? Well, at least you can't say I'm cheap! (LOL) And I do it all out of my love for you!!! I really do love making you happy......"

I never mentioned HOW much, like a dollar value, or even hinted that she owed me in any way for my financial help or gifts.

Here was her reply:
"I feel a bit strange when you keep telling me how much money you've spent on me. A real gentleman never says that. Never. It's rude and it makes the woman feel bad. I feel like I owe you a lot. It's not that am not happy about them all, of course I am, but a man never should say how much he has spent on a woman."

I told her that I agreed with her, if I had mentioned a dollar amount or said she owed me in return. Who's right here? Was I out of line? Should she have gotten offended by my intended innocent remark. Puzzled and hurt!

3000 characters left  Anonymous Spell Check Spell Check
 Report Question  Email Friend Widgets Note This
Answers
  Hide Comments From Guys  
2
From Girls  
5
 

What Girls Said

A-R-Norman
2456  
A-R-Norman (Age:36 to 45)      When: 8 months ago
I have bought gifts for my man ( love to in fact) and never bring it up--why--because I don't feel the monetary aspect of giving is something to even remark about. Once a gift is given, it is no longer my possession in any aspect--I don't even know what the things I gave to my hubby costs any more, and if we were to break up, I wouldn't even think about wanting them back, like some people do.

Anything I ever bought a lover was from me to them, or I wouldn't have bought it. In one way yes, it can make a woman feel bought when money is tossed around, or like the money you spent on her bothers you. We all know that as adults, we sometimes joke about things that are really bothering us, and if you are the main bread winner, or make more than her, she is probably uncomfortable about it. For that reason alone, even if you meant noting by it, just apologize and don't bring it back up ( unless you want a fight) LOL...
Do you agree?
Agree   2 Disagree   0
Report

sweetvalle03
446  
sweetvalle03 (Age:18 to 24)      When: 8 months ago
Ouch. You used the how much money have I spent on you line?! *cringe. Well, even if you didn't mean it, I know I hate when guys say that to me. Well, only one guy has said it, but it makes me feel like he feels like he has to spend money on me to make me happy. Almost like I'm using him and it's not the case. So I'll say, while you meant it as nothing offensive, please try not to say that. Just don't use it again.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

witchy-1
80  
witchy-1 (Age:30 to 35)      When: 8 months ago
Whilst it was an innocent off-hand comment, it was kind of tasteless even though you obviously didn't mean it that way.

Saying that "sometimes when I really think about it" implies that you have given it some thought, and often. Which might make her think you sit there all the time adding up how much you have spent on her.......she probably feels that you might begrudge it or expect her to be constantly grateful.

If you didn't mean anything by it, then make sure she knows that and don't bring it up again.
Do you agree?
Agree   2 Disagree   0
Report

bribaby
421  
bribaby (Age:Under 18)      When: 8 months ago
If you bought her things and spent that money on her to make her happy, leave it at that. She knows you spend money on her, no need to bring it up like that. LadyLush is right though, don't bring it up anymore, and you'll be fine, so will she.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

LadyLush
586  
LadyLush (Age:18 to 24)      When: 8 months ago
When you make "jokes" like that it makes a girl feel as if your implying she owes you something or that you don't like spending money on her as if she were too much or something.... especially if your girl is an independent woman and likes doing things for herself more, has always taken care of herself that remark would be offensive because it's like your throwing things you have done on your own in her face... She doesn't ask for all that stuff, you most likely do it on your own therefore saying it was out of line, if you meant nothing by it then let it go. Don't bring it up again and definitely no more joking about it...... Dollar value or not she feels as if you think you have something over her head and that's a bad feeling especially when it comes to financial so don't be hurt just let it go, she should be fine.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report
 

What Guys Said

DeanW
1689  
DeanW (Age:25 to 29)      When: 8 months ago
I think you're right. I get that it's suave to pay bills and never mention them. That's stylish. But if you made an offhand comment about the money you spent and meant nothing by it, then I don't see that as such a big deal. People are often uncomfortable if they feel like the other person is contributing the most money to their relationship and I wonder if she doesn't feel a little bit bad about that and is projecting her feelings on to you.

