Different strokes for different folks. Many guys like the classic girlie look and that has the universal "appeal" but I know guys who like the more punk rock look, and some guys like more athletic girls or girls who are very loud and aggressive in a slightly unfeminine way.
it doesn't really matter to me, some girls are overbearingly girlie though, if you know what I mean and it's a little annoying, girls that aren't really really girlie though are usually more fun to hang out with though, I once dated a girl who's favorite hobby was target shooting, you could never tell by looking at her, but I thought that was really awesome, so not all guys like super feminine girls.
Not me because I have it in my head that MOST of them are boring as heck. IF I'm even in a conversation with one, I tend to think about more interesting things like my K/D ratio or or or how should I EV train my Jellicent on Pokemon Black.
Maybe if one kept picking on me in a mean but playful manner, I might fall for her. Otherwise, I'm looking at the tomboys.