If they have an average looking facial structure. And think of an "average" body as the starting point, and a very fit / ideal one as an "attractive body". I'm talking about the difference between average and ideal, not between totally unattractive and ideal. How much does it make a difference to you?
Below a certain threshold level of bodyfat, almost *any* man's face will look ruggedly attractive. "Traditional handsomeness" does nothing for me -- indeed, few things dry me up faster than a boy who's prettier than me -- so, yeah.
To me, a average face and a nice body will get you a rating of slightly above average. Personally, I really care about the face. A amazing face and not nice body would put you at average. But if you get your body right then your about to hot as hell.