Ask a Question Answer a question Read/Write Articles Rate Members articles | sign up










  Anonymous User

Did I take it too far?

Average Rating: Not yet rated!
Your Rating: 
MiserableBoringEnjoyableInterestingFascinating
 
Anonymous User (Age:18 to 24)     When: 3 months ago
Views: 85     Category: Relationships
Yesterday I found out that one of my friend had cancer, and I wasn't aware of it. She is a very great friend, and we are somewhat close (we hang out quite a bit). My girlfriend also knows her and they are friends too, so. In a way she is a mutual friend for us. She never told me about her health condition, because she was worry that I would act/treat her differently, better or worse. Thus, she never told me, but told my girlfriend about it. My girlfriend knew about her condition for quite some time, but I am not one of those guys who forces her to tell me every bit of her life daily, and thus she never mentioned to me. I like giving her room, ample space for herself and let her tell me what she wants to tell me. Now, the problem is that my other friend who found out about it told me about her health condition, and trusted me that I wouldn't treat her differently, which I never thought of doing. I am mature enough to accept serious matters like this, and not freak out about it. I just don't understand why it wasn't my girlfriend who told me, and trusted me, but instead one of my other friend. Is this a hint to her insecurity with me, lack of trust and could this link to her personality? If she could hide something this serious from me, what other things is she hiding? I know I don't have the right to know all of her secrets, but I think she is too bias about this incident. If this is a sign of lack of trust, should I consider letting her go? She says she love me, and I love her a lot, never thought about cheating with another girl even when I am away from her. Whatever, I just mentioned above, I also asked her, but she was quiet. I know it is harsh, but wouldn't you be angry if you have to find out something serious like this from a friend, and not the one you love? The last thing I want is finding out that there is something wrong with her via another friend. What do you guys think? Should I give us both some time? Thanks for the help guys and girls.

BY THE WAY, SHE LIVES 1. 5 HOURS AWAY FROM ME, SO IT IS A LONG DISTANCE IN A WAY. HOWEVER, WE ALMOST ALWAYS CHAT OVER THE PHONE AT LEAST 1/DAY IF NOT 1/2DAYS.


3000 characters left  Anonymous Spell Check Spell Check
 Report Question  Email Friend Widgets Note This
Join GirlsAskGuys on Facebook
Answers
  Hide Comments From Guys  
3
From Girls  
1
 

What Girls Said

kiem-gg
66  
kiem-gg (Age:18 to 24)      When: 3 months ago
This is not a matter of your girlfriend not trusting you or hiding something from you purposely, this is about your girlfriend keeping a promise she made to a very ill friend. As her boyfriend you should understand that there are loyalties we should keep with our friends even when we have a partner. If this would have been something that affected your relationship directly, rest assured she would have said something to you, but since it doesn't involve or affect your relationship, and it was asked of her to keep it a secret, she felt she had to respect her friends wishes and keep it quiet.
The friend that told you did not respect this poor girl's wishes and that is what's wrong here, not your girlfriend being the loyal friend that she is. And if you are thinking of dumping her just because she stayed a loyal friend, then you're being selfish and stupid. Don't say you give her space and do not ask she tells you every little thing when you are getting all riled up over her keeping a friend's secret that never even involved you.
Do you agree?
Agree   5 Disagree   0
Report
 

What Guys Said

tegdim
842  
tegdim (Age:18 to 24)      When: 3 months ago
Your overreacting, your friend have cancer might not want anyone apart from the people she told to know about her condition, your girlfriend is just keeping her promise, if she told you about this she broke her own promise and trust. If your mature enough like you said, you would understand why she didn't tell you this, your mixing up friendship promises and trust with your own personal love relationship trust.

For example, If you have a guy friend going out on a late night to a pub having few drinks and hugged this girl, he then ask you to not tell his girlfriend(His girlfriend is best friend with your girlfriend) about it because it was just normal hug and your guy friend had no feelings for that pub girl. Would you tell your girlfriend and break your guy's promise/trust or keep the promise?
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report

quietbutsexyman
254  
quietbutsexyman (Age:18 to 24)      When: 3 months ago
Ok kiem-gg. You need to chill. He's asking for advice, not for a lecture from you. Anyways, I can understand why you're upset Anonymous. Obviously you want the one you love to have complete trust in you and to put you above most other people in her life. However, if this is just an isolated incident, I think you can take comfort in the fact that she was probably just honoring her friend's wishes. Who knows, she might have even stood up for you when her friend told her to a keep it a secret. She might have said you'd be able to handle it, but maybe your friend didn't give in. So if otherwise your girlfriend seems to trust you, I would let it go and comfort you friend with cancer as much as you can. If however, this is just one of many other similar trust-issues, it might be time to sit your girlfriend down and tell her, directly, how you feel.
Do you agree?
Agree   0 Disagree   0
Report
 
kiem-gg I don't tell you how to dispense your advice, don't tell me how to dispense mine :) - 3 months ago
Answerer Yeah you can't call that "advice" - 3 months ago

AJtogo
2404  
AJtogo (Age:Over 45)      When: 3 months ago
You are turning a serious health matter for a friend a yours into some kind of personal slight. Stop it. It doesn't matter what or why she never told you.
Do you agree?
Agree   2 Disagree   0
Report
 
Related Questions
Search
A Guy Asked If she still has feelings for her ex should I leave her alone?
Right girls I need your help!I am right now dating this really nice girl.We already went out twice and everything worked out well. She laughs at my...   View Answers
A Guy Asked Should I give her the cold shoulder?
Ok so here is the deal. Me met girl about a year ago at a church group. I liked her and I suspected she liked me too, but she was 14 at the moment so...   View Answers
Find more questions on
give her time
Home > Relationships Questions > Did I take it too far?
 
Not a member yet? Sign Up for free in 1 easy step!
  
My Icon
0
Questions View
Answers View
Stories/Articles View
Messages View
Shout Outs View
Reality Check Create
Notebook View
Does it ever annoy you that you're single?
random-ren asked 3 days ago

Yes, most of the time! I really wish I had a boyfriend/girlfriend!

A little, because I feel left out.

Not really...

Nope! I have too much fun being single!

What's there to be annoyed about?

Join GirlsAskGuys on Facebook
Invite a Friend
Invite Friend

Funks (Age:18 to 24)

Describe your ideal first date; Where do you go? What do you wear? How does the date end?
Hmm..my ideal date..well..i had one of those so..let's see...i would wear something casual that fits me and my personality....i would go in a park or in a bar.my date will end with a hug.

Afterwards..what will your date know about you?
Well...my name..where I live...what I like to do...what I like...my favorite music bars.etc

Would you date me?
Browse Categories: Flirting  |   Dating  |   Relationships  |   Sexuality  |   Break-Up  |   Behavior  |   Style  |   Other                                         Home Top
  Site Links     About GirlsAskGuys     GirlsAskGuys Widgets     Help Us Improve!   RSS Feeds
Home
Partners
Search Questions
Terms of Use, Privacy
Help
Affiliates
About Us
Contact Us, Send Feedback
Sitemap
Advertise With Us
Links
Post your questions on your blog, website, or any social networking page. You can embed into MySpace, Facebook and more. Click here for more info.
Have a suggestion? See a problem on the site? Click here to give feedback and suggestions on the new GirlsAskGuys, and help us give you a better experience. Visit our blog here
 Subscribe
Add to My AOL
Add to Google Reader or Homepage
©2008 girlsaskguys.com™. All Rights Reserved.