Yeah see some girls look good without makeup. Some don't. It would be ludicrous for anyone to say they prefer ALL girls without makeup. Personally without make up my acne is really bad and my eyes look too small. I look best with foundation/concealer, a little blush, and a little eye liner. Or at least decent. Mascara and lip gloss never hurts either.
Whole natural. Most girls look better without makeup. Nothing on is best. Girls tend to say, "Oh I just emphasize my eyes a little bit" and the eyes will be completely out of ratio at first glance, the mouth tends to be out of tune and too bright, the skin looks too artificial, the eyebrows get an unusual curve and the eyelashes just look too powerful. And I didn't even mention the eye shadow, which makes the skin around your eyes be colored in such a way that does not even fit with neither the skin nor the eyes nor anything on the face.
natural (no-make-up make up) in normal situation but like if we are going to a luxury restaurant or a concert or a night club i would like some make-up and dressing up. if i wear a suit you put on make up and a dress simple as that.
I guess it depends on the guy. For example I don't wear make up and when I do, it's mostly a mascara and a black crayon or something.No foundation, because I don't wanna ruin my skin at this age. Guys in my town seem to like a lot of make-up on girls, but honestly: wouldn't it be better to be surprised of how good your girl looks with some make-up on special occasions rather than be scared of how she looks without it because she wore it too much? haha. My guy friend don't care if I don't wear make-up, neither did my crush, but I guess it's one reason I was in the friendzone...that and my body.lol So it varies from guy to guy. They have different preferences when it comes to body, face, make-up, how a girl dresses etc.
I just wear winged black eyeliner, an eyeshadow 1-2 shades darker than my Skintone and chapstick everyday when going out. I'm lucky I don't need a lot. But when I'm sick I wear blush/bronzer to make me look less pale and um, dead. If my skin is dry/washed out some BB Cream. If I'm going to an event where lots of pictures will be taken I'll wear some foundation (idk why but it makes a difference in pictures) and probably some natural looking lipstick and mascara. If I get an occasional zit/blemish concealer. When I'm bored I try bold lip colors. When I'm feeling creative I'll play with eyeshadow. Uh, thats about it. Girly things are fun ^_^
I honestly think it depends on the guy. Most of the time I go natural, but sometimes I do wear makeup and some of the guys comment that it's nice when I get dolled up once and a while. I was surprised, because I always thought guys hated make up. I barely even wear any as well when I do. Just mascara and eyeliner, so I didn't think it was noticeable. Apparently it is.
I'm not a guy (Obv) but I would think most guys prefer the natural look. Less mess, no long hours getting ready, etc... But a lot of guys really don't mind. If you're hot, then that's all that matters.