The question is in the title. Please say why also! And be honest!
Most Helpful Guy
A healthy mix of the two. Obviously if she is caking on the makeup to cover up her features, it's going to hide who she truly is. We would be seeing makeup and not the real her. But if she has something that she is self-conscious about, and makeup helps her feel more comfortable, that will help her feel more at ease when around in public; which is very attractive when a girl can remain relaxed.
Pertaining SOLEY to physical appearance, I would have to go for Acne products over makeup. I don't think that people should cover up natural beauty.