People who are attractive with makeup tend to be attractive even without makeup.
To me, they are always more attractive without make up. I see through the fake paint, unless you are REALLY good at making it look like as if you were wearing none of it.
To be honest, I hate makeup. I only hate it when I see it. But I usually see it. Mascara and eyeshadow are my arch nemesises, but I also dislike eyeliner and blush and lipsticks (yeah lipstick is so unnatural._.) and foundation if it's too much. Also it looks really dumb when people re-draw their eyebrows after ripping them out, like, just leave them alone what are you doing
Thats a very personal question. I personally detest it on MY girl.. i like the Au Naturale look. i mean light make up is fine.. but keep it close to natural. no weird colors. many guys like make up but that is just because we are visual creatures. I like seeing fancy make up on girls... but just not MY girl.
I don't hate makeup, but I prefer natural. Some makeup is good especially if it's about the eyes, but when you start looking like a doll, or totally different from who you really are... then that's a huge turn-off. You're not only lying to the guy with a "fake" face, but you're also showing you lack confidence on yourself, and guys hate that.
It's fine one way or the other. I don't have any strong feelings about it. Probably the same girl will look better with makeup than without it. But I can't see the effort in putting it on being worth it most of the time.
Guys sometimes say: I like it when a girl has no make-up on, like Kim Kardashian.. They don't know what they're talking about... most girls just suck at doing their make-up though, that can never be an improvement