Cute eyes are by far my biggest weakness. Bat your eyes at me and look at me sad and you can get me to do just about anything. So yes, I am drawn into a girl a lot by her eyes.
And also I don't feel as though I need "the hottest girl out there" to be drawn to her. She can just be averagely cute, and if she's got something special about her, then I'll be drawn to her regardless. Because that 'spark' is more important than anything else.