I wish I could choose average weight with abs :D but that's not the point of this... hmm well if I had to choose out of these three I would pick chubby because skinny is just so I don't know... it's not bad but when I think of skinny I think of bones and just I don't know. So I choose chubby its cuddly!
I would have to say all three in a way because I don't want a really fat guy but I want him to have meat on his bones (enough so that he looks healthy and is at a healthy weight for his height and build) definitely not too skinny because that doesn't seem attractive to me but skinny in the sense that he is healthy to his height and build. and then of course muscular enough for his height and build (some guys don't try enough and others go overboard)
Depends what you mean by extremely muscular...Cause if you mean those scary buff guys with their vains bulging...NO. But if you mean like Taylor Lautner muscular, then yes! Haha, and if not, skinny I guess.
Well I personally really like tall guys, and tall guys who are skinny look funny. The best looking guys I've seen have been tall with a little bit of chub. Everyone has their own opinions though, and there's someone to love every type of body!
There's multiple situations with multiple options..
Girls that are "only after sex" will typically want that muscular meathead.
Girls that are looking for a cuddle buddy, but no immediate sex or relationship, will look for a chubby person.
Each person has their own "Real preference" but those are the generalizations. By real preference, I mean some "type" that they take to more-so than the others, for any number of reasons. As with most my answers, there will always be exceptions to these generalizations because not "everyone" follows the same cookie-cutter outcome.
What I can tell you, is that it makes a huge difference as to what type of personality you have in regards to how women choose you. It's not so much as towards what you "look like" but more-so on how you make them feel. Men on the other hand, are highly "visual" creatures.. We feel with our eyes in sense ;D..
Where's the option for the proportionate, athletic but not bodybuilder type body (i.e. a V-shaped torso, broad shoulders, chest, arms, with good muscle relief but not every vein popping or crazy muscles)? My understanding is this is more or less what most girls, who are themselves in shape, like. Or am I wrong, girls?
Mind if I ask why skinny and chubby stand equal with "extremely muscular"? The percentage of the population that would qualify for "extremely muscular" is counted in the permilles, not the percents, whereas skinny and chubby would easily account for twenty percent each. Why not "very muscular" instead?
Or is this to see to which degree girls would choose brawny over bony?