This is just out of curiosity, I'm not saying you're shallow if you think girls look better with it because it's your own opinion. Personally I'm not overly bothered, I wouldn't die if I didn't have any makeup but I feel a lot more confident with it on, and I certainly wouldn't judge someone because they didn't wear it. I normally wear foundation, some powder, eyeliner and mascara, so I really dont over do it. For God's sake, my makeup routine takes 5 minutes at the very most. What about eyeliner? If I have more than 2 minutes I generally try winged eyeliner, and go for the cat eye look. Do guys like this or is it overdoing it?
I prefer a natural look, put a little on by all means but don't hide yourself behind it, most guys would probably think you look better without it. Personally I hate bright lipstick and foundation that looks like u put it on with a shovel and ur orange from it
If you meet and someone and the first impression is "Makeup. Makeup everywhere" you've gone too far. in my opinion girls look better with just a little makeup. I want to see the girls face, not a layer of cake on a face. It sounds like you have about the right amount of make up anyway. I'd go with whatever you feel the most comfortable with. Chances are the guy will agree.