As a guy into eyes, I'd have to say the color is not all that important.
I will say however, I've seen some amazing blue eyes that were beautiful. I'll note this was looking into the person's eyes, my dental hygienist , so it wouldn't be something you could see just looking at a person.
But I wouldn't pick a girl based on her eye color. It's more the look of her eye and the shape.
Sorry if this doesn't exactly answer your question.
it depends on the face. light hair and blue eyes isn't spectacular because it's common. but dark hair and blue eyes is stunning! but I always love green, hazel, and light brown eyes. and there's nothing wrong with dark brown.