I don't get why the loud outgoing girl with a bunch of guy friends who "tries too hard to be cool" can't be sweet and caring? Or that she tries to be cool, maybe people are just drawn to her natural personality and she's just being herself. Assuming that only shy girls are sweet and caring is ignorant and just shows how bitter and jealous you are. You certainly don't sound sweet to me...
Most Helpful Girl
They would be into the one who is more objectively attractive than the other.