Your body type is just like mine! Except I'm 5'2'' I consider myself in the athletic/curvy category. I have trouble calling myself skinny with the hips & butt that I possess, even though the rest of me is quite skinny and I work out a lot. I think girls that look athletic, curvy, or any combination of those with skinny look the best.
Girls who are just skinny (no curve or athletic look) or just fat, don't look as great. But that's my opinion, I know many who disagree.
All girls, all sizes as long as the waist is not bigger than the other 2. For me the hourglass shape has to be there, but how big the other numbers are is fairly irrelevant. Real beauty lies within, and the right attitude is way more important. But my preference isn't on your poll.
I selected "curvy not fat". I don't like the idea of girls doing everything they can to be extremely skinny. The next step is anorexia. Although I do like it that people do sports. It's essential for good health! You're looking nice on your profile pic, don't worry :-)
I voted curvy not fat but not if curvy means hourglass or big butt, then I guess A would have to do.. but I really prefer not athletic and not too skinny :P But not chubby either, halfway between skinny and chubby Something like this is my ideal I guess http://oi48.tinypic.com/11uggep.jpg