Guys always say they prefer a girl with natural makeup, but I RARELY see them follow through with that. As long as it's not over the top, I don't think they mind. However, when they have to drag their girl out of the door while she's clutching a mascara wand, I think that's when they get annoyed.
The ones in the pictures wouldn't be bad if the lashes weren't so dramatic. Also, in the second pic the eyes + lips together are just too much. The rule of thumb is heavy eye makeup OR dramatic lips, but never both at the same time, even in the evening.
The first one looks kind of creepy to me. Like, waaaay too much makeup. I say that makeup is great in general but only if it's a little bit and is well-done. Going too far basically blocks the view of her real beauty.