Home | New Members | Expert Answers | How To Videos | Our Blog | Sign Up | Sign In
Invite Friends
 
GirlsAskGuys.com GirlsAskGuys.com
  Chat Flirting Dating Relationships Sexuality Break-Up Behavior Style Other
Crazycanuck

If your boyfriend/girlfriend was of a different religion, would you convert for them?

Average Rating:
Your Rating: 
MiserableBoringEnjoyableInterestingFascinating
 
Crazycanuck (Age:18 to 24)     When: A month ago
Views: 393     Category: Relationships

Why or why not?

just wondering

As for me no I wouldn't convert no matter how much I loved her. Because my religion is still important to me in all aspects.


3000 characters left  Anonymous Spell Check Spell Check
 Report Question Widgets Note This
SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend
 Share on Facebook
  Poll added by question asker. Cast your vote to see the current results.   What is this?

If they asked, then yes, I don't see why not

Only if I loved them enough

I might consider it, but I don't know

No, my religion is too important to me

Answers

    From Guys  
20
From Girls  
25
 

What Girls Said

 
Anonymous User
N/A  
Anonymous User      When: 27 days ago
My religion is not that important to me, it is just something I say I am and don't live, so depending on the religion and whether or not I agreed with it I would consider converting.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

Pancakes
446  
Pancakes      When: A month ago
Most definitely not. I don't believe in any God so I would be lying to myself to convert and am not willing to preach about something I absolutely don't believe in. I wouldn't mind being with someone who believes in a God as long as he doesn't attempt to push his beliefs on to me. I can have my opinions while he can have his.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

ukrainianChika
173  
ukrainianChika      When: A month ago
I could not switch out of a Christian life, I love Jesus Christ to death and there is no way that I m changing that or having someone change that.
Do you agree?
Agree   3 Disagree   0
Report

the-love-guru
2142  
the-love-guru      When: A month ago
I honestly think it depends. There's a large difference between switching from Christianity to Judaism (and vice versa) or switching to a completely different type of religious background like Buddhism, Muslim, or a Wiccan. This requires a HUGE change that will take time to adjust and make your own. You have to think of how the switch will make you feel over time.

Personally, I could not switch out of a Christian-based religion. It's part of who I am... my core beliefs and how I base my decisions. I believe that we should marry someone who holds our similar values (religious and non), so that would prevent me from marrying someone from another faith. However, that would not prevent me from marrying someone from a different cultural background, so I hope nobody gets the wrong idea!
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

Reyah
222  
Reyah      When: A month ago
My ex did it but not for me and he acutally stayed catholic even after we broke up. I don't know about changing my religion though. I mean its a big part of my culture and life. and he understood that so he never asked me to convert and I didn't ask him but I did invite him to church (church is boring so I wanted him to suffer with me) >.< but he ended up likeing it.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

maddiezilla
35  
maddiezilla      When: A month ago
Religion is not important to me... But If I was religious, and it came down to that with the person I loved, then yes, I would convert for them.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   1
Report

underthemistletoe
243  
underthemistletoe      When: A month ago
I don't want to have to change for someone that I love. Especially when it's something that has been with me for my whole life.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

rockstare
144  
rockstare      When: A month ago
well I think the other person would care enough about you to understand that religion is important to you.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

 
Anonymous User
N/A  
Anonymous User      When: A month ago
meh..it depends on the religion, I'm christian and it wouldn't bother me to be a catholic or sumthin like that, but I probably wouldn't wanna be with somebody who was pushing their religion on me anyway because its annoying and rude T.T
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   1
Report

almondz
421  
almondz      When: A month ago
I voted B. It wouldn't be that important to me unless I feel like it may cause too much tension in the relationship. Other than that our wedding would be extra special!
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

shamelessBlues
16  
shamelessBlues      When: A month ago
Being married it is very hard to be with someone that has a different religion. Their philosophy and standards are completely different. You can talk about it with each other, and hopefully he is willing to put in as much in your religion as you will with his. That includes being open minded.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

HopeIessRomantik
1137  
HopeIessRomantik      When: A month ago
I'd only consider changing religions if he were someone I can see myself marrying and spending the rest of my life with. I don't really see the need of changing religions though,n so I'll only do it if I MUST!
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

 
Anonymous User
N/A  
Anonymous User      When: A month ago
Jeez, there are so many atheists here, I was raised Catholic, and though I may not believe everything I was taught, I still can not see how people could believe in NOTHING...

