I have always been more attracted to girls who are fashionable. Not fashionable in a very formal way all the time but dresses nice casually as well. I like a girl who will wear nice dresses and things like that for formal occasions. But when dressing casually she will wear a nice pair of jeans and a nice shirt, Or maybe a more casual dress, or a skirt, or shorts. I also like it when girls wear black leather. like a leather jacket, or leather pants, or leather skirt. I think a leather jacket especially adds a little bit of edge to a girls outfit that can go along with a nice colorful dress.
As for makeup, I love the the natural look best. The same reason I love hair long and hanging down with no braids or anything. As for clothes, probably anything simple and pretty. Nothing terribly sexual. I also think high heels and tights look silly.