In your age group, at your school, etc.
Most Helpful Girl
I'm a college student, so I see quite a few guys around. Here's some arbitrary stats for you.
Of the guys I regularly hang out with (n˜20), just a few of them (n=3 or so) I would consider cute, although none are attractive to the point that I'm like "Oh my god, look at this piece of eye candy".
Of the guys I see around campus, maybe 40-50% I'd consider generally good-looking (that is, worth a second glance). Of those, maybe 15% I personally consider cute, and would check out whenever I saw them, and every once in a great while I see somebody who just blows me away (<2%).
For any guys outside my age group (say, beyond three years either way), the percentage of guys that I think are good-looking decreases steadily.
It's probably worth it here for me to make a quick distinction between guys I consider good-looking and guys I think are cute. The guys I think are cute are the ones I'm actually interested in based solely on looks. As for the rest, I can appreciate that they're better than average, but they're not quite my type.1