I wouldn't change my religion, I went to Catholic school for grammar school, high school, and college, there is no way I would convert into something else at this point..I was baptised, had my holy communion and confirmation, next up is marriage, and I intend it do that in a Catholic church..
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

Ceesa
614  
Ceesa      When: A month ago
if I truly believe in my religion which I do..how on earth would I trade God with love? Of course not ! :-)
Do you agree?
Agree   3 Disagree   0
Report

bellahgd
526  
bellahgd      When: A month ago
I absolutly love my religion and I don't think any other is better; but if the guy I'm with wants to convert to my religion then sure I'm all for it.. but I would never convert to any other religion for no one. I want my kids to follow the same religion and have the same beliefs...

I won't mention what religion that is so no one will get offended...
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   1
Report

simplymebabeee
778  
simplymebabeee      When: A month ago
Hmm..I would say maybe..I'm not real religious right now..but I am more of a Christian..and I've been taught to love Jesus since I was little like..born, so, Yeah Probably not for some TOTALY different religion..And if it was just my boyfriend probably not.but HUSBAND..then I'd consider it more..:)
Do you agree?
Agree   3 Disagree   1
Report

 
Anonymous User
N/A  
Anonymous User      When: A month ago
I would because I'm a catholic and if that person was a Christian and asked to convert I wouldn't think about it I would say yes because I LOVE the Christian religion
Do you agree?
Agree   2 Disagree   0
Report
 
smallz660 If you love the Christian religion more then being Catholic then why don't you just convert now? - A month ago
Littletad They are not even that different... - A month ago

tallenblog
483  
tallenblog      When: A month ago
Honestly- No. I couldn't. I'm a Christian and I love my Lord more than anyone else. Just as I believe it should be.
Do you agree?
Agree   3 Disagree   0
Report

thatswhatyourmomsaid
321  
thatswhatyourmomsaid      When: A month ago
i think that if someone loves you, they won't want to force you to change what you believe in.
Do you agree?
Agree   5 Disagree   0
Report

cheerangelcharity
2933  
cheerangelcharity      When: A month ago
I would never change my Christian beliefs just because of somebody else. I will admit to being "involved" (within the past year) with mostly those who are atheists or agnostics but I certainly won't do that again because for one I'm looking for someone to have something serious with [not just to "hook up" with] and two not only will just having two very different big beliefs complicate things if we're serious about each other but most likely their lifestyles and morals will be different than mine. So basically I'm not gonna be more than just friends with anyone unless he's a Christian anyways.
Do you agree?
Agree   2 Disagree   4
Report
 
jacquesvol "lifestyles and morals will be different than mine."
Lifestyles and morals of a serious atheist guy will be less different from yours than you might think. :) - A month ago
Answerer Actually from experience I know that many non-Christians are into stuff I'm against - such as alcohol, pre-marital sex, drugs, stealing, etc. no I'm not saying that all of them are into that stuff but from experience they are far more likely to be than Christians are [I've also grown up in Christian schools so I should know about that.] - A month ago

Rainbow35
58  
Rainbow35      When: A month ago
I might... I'm an atheist, so if I was going out with someone with a religion, and they wanted me to be religious too, I might, if the person was really nice, and I really liked them. The person I'm with right now is an atheist like me, so no problems there!
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report
 
jacquesvol You'd participate in the ceremonies (and so would I), but would you really and honestly believe? - A month ago

ivarei
12718  
ivarei      When: A month ago
while religion might be cool for other people, it's not cool for me. I wouldn't not date someone because of their faith, and if I loved them enough, I might go through the formality of conversion (I refuse to be Baptised). but if they started to expect me to behave a certain way on account of their beliefs, be it Jewish, Muslim, Hindi, Voodoo, Christian, Taoist, it would just be unacceptable to me. I don't want to have to clash horns with his religion, he can follow it if he wants. but to me, religion = myth, legend, and pseudo psychology; I'm not going run my life according to that stuff.

