Most Helpful Girl
Most Helpful Guy
My name is Randall, but often it gets nicknamed to Randy. Some girl being named "Randall" would be kind of odd, but I've seen girls named Randy (or rather it is usually spelled "Randi"). That wouldn't bother me. Randy/Randi is mostly used for guys but can be used for girls as well.
Her being named the same thing wouldn't take off any 'points' in my book.
If I like her, I'd date her.2