A girl needs to look beautiful naturally. Without makeup. A little is okay, but having her entire face or body covered in all that powder, ink, and whatever else makeup is made of totally destroys the beauty of the body. It's like creating a fake skin-cover. I prefer real girls.
B is better given the two options definitely. No one likes a fake. But unfortunately I always see the made up girls with the guys in real life. It's always them who get called hot and beautiful despite them wearing make up so clearly it doesn't put guys off as much as some on here claim to. It's tough to please everyone. Like even in my group of friends it's the same story. The ones who never wear make up are all single and have been all their life. The ones who do wear make up get attention, have had boyfriends and gets flirted with. Few girls are blessed enough to get to rock the no make up look and get attention at the same time. It also is possible to wear make up and still look good without wearing it. It's a awful stigma that girls who wear make up are either insecure or look ugly without it. Some do but for a lot it's not the case. I think I look great without make up (sorry if I sound vain, this is not my point) but I still wear make up cause I enjoy putting it on and trying new things. It's fun for me and not a chore. I also like showing that I take care of myself as well and spend time on my appearance.