Girls what do you like? do you like smart men like doctors, bankers, lawyers (men with very high iq's) or do you like atheltic guys, like boxers, mma fighters, soccer, nfl, but we all know they are not the smartest etc. What attracts you more? I personally love smart men... i experienced one and life was simple a cake walk with him... he was very smart like 138 iq...
Actually sportsmen are some of the smartest men in the world, if not the smartest.
Whilst profession hints towards a higher/lower IQ it is usually diligence that gets you there. As for Smart vs Athletic reality is that most people that have one of these attributes often have the other as well. Your ivy league kid isn't the fat guy in his mother's basement but rather the guy winning all the sports events in school.
Still fun to find out which trait takes precedence, but normally you get both of these or neither of them.