Appreciate all of the feedback so far! Please keep it coming. Just one bit of clarification to be thorough - outfit 1 is a black tank and a frilly black skirt... I love short skirts/dresses/ to show my legs and love of heels...
Outfit #1 for sure. #2 is is very un-flattering (in my opinion). Because #2 narrows as it goes up to your neck, it makes your middle-area look bigger. Outfit 1 is the exact opposite... because it poofs at the hips, it makes your middle look thinner and your legs look amazing! Again... just my personal opinion though.
I don't like outfit 2 very much, though outfit 1 is really quite nice. Hard to tell if the material of the top matches the skirt though, the picture makes it difficult to see the detail. Also, since the shoes have so much contrast with the dress you will want to make sure your purse matches the shoes really well. Smart to be highlighting your legs, they are quite nice.
I really like #1. And those heels are my favorite kind. If you are using flash to block your face, please use a black square in a picture-editing software instead. Flash makes pictures against a mirror look annoying in my opinion.
Hmmmm both outfits are a little tacky and they don't show off your curves I think u look nice but where something that compliments your body shape the black dress is nice but the white shoes don't match I'd go with black heels and a longer dress though.