I don't want to be cliche though. I want it to be cute. I want to be a bit straightforward and surprise him a little. What should I say?
Most Helpful Guy
Just walk up to him and say "I like you". Simple. All that touchy feely crap, and mind games is never as effective as directly telling a person how you feel. If you tell him you like him, he will probably already be surprised because I can probably guarantee that nobody told him that before.1