I got home from a 3 week trip and found that what used to be a stash of 13 condoms is down to 4. And I also found disposable contact lenses wrappers in the trash - he does not wear contacts and neither do I. Seems to me some other girl was here while I was gone! He said he threw away the condoms because we don't use them and he's ocd with organization and not having clutter (this is true) and kept a few in case we needed them for some reason. And he said "I don't know" about the contact wrappers... suggested the housekeeper or maybe his friend that was over for 3 hrs one day. Am I being unreasonable/paranoid or am I dating a liar?
Most Helpful Girl
Sounds fishy. Why keep 4 and not the whole box? That's a random number.
And he doesn't know where contact lenses came from?
The bigger factor here is your intuition. You're jumping to the cheating conclusion, which means he's done something to cause you to suspect this (if you're not someone who always suspects cheating with every guy in every situation).
It's up to you what to do. If it were me, and I'd done enough introspection to decide that it wasn't mine own issues that were causing suspicion, I'd seriously consider ending the relationship. Even if he didn't actually cheat, the fact that I *think* he would is a problem. No trust = no relationship.2