As a 17-years-old senior, I can easily say that I would prefer seeing no make-up at all. I think a girl doesn't need make-up to look sexy. In fact, I believe that the natural look is the prettiest look of all.
Plus, make-up can sometimes (not always, but sometimes) be the sign of insecurity (The "I'm too ugly to go to school wihout make-up." syndrome)
But, this is just me. I don't know about the rest of the world population.
What Girls Said 1
if anything guys in hs likes girls with makeup because they are all about looks in hs