no offense to any religious people here, I'm not attacking you or your beliefs.
Do you agree?
Agree   7 Disagree   7
Report
 
Dela1111 Actually you are by comparing religion to myths. If its not for you then its not for you, but keep that type of opinion to yourself if you don't want to offend someone. - A month ago
Answerer Nearly every religion in the past is based on what one perceives to be the creator of life and moral stories. religion is constantly changing, in 3,000 years, if humans still exist, they'll be worshipping something or someone else. they'll be excavating the ruins of our civilization and find Bibles and say, "oh this is their book of stories". and then they'll find all the faded and torn magazines and tabloids and think we worshiped the Jonas Brothers. - A month ago
jacquesvol @Dela1111,
The moment you understand why you don't believe in Jupiter, Zeus or Quetzalcoatl, to name but a few (you'd call them myths) you'll understand that your as "atheist" as I am. I just believe in one god less than you do.

Read this to understand it better:
http://www.samharris.org/site/full_text/10-myths-and-10-truths-about-atheism1/


- A month ago

 
Anonymous User
N/A  
Anonymous User      When: A month ago
i don't think you have to convert fully, just be yourself and he can be himself...as long as you have a common ground and lifestyle, I don't see why a couple can't live happily following different religions, its not like it has to be exclusive, you can practice their holidays and rituals, they can practice yours, join in on the fun!
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   2
Report

-smilewhore
2158  
-smilewhore      When: A month ago
Im close to my goddess I couldn't leave her. and I don't mind if the guys a different religon.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   2
Report

Felwa
153  
Felwa      When: A month ago
Nope, my religion is the most important thing to me, no relationship is worth throwing what's important to me
Do you agree?
Agree   4 Disagree   3
Report
 

What Guys Said

EddyMetal
367  
EddyMetal      When: 27 days ago
Dude. You don't choose your religion. If you believe it you believe it, if you don't you don't.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

shyperson2009
925  
shyperson2009      When: A month ago
I wouldn't change. I'm not extremely religious or anything, but I wouldn't expect anyone to covert for me and vice versa. I don't think it would really change anything anyway. For example, a Jewish and Christian couple around the holidays should be able to celebrate both Hanukkah and Christmas. If you loved someone, I would think that they would respect your beliefs and not make you change them.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

BrettH
2634  
BrettH      When: A month ago
im not sure I would or not. I'm not a big religous person I belive in god but I can't stand going to church cause all it is is you are doomed go out repent and find more people to come to church... it gets annoying hearing the same thing every Sunday. if she is really religious and its important to her I might consider it.. otherwise take me as is and we will work out the kinks later.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

soccerguy92
180  
soccerguy92      When: A month ago
I would really hate it if our relationship depended on religion
I know I wouldn't change, I wouldn't force her
i would just probably take her to my church and whatever happens, happens
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

mikethebear
406  
mikethebear      When: A month ago
atheist here. wouldn't ever date a religious person. to much conflict
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   1
Report

Jpalms56
556  
Jpalms56      When: A month ago
i believe in God but I don't think he listens to us so yea I would change if it was really important to her
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

DrJones
1443  
DrJones      When: A month ago
Can I request a new option?

E: No. If you love someone, you don't demand that they change their religious beliefs to match your own.
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

here4you
6872  
here4you      When: A month ago
not at all
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

smallz660
911  
smallz660      When: A month ago
If you converted to a religion just because your boyfriend/girlfriend wanted you too then you obviously don't care about either religion. By asking someone to convert religions you're asking them to change their values and belief system and no one should change that for another person.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

 
Anonymous User
N/A  
Anonymous User      When: A month ago
It's nice 2 hear some Christians standing up 4 their beliefs - I'm a Christian 2 and wouldn't want 2 marry someone who wasn't becuz there is just 2 much conflict if people don't agree w/what the other person believes.

