Yeah I know this question is old but it just amazes me how a girl who is probably socially awkward and has never gotten male attention in real life automatically becomes a goddess in dating websites. I'm sure the Male:Female ratio is completely thrown off but, It's scarce to really get a response from someone you like. I simply ask why is that?
Most Helpful Girl
Everyone on dating sites is pickier. Not just the guys. And you have to remember that looks aren't as important for girls as it is for guys. She might have seen something in your profile that she didn't like.
Desirable traits for men are: ambitious, tall, works out, has a job and a car, funny, sweet, romantic, etc.
I've used a dating site before and some of the guys who message me on there didn't even have a car. If you don't know somebody in person, it's really easy to dismiss them for things like this.1