I don't care about a girl's nails/hair/whatever. That's not even a consideration unless it's really gawdy and then it's a negative. If you ever hear a guy go "Wow those nails are awesome!" he's probably gay. I guess those frito-looking fake nails are a turn off, and watching people with them try to do everyday things like write, use a phone, or push a button to call an elevator is truly a forehead smacking moment.
It is way more important that a girl's overall look matches the way that she carries herself. Otherwise, she'll always seem phony to the guys that pay attention.
I don't care about nails..guess I would prefer natural and natural color...but my wife paints on occaision and I don't care...fake don't seem very practical though...I have a friend that said he thought painted toes & nails made a woman look like a whore...but I don't feel that way
personally my ex loved my solar nails he loved that I got my toes pained and that I was always groomed, He just naged me about always going to the nail salon but it was more of a joke that real nagging cause he was always keeping himself groomed to. to each their own I guess