Well I have a pretty natural look going on today so I'll tell you what I'm wearing.
So first I'm wearing my primer obviously Then my concealer, this is obviously for any blemishes and marks or even just colour adjusting. Foundation, this is where you need to make sure not to put too much on. I just spread some on my face with my hands, blend it well. I'm also wearing translucent powder to set my makeup, always do this, it'll make your face look more natural. I have a light beige eyeshadow on my eyelid and up to my brow. I filled in my eyebrows and made them all nice with this goopey stuff I got from sephora (I don't know the name its like clear mascara tbh) To make my eyelashes look longer and darker and also make my eyes look larger, I put on a thin line of eyeliner on the top outer edge (does that explain it well?) Then I did my mascara routine. I also used a pink blush.
Make up is unnecessary and a bit misleading. If a guy is used to seeing a girl with makeup, when he finally sees her without, he'll be shocked! I encourage most of my female friends to go without makeup, and the only ones who make fun of them are OTHER girls! Guys don't care about that stuff :3
The most natural look is no makeup at all. However, your update is reasonable. I don't like what messes with the color scheme of the face, and what makes the eyelashes noticably thicker than they already are. It looks creepy.
You can't really find pictures of natural women since the internet is flooded with photoshopped images or women in make up. I personally prefer a woman who does the minimum to make herself "presentable".
No make-up, no hair products, no hair dye, no piercings, no tattoos. T-shirt, *and I mean a normal T-shirt, not some really low cut thing with your tits hanging out) and jeans. (loose comfortable jeans, not skinny jeans)
A TRUE "Natural Look" is NO make up at all. There is a "Natural Look" that does use makeup, which is colors that slightly enhance your lips, eye lashes, cheekbones, highlights & lowlights on your face and gives you a glow. Makeup should be used appropriately anyway not too much or colors that do NOT look good on you. Make up does wonders to some girl like for real it will make a girl who is a 4 look like an 8 lol not to be mean but it's true.
lol this just proves that when guys say "I like a natural girl", they don't know what they're talking about. Also, that guys should learn more about girls lol A real natural girl is her face when she just woke up. Nobody wants to see that kind of face running around. You wouldn't even GLANCE at her. So don't tell me you like "natural" girls. Your "natural" is not natural.