I don't like the style, not the kind of femininity I like. Same as long fingernails. I very much prefer a girl in jeans and sneakers any day.
And don't get me wrong, it's got nothing to do with the girl being taller than me or not. My first girlfriend was 180cm (5 ft. 10), a bit taller than me. I somehow never thought about it. Now I'm with a girl way smaller - wouldn't want her to wear high heels either. Glad she doesn't like it.
Makeup: Not too much either. I like natural looks. Mascara is okay, not necessary. Eyeshadow, hmm... rarely I see someone where I like it. Lipstick: please not.
Long hair/short hair depends on the girl - both can look really good.
Favourite eye color: Not possible to say. I always used to think I was into brown eyes. And the few girls I was with all had beautiful blue or almost greenish eyes.
Down there: Hairy. I like it. :P The girls I've been with were not even trimmed. Some Americans might cry out "disgusting" now maybe? Not at all, I say. All a matter of taste. Legs I prefer shaved though ;)
Not feminine enough? For me: yes. The curves stay the same, no matter the style or how much you show them at once.
all of them can be a turn on. I used to say that I would never sleep with a woman who had shorter hair than me, until I met one who had such a delightful sweet nature, that I did not even notice the short hair!
Heels are nice!
Minimal make up is nice!
Bare or hairy does not matter, but not so bushy that it looks like it needs a brushcutter to trim!
All eyes with a bit of color - hard to read black eyes!
Looks mean a lot when you are young, but as I got older, looks didn't matter as much as whether I liked them or not!
High heels, not a turn off. Although I will admit I get slightly ...i don't know, uneasy because I'm only like 5'7'' and usually women don't like to be taller than the guy so I end up feeling uneasy about it because she might not like being taller than me. Other wise I wouldn't care.
Make up is fine just not a whole lot to where your face looks fake or like you're wearing a mask.
Long hair or short, it depends on what looks good on you. A lot of guys say "oh no, girls with short hair look like guys." I think that's completely retarded, I've seem plenty of girls who look VERY sexy with short hair.
If you're going to have hair down there, make sure it's well trimmed and clean.
I have no preference on eye color because you can't change it. If you have a unique eye color then awesome, but if not I wouldn't care.