Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory vs. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory?
Well let me just say that this is one of my favorite remakes. When I first heard of it, I was skeptical. But once I found out that Johnny Depp was playing Willy Wonka, I was sold.
And you are?
I'm a Girl I'm a Guy
Updates: Most Helpful Guy
Willy Wonka and The Chocolate Factory is a classic film with some great sets and imaginative ideas. But that nightmare tunnel portion was the creepiest thing put to film.
Charlie and The Chocolate Factory is vapid a Johnny Depp vehicle with some interesting effects but no real charm. Plus Depp looks like sex offender in that movie. I'm glad you enjoyed it but I have to be honest I don't see how.
Most Helpful Girl
Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. Gene Wilder was a great Willy Wonka, in my opinion.
http://i.imgur.com/Eo0vLAc.gif I usually prefer the originals over the remakes. I'll watch the remakes, and might enjoy them, but still prefer the originals.
What Guys Said 10
Its not a remake. Its just Tim Burtons interpretation of the book and he never intended to recreate the original movie ;P I like the newer one better because it stuck with the book more than the old one. I used to be obsessed with the movie when i was little. i still own it
Ehhh sorry I'm a sucker for the classics/originals.
Gene Wilder is a really great actor and he did a great job with his role. So did Jack Albertson as Grandpa Joe and Peter Ostrum as Charlie.
johnny depp is such a creep lol
Depp is amazing at whatever he does. But the original was better.
What Girls Said 12
I haven't seen the original version, and I enjoy the creepiness of Johnny Depp in his role, so I voted for him.
yeah i like the new one better :) the oompa loompas are hilarious as well lol.
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory without a doubt. Jonny Dep made the movie 10x better 👍
I prefer the original. But I feel that way about most remakes. Same thing about books... I almost always prefer the book to the movie.
The original one is better.
Will Wonka and the Chocolate Factory isn't as boring! Real talk.
I forgot about the remake. The original was better, some things are best not to remake!.
It's not a remake Charlie and the chocolate factory was a sequel
I don't like the version with Johnny. The older one is a classic and will always be a fav
Click "Show More" for your mentions