Girls, long hair or short hair on guys.. my example?

Ok so I have experimented with hairstyles. Basically people tell me (girls and guys) that I look nicer with longish-layered-shaggy hair. Girls say I look cute (sometimes lol) but some people say I look beter with shorter hair. I gained some weight due to taking some medications but now I am losing it again. I think that with shorter hair my face looks puffy and fat. What do you think? So this is me with longish hair:

Girls, long hair or short hair on example?

me with short hair:


What Girls Said 3