Most Helpful Guy
I like the darker one more, although the lighting on the second pic may make the bright red look more blindingly bright than it really is1
Most Helpful Girl
I think both dresses are really pretty. They both convey a different message and are both suited for different seasons.
The lighter one would be better for the current season, and it definitely is cute and has its own charm.
But I'm a sucker for dark wine colors, so, I would have to choose that one-plus, I love the ruffle thing on the front :)1