Don't bring it up again and definitely don't bring it up if you two are arguing about something else (yikes!) because that will not turn out well for you. But I think you are guilty of making a bad joke, very little more. I think your status as a gentleman is undamaged.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

Selected as Best Answer
Genesis5
3652  
Genesis5 (Age:25 to 29)      When: 8 months ago
I'm sorry,... I feel bad but this made me laugh a little. Just because I have been in situations like this and had to take a trip to the hospital to have my foot removed from my mouth.

You know,... if you are buying GIFTS, then you should not bring up the fact that you bought them, they were gifts (unless you are always getting her big ticket items, and she gets you Pez dispensers).

But,... if you are always helping her out with bills, there might be something there that is bothering you (psychologist would say that your subconscious mind made you say that because it is weighing on you, Freud would say you want to sleep with your mother,... weird guy). If you two get married, then you will share finances,... but if you are always helping her with bills because she is not responsible with her money, that could cause problems (this is the reasons most marriages fail), and you really need to look at this, and try to solve it now.

If, you are helping her because she just has a large debt load, and work is tough (school loans, car loans, etc.), and she is responsible (you are just helping her get on her feet), then don't hold that over her,... you offered, and if you do hold it over her head, it will create feelings of resentment.

I think this comes down to,... is she responsible or isn't she. If she isn't, address it, because you will now be married to it. If she is, then apologize with something sparkley (a diamond perhaps) and for the love of God, don't tell her how much it cost.

Best of luck.
Do you agree?
Agree   3 Disagree   0
Report
 
marisa Agreed - 8 months ago
sassysteph I like how you said "apologize with something sparkly" lol it made me laugh. - 2 months ago
 
Related Questions
Search
A Girl Asked Why do guys spend so much money at the strip clubs?
Why do guys spend so much money at the strip clubs?   View Answers
A Girl Asked How much money should he spend on my engagement ring?
I know I sound like a gold digging bitch but my boyfriend - now fiance - popped the question a week ago. The ring he gave me probably cost less than...   View Answers
Find more questions on
money
Home > Dating Questions > Was I out of line mentioning...
 
Not a member yet? Sign Up for free in 1 easy step!
  
My Icon
0
Questions View
Answers View
Stories/Articles View
Messages View
Shout Outs View
Reality Check Create
Notebook View
What is most important in your significant other?
Anonymous User asked 17 hours ago

Good at cooking

Loves to clean

Awesome sex

Loves kids and animals (& willing to do the diapers/poop scoop, etc)

Invite a Friend
Invite Friend

Cborah (Age:25 to 29)

Describe your ideal first date; Where do you go? What do you wear? How does the date end?
I pick the lady up and we go out to dinner. Some place semi-quiet so we can talk but not too quiet I don't want it to seem overly romantic. Depending on the time of year we might do something outdoors like mini-golf or a football game, otherwise go to something indoors where it's warm. Not a movie, because I want to get to know her. I take her home and walk her to the door. The End.

Afterwards..what will your date know about you?
My name, Hobbies, Musical Tastes, a little about my family and what a I do for a living and hopefully have a good indication of what my personality is like.

Would you date me?
Dating Articles
 
●  What Women Really Mean
by  AshleyL
Guys, I know you have been puzzled by the opposite sex and by no means do we make it easy for you. We say one thing, we mean another. We rarely ever say just what we mean. We only expect you to...
●  Cooking for Your Man
by  GirlsAskGuys
I know women like men who can cook. I enjoy cooking myself. It is the most satisfying hobby I have ever had. In fact it is more than a hobby, it is a survival kit. One more good thing about cooking is...
Browse Categories: Flirting  |   Dating  |   Relationships  |   Sexuality  |   Break-Up  |   Behavior  |   Style  |   Other                                         Home Top
  Site Links     About GirlsAskGuys     GirlsAskGuys Widgets     Help Us Improve!   RSS Feeds
Home
Partners
Search Questions
Terms of Use, Privacy
Help
Affiliates
About Us
Contact Us, Send Feedback
Sitemap
Advertise With Us
Links
Post your questions on your blog, website, or any social networking page. You can embed into MySpace, Facebook and more. Click here for more info.
Have a suggestion? See a problem on the site? Click here to give feedback and suggestions on the new GirlsAskGuys, and help us give you a better experience. Visit our blog here
 Subscribe
Add to My AOL
Add to Google Reader or Homepage
©2008 girlsaskguys.com™. All Rights Reserved.