I have heard that quite a few times already from girls. I think generally speaking with make-up you are "objectively" more attractive - which the other women mention. Being actually attracted to someone though is more than just a nice face - but also what you radiate and when you have lots of make-up on you, you radiate a sense of elusiveness by hiding behind a mask.
I don't wear much make up anyways on daily basis, my face doesn't take huge amounts of make up well... But I do get more attention with make up even though I don't think I need much since my skin is okay and my eyebrows are naturally dark and full, so I don't need much.. But my lips tend to be a bit pale, so some lipstick makes a hug difference, and eyeliner+ Mascara to make the eyes pop!
The max amount of make-up I wear still looks relatively natural, so I don't know how much attention I'd get if I wore "lots," but I get more when I'm wearing some. I'm willing to bet you're very pretty, so you hit that great balance of looking beautiful -and- natural, which is what seems to be most preferable. Woo!
I get more attention when I wear makeup. Though, your poll is not that accurate. On everyday basis, I do wear what some could consider a lot of makeup. Yet, people think I wear almost nothing. It's really nude but it's there
If I wear more than I would on a day-to-day basis such as playing up my eyes or whatever, from past experience some guys have been more overt when showing interest -- but guys who I'm aquanintenced with, so who I barely know. Whileas every day (really light makeup), I don't think anyone would do that. So only guys who I know well (closer to friends) would approach me in that way.
No makeup, I don't need it, it's not healthy anyway.
I always wear makeup when I go out I look majorly washed out without it. I probably get more attention when its a bit heavier but only because that generally means I'm at a party, club, etc. I'd say even between light and heavy