The poll will probably say Disturbed, hands down. However, it should be noted that for 1965, when pop music was still mostly bubblegum and boy-meets-girl, with a few folksy protest songs just starting to make headway, Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel's tune was unusually dark and brooding.
First of all he doesn't have as good a voice as the combination harmony of Simon and Garfunkel. Second the song starts out as a folk song. You are not even playing the original. His attempt at marginalizing the original is pathetic