Even in Christianity (and maybe other religions 2) there are differences that make people argue and fight...Who needs that in a marriage? I think that would be like a nightmare...ha ha

At any rate, hey, I don't begrudge anyone their own religion, but like I said, I think I would probably be careful about who I marry because of wanting 2 be able 2 have a good marriage & be happy...
Do you agree?
Agree   2 Disagree   0
Report
 
ukrainianChika Yupp, I agree. - A month ago

Snorkledorf
536  
Snorkledorf      When: A month ago
My _lack_ of religion is too important to me, for me to join somebody's belief system, so...would that be D?
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   0
Report

WhatIsThisIDont
1745  
WhatIsThisIDont      When: A month ago
Dunno, I'm open to new ways of life but it depends on her religion and how much I love her. Umm if she eats babies in her religion, NO. If she is Buddhist with me being raised Christian, then maybe I would try it.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

bersaba
493  
bersaba      When: A month ago
I wouldn't go out with someone of a "different religion" (that is, any religion, I'm an atheist) to begin with.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   2
Report

jacquesvol
8943  
jacquesvol      When: A month ago
No, I wouldn't convert.
I'm an atheist (an apatheist, actually link ) and I don't see how I could get to believe or to play the comedy of believing if I 'converted'. I'd leave her the liberty to believe and to attend church , temple, synagogue or mosque, of course. I would go there with her if she wanted it, but without converting or believing, as a spectator.
I've attended many religious services (different religions) in my life, some to be polite (mostly funeral or wedding masses), others because I'm curious or because there was one element I wanted to hear or see for artistic or other reasons or just because I was curious. Of course I don't hate religious people in any way.

As for the education of children, they shouldn't be brainwashed by any religion when young. When they'd be old enough to chose they should chose freely what they want to believe.
Do you agree?
Agree   2 Disagree   1
Report

MrTinker
164  
MrTinker      When: A month ago
I'm with her for a reason, we love eachother; I would do anything for her and I did convert from a christain to a shadow shaman.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   1
Report

 
Anonymous User
N/A  
Anonymous User      When: A month ago
I am really open to other religions. I believe that we're all basically the same-we're all worshiping the same entity(ies) and most people have the same morals. I'm not especially fond of my denomination, mostly because they do not seem to be tolerant of other good people, and somehow even fail to follow their holy book. I think there are certain fundamental morals that everyone should have, and most religions promote them (with lots of hypocrisy, though). For example, I think the most basic of all is that everyone should love each other, and care about the rest of society more than they care about themselves.

So, basically, I would definitely consider converting to another religion for a girlfriend. I would require that I agree with most of what that religion promotes, but since I don't care for what my current denomination does, I'd be more than happy to look for something else.

I think the idea that "my religion is more important to me than a relationship" is looking into it too much. I would definitely agree, if your boyfriend/girlfriend were worshiping Satan or associating with religious violence, or whatever. For the most part though, if they were taught to love each other and to forgive and tolerate other humans, I don't see any problem with switching religions. I think a lot of organized religions can kinda lose the whole point of the whole thing, and end up being too complicated.

In conclusion, I'll leave a small story that my uncle told me.

There was a small town, and the citizens were very devout with their religion. They attended church regularly, prayed often, and were "good" people. However, there was one citizen, who was homeless and an atheist. He begged and attempted to rebuild his life, but was only met with cold shoulders from the townspeople. After time, many of the townspeople passed, along with the homeless atheist. In Heaven, God asked, "You know that I exist in everything and everyone,even that homeless atheist. You turned your back on him when he was in need, and therefore have turned your back on Me. True, he didn't believe in Me, but that only means that he was more lost than any of you, and he deserved My good will more than any of you. Atheists, criminals, people of other religions, lost souls, etc etc, need for you to give them My Word more than anyone else. You were told to love your neighbor, not just your Christian neighbors. Many people do horrible things, and it may be hard to love them. I've taught you forgiveness, though, and that allows you to continue to love them. It is not My WIll that the lost, hurt, misguided, and hopeless are excluded from love."
Do you agree?
Agree   1 Disagree   1
Report

Littletad
14615  
Littletad      When: A month ago
I'm sticking with Christianity.

I might date someone who is a different religion and talk about it. See where it goes from there. But I would not marry someone, and THEN try to convert.

I like to think of this verse to at least help somewhat.

