Yes, done right, on the right girl, it can look attractive, but it always looks like a LOT of eye makeup, and that always screams to me "trying too hard" and "hiding behind a mask." Other people have said "only for special occasions", and I agree; sometimes it's fun to put on a mask and be different, and that's fine. But if you're doing that much every day, I'm going to wonder why you are afraid to be seen as yourself.
Those special occasions (possibly) aside, when it comes to make-up, less is more.
Well, I voted B but can't really tell if other guys hate it or not. I can't generalize after all. But I can tell that I hate it. It's not going to change the way I think about a girl, but I do not like the winged eyes.
so far its a 50/50 for guys and girls seem to like it on themselves lol.
It can look nice or rather hot, but as long as you are not drawing wings that would allow you to fly to Europe. Some girls really make them too large and it's not nice anymore, If it remains kind of light (like for the Asian girl) yeah it looks pretty.
So it all depends on your skills and how you make them on yourself I'd say.
I don't think any guy thinks "OMG her winged makeup is spectacular!", but we appreciate women who look good and part of that is knowing how to enhance your face with make up. One form of make up is going to be much the same as another for a guy.
It's really attractive when attention is not being drawn to it. For example using a different color or a really bold line instead of a thin one. The first link is as far as I would find attractive. Anything more is too much.
The firat girl is ao pretty that whatever she does, the reat of the face will distract you. The second one is also OK but I watched Demi Lavato do it a lot in X Factor and it would look terrble with her.
personally it depends on the subject. It may work on some girls but not others, and of course, I will like it if its on a cute girl but if shed look better without it then you know the answer. some guys appreciate fashion, but this is makeup and it can always be avoided
I wear my eyeliner where the top is rounded and arched instead of a straight wing. I got complimented by a creepy Batman yesterday who worked as a doppleganger for photos in front of the Chinese Theater.
I had one guy a year ago that told me to wear eyeliner because it makes me look hot.
Obviously the first link is beautiful, it's Diana Agron. But the second link isn't attractive. I think that if you're going to wear eyeliner, you should wear mascara as well. It makes your eyes look less beady.