To me both are attractive. I think its a different appeal in the sense that thicker women seem to be more womanly/maternal and slimer gilrs are more girly and tend to elicite a more paternal response. Basicly from my understanding women like guys who are taller bigger then them because it makes them feel small and feminine, this would also inturn make a guy fee bigger and more masculine, like a protector ie paternal. The thicker woman has secondary sex characterisics (thighs, breasts, butt) that are more for child birthing rearing so seems more maternal (perhaps thats why they use the term cuddly for thicker women) (if any of that makes sense?) So its more of what the individual is looking for and at what time. As I said, I think both are attractive but for different reasons.
Most Helpful Girl
skinny!!! though I do wish I were more "slim" than skinny. ;p