I used to think that Goths were "different" and unique and what not, but when you get a bit older you see the Goth scene is just as exclusionary and just as elitist as any other "scene". Just a group of people trying to be "different" by being the same as everyone else in their clique. It stopped being interesting in the mid 90s.
I prefer people that don't have enough time on their hands that they're trying make a statement through their clothing and makeup.
I think its attractive if done right, too much of anything can be a no go lol, this one time at a train station there was this goth girl sitting on a bench, I was standing near her and then we locked eyes for a solid like 5 seconds. Both of us never said anything, I was just awed by her eyes lol, they were dark brown and had really nice eye liner and stuff, she was really attractive to me... I guess its just really different to be goth where I'm from, so yes like any other person goth style people can be equally as attractive