Would you marry a girl who cheated on her first husband with you?

No not at all if your in love with her and she hasn't given you reason to believe she's cheated on you then go for it because its not always the person it also depends on the relationship they are in when they felt the need to cheat. Not to mention that people do change and if you love and trust her your not crazy not in the least so go for it esp if this woman makes you happy!

I think you should figure out exactly why she cheated in the first place. Does she have a pattern of cheating with other boyfriends or was this a one-time thing? You should ask good questions and don't be afraid to ask questions you might not like the answer to. I don't necessarily think it's a deal breaker.

I'm a believer that cheaters do cheat again. I understand each has their own circumstances...but unless she was in a dramatically neglective relationship and was too weak to escape it without you - I'm going to say it will happen right back to you. And I'm not so sure why you have fallen in love with someone that hasn't the guts to end things dignified and start an new relationship with the other man?

Why do you ask now? I'm surprised!!