I love thick girls. Curvy, Thunder thighs, big booty, nice sized calves. I dont mind if her boobs aren't big. I'm a leg and butt guy anyways. But I dont mean thick as in fat although I don't mind some gut/ belly. she can be "slim thick" or thick with a little bit of fat. But there's a limit. If you look a Iskra Lawrence or Ashley Graham, thats what I like. But to be honest, any girl with a decent amount of meat on her bones thats not obese will do for me. Like Salma Hayek, Rachel Mcadams, or Halle Berry for example.
Both can have their charms, honestly. Occasionally I get these moments where I really feel like wanting to have sex with a skinny girl and choke her out, then I can shift in the polar opposite direction.
If I had to say which I PREFER though, probably the curvier girl, if her weight has distributed correctly.