Love Charlotte russe! And it depends on what look your going for. First is variable. You could dress up some casual clothing or complement formal clothing really well and it'd be a great pop for your outfit because of the color. Two is more rocker chic casual. Itd be harder to dress up but you could easily wear it with many different types of casual outfits. The third is very elegant and formal. It'd be harder to dress this one down but it'd be very complementary with a formal dress. Ultimately I think the red heels are the most versatile but for my personal style I think I veer a little more towards the booties.
I think it's a choice between link 2 and the update link. Depends to what occasion you plan to wear them to. If it's pretty casual, the second link is an excellent choice. If you're planning to dress up a bit, I think the updated link fits that category.