On average guys give other guys better dating advice.
The subset of women who give good advice give -great- advice.
Someone has said asking women for dating advice is like asking fish for fishing advice, and there's a lot of truth in that. But it's also true that if there were a few self aware talking fish, any fisherman would be reeeeally interested in their help.
Most women aren't self aware enough to see what excites and attracts women, they can only describe what they'd like behavior wise from someone they're already attracted to. Since most guys with dating problems are stuck on the 'generating attraction' part, most women dont' give them much useful advice. But a few really do.
Men are pretty much as bad in terms of saying what they'd like, not what they find attractive.
girls are and i am sorry if you find it offensive delusional ( sometimes ) the advices they give apart from look and smell good dont really work that well , in fact the opposite does , weird i know but thats how it is