"Do not be yoked together with unbelievers. For what do righteousness and wickedness have in common? Or what fellowship can light have with darkness?"

2 Corinthians 6:14
Do you agree?
Agree   3 Disagree   1
Report
 
cgiddings Most monotheistic religions have similar passages. Even a number of polytheistic religions indicate your worship should be placed wholy with a singular deity. Just sayin'. - A month ago

cgiddings
754  
cgiddings      When: A month ago
There should be an option for "I don't have a religion and would prefer to keep it that way."

Some of us regard religion with a level of apathy and wouldn't convert or be converted into a particular set of views really for any reason.
Do you agree?
Agree   4 Disagree   1
Report
 
Average-Joe There should also be an option for "I am open to converting, but must learn about that religion's beliefs before considering it". Just because I have a girlfriend who is something else, doesn't mean I will immediately drop my religion and convert. - A month ago

bunny420
2043  
bunny420      When: A month ago
Why would I change when I believe because someone I love believes something different? I won't lie about who I am...
Do you agree?
Agree   2 Disagree   0
Report

Dela1111
5669  
Dela1111      When: A month ago
There is no way in hell I would convert my religion for anybody or anything.
Do you agree?
Agree   2 Disagree   1
Report
 
ukrainianChika Amen =) - A month ago
 
Find more questions on would you convert religions     
Home > Relationships Questions > If your boyfriend/girlfriend was of a different religion, would you convert for them?
 
Join GirlsAskGuys
Members earn points to get Expert Advice on Video, Amazon & iTunes Gift Cards, books and more!
Male Female
 Open Contests  
Crazy Thanksgiving Story with Family
Thanksgiving is right around the corner and just like the last year and the year before, you will most likely spend it with your family. And just like everyone else, you have a crazy uncle or an...
$20 Amazon Gift Card   $20 Amazon Gift Card
Check out the winner of the last contest!
Worst Pick Up Lines
Winner received $20 Amazon Gift Card
View All Contests >>
Questions on would you convert religions
A Guy Asked Would you convert for that someone?
Ladies and gents, here's a melon scratchier. Would you be willing to convert to your significant others religion if marriage was on the table, or...  
A Guy Asked Would you date someone from a different religion?
For example if you were Christian would you date a Buddhist or a Muslim...Why or why not.just wondering as for me I would take it as a learning...  
More Questions on
would you convert religions
Expert Advice
More Video Answers
A Girl Asked  Question: Why does my boyfriend keep checking out other woman ?

Video Answer From Matt Titus
Click here to watch larger video
Relationships Xpers
  
Shlei3
14534  
Shlei3
Engaged, 26 years old
United States
6 Questions - 999 Answers
Relationships Xper: 3499
kingbrother
12252  
kingbrother
Single, 16 years old
United Kingdom
0 Questions - 1017 Answers
Relationships Xper: 3081
Hercules
14690  
Hercules
Single, 20 years old
United States
2 Questions - 734 Answers
Relationships Xper: 2619
Littletad
14615  
Littletad
Single, 26 years old
United States
5 Questions - 623 Answers
Relationships Xper: 2217

What is Xper? View Rankings
Disclaimer: GirlsAskGuys cannot guarantee the accuracy of answers, opinions and advice submitted by members. Please use common sense when following or omitting any content on GirlsAskGuys.com
Browse Categories: Flirting  |   Dating  |   Relationships  |   Sexuality  |   Break-Up  |   Behavior  |   Style  |   Other                                         Home Top
  Site Links     About GirlsAskGuys     GirlsAskGuys Widgets     Help Us Improve!   RSS Feeds
Home
Videos
Partners
Search Questions
Terms of Use, Privacy
Help, New Members
About Us
Contact Us, Send Feedback
Sitemap
Advertise With Us
Resources
Post your questions on your blog, website, or any social networking page. You can embed into MySpace, Facebook and more. Click here for more info.
Have a suggestion? See a problem on the site? Click here to give feedback and suggestions on the new GirlsAskGuys, and help us give you a better experience. Visit our blog here
 Subscribe
Add to My AOL
Add to Google Reader or Homepage
©2009 girlsaskguys.com™. All Rights Reserved.