Well of course you look at the outside first when you still dont know the person. I look at hight, he needs to be taller then me (when im with hills, but im not that tall so its fine) , weight (not being too thin or fat), i try to see if he has muscles, if he is athletic because i am. Then i look at his face, i like guys that has a manly look, they can't have a too perfect face but they need to look nice (eye color, i dont like ugly noses, teeth!!!, and i like a little facial hair). But overall i like men that are bigger than me because i feel safe, they dont have to look too perfect, but they have to look manly and tough. But thats just me ;)
This is gonna sound really shallow but hey, you never really see someone's personality first, do you? I always notice whether or not they have good hair and if they wear glasses that suit their facial features then im down for it. The guy i have a crush on wore a turban last school year so i never really noticed him because im always looking at people's hair but he decided to cut it so this year it was his hair and glasses that